Best Buy - best business model?
Best Buy - best business model?
Author
Discussion

V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
LadyV8 said that she'd buy me a new camera for Christmas and, after lots of research, I decided on the model I wanted and had a pretty good idea what the best price in the market was.

We were in the Lakeside area today, so I suggested that we pop in to Best Buy to see if, maybe, they were any cheaper. Neither of us had visited their store before, so we felt it might be doubly worthwhile. (They are only just starting online selling, so I hadn't been able to research their prices)

We found the camera but they were selling it for £50 more than modal market price and £55 more than the best price I had found last time I looked (4 or 5 weeks ago).

Assistant appears on cue and asks if we need any help. I tell him that I really like the camera but have seen it much cheaper elsewhere. Another customer overhears me and says he has seen it even cheaper than the price I quoted. "No problem", says assistant, "we'll price match and give you 10% of the difference on top".

So, I send him off to get his best price and, indeed, he comes back with a price £88 lower than marked on the shelf.

But I wonder - and here is my query on their business model - how many people take one look at the price on the shelf edge and make for the door? Why call yourself 'Best Buy' if, on the face of it, you are not and need to be challenged before you are?

I have no gripe with BB - the final total (as they also had a separate promotion running on memory cards purchased at the same time as cameras) smashed anything else in the market - but why would they risk alienating customers who weren't so bold, especially given their brand name? Haggling in PC World, Currys, Comet etc is pretty much impossible on regular stock, so it's not really within the mindset of UK shoppers to behave in that way in such stores.

Very strange.


Crafty_

14,231 posts

231 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
I don't see its any different from any other store. High Street is often more expensive.

Would it make any difference if they were called "Acme electronics" ?

Its just a name at the end of the day, its actually part owned by Best Buy US and Carphone Warehouse.


TVR Sagaris

1,455 posts

263 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
You're assuming people research these things before they get to the shop. There will probably be lots of people who believe Best Buy is cheap and will go straight there for a camera, without investigating competitors' prices.

Shaw Tarse

31,904 posts

234 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
Currys will also price match, plus 10% (or at least they used to)

sinizter

3,348 posts

217 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
Shaw Tarse said:
Currys will also price match, plus 10% (or at least they used to)
But you would have to interact with the ignorant cretins. (There are some good people working there, who know their stuff, but generally ...)

Crafty_

14,231 posts

231 months

Saturday 6th November 2010
quotequote all
TVR Sagaris said:
You're assuming people research these things before they get to the shop. There will probably be lots of people who believe Best Buy is cheap and will go straight there for a camera, without investigating competitors' prices.
But why single out best buy, they aren't any different...

H_Kan

4,942 posts

230 months

Sunday 7th November 2010
quotequote all
From what I understood, I thought these guys were big on customer service/ product knowledge not just price.

Also, it's not haggling as such, they are just applying their price match policy, which incidentally Currys has as well. In any case, this camera may have been over priced, but they may be more competitive on other items.

wiffmaster

2,622 posts

229 months

Sunday 7th November 2010
quotequote all
Seems like a great business model, as you get the best of both worlds. Firstly, you get the non-savvy market who just pay the sticker price and don't shop around online, and you get the savvy market as well. I reckon the non-savvy market is by far the larger, and I assume that even with the price match and additional 10% off, they're still going to be making a slim margin. They're huge in the US, so they must know it's a proven model.

V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Sunday 7th November 2010
quotequote all
wiffmaster said:
Seems like a great business model, as you get the best of both worlds. Firstly, you get the non-savvy market who just pay the sticker price and don't shop around online, and you get the savvy market as well. I reckon the non-savvy market is by far the larger, and I assume that even with the price match and additional 10% off, they're still going to be making a slim margin. They're huge in the US, so they must know it's a proven model.
But you're missing one dimension: The savvy market - people who do a bit of research - but who aren't minded to 'demand satisfaction'.

These people will walk and never return. They'll think that the business model is to be expensive on everything apart from a few well advertised promotional lines/loss leaders.

Silver993tt

9,064 posts

270 months

Sunday 7th November 2010
quotequote all
TVR Sagaris said:
You're assuming people research these things before they get to the shop. There will probably be lots of people who believe Best Buy is cheap and will go straight there for a camera, without investigating competitors' prices.
exactly, just as many people buy flights on Ryan Air assumingthey are the cheapest because of all the marketing hype, or the same with John Lewis who are regularly undersold and refuse to price match for all sorts of made up reasons.

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Sunday 7th November 2010
quotequote all
Exactly the same buisiness model that allows e-bay shops to sell items above shop prices, people see the hype about the cheapest source and don't question it. I admit I am currently very tight with my cash and will spend a stupid amount of time researching the best price and generally end up buying online.

jeff m

4,066 posts

289 months

Sunday 7th November 2010
quotequote all
I would guess they were matching another stores loss leader.

Best Buy as a business model....I would say they get a lot right. In the States they employ excellent staff who seem to have the "need any help" approach just right. They are non commisioned and know their products very well.

Simpo Two

93,101 posts

296 months

Sunday 7th November 2010
quotequote all
V8mate said:
Why call yourself 'Best Buy' if, on the face of it, you are not and need to be challenged before you are?
I can think of several reasons:

Because some people will be fooled by the name and buy without checking.

Because many people are embarassed to haggle.

Because some people think that by paying a little more they're going to get better service/backup if it breaks (the 'BT/BG effect').

Because if the store offered its (real) lowest price on everything they would lose too much margin.

Because they know some people, inspired by the internet and that Iranian comic Al-jwotsit, will try to haggle them down so they have to start higher. I suspect many 'hagglers' are less interested in the actual price but feel that getting £10 knocked off is a victory and makes them feel better.



Turn it round. When you quote for work, do you quote the very lowest you are prepared to work for, or what you would actually like to receive?

Edited by Simpo Two on Sunday 7th November 13:03

whythem

773 posts

208 months

Sunday 7th November 2010
quotequote all
The biggest advantage a bricks and morter retailer has over the online retailer is for the customer to walk away with the product immediately, without having to wait for delivery. Coupled with live hopefully knowledgeable sales staff.

Bricks and morter retailers without a price match guarantee must spenad an awfull lot of time, demonstrating products, only for the customer to walk out and then buy online at a cheaper price.

Price matching creates some extra T/O for the retailer, but probably has just as much value as being something to market and attract attention to the brand.

XB70

2,494 posts

227 months

Sunday 7th November 2010
quotequote all
whythem said:
The biggest advantage a bricks and morter retailer has over the online retailer is for the customer to walk away with the product immediately, without having to wait for delivery. Coupled with live hopefully knowledgeable sales staff.

Bricks and morter retailers without a price match guarantee must spenad an awfull lot of time, demonstrating products, only for the customer to walk out and then buy online at a cheaper price.

Price matching creates some extra T/O for the retailer, but probably has just as much value as being something to market and attract attention to the brand.
Or buy instore using the internet on a phone.

dreamz

5,299 posts

224 months

Monday 8th November 2010
quotequote all
Shaw Tarse said:
Currys will also price match, plus 10% (or at least they used to)
there's a list of about 10-15 stores they price match with - they dont price match with just any one