Paying phone insurance for 7 years....
Discussion

Just found out Carphone Warehouse have been DDing my account £35 a quarter for the last 7 years!!!
Admittedly I did agree to the original contract but didn't appreciate it would run indefinitely!! Bought in 2008 and got rid in 2010 and they still take the payments for another 5 years! A lot of exclamation marks I know but I am really surprised this is allowed and it appears the regulations have since been tightened up to stop it going on.
Upshot is that they have at least responded swiftly and will be crediting me back the 5 years since I moved on. But I thought I would post this up in case anyone else is still unwittingly paying insurance for a phone they no longer have. I know phone insurance is b
ks so I'm unsure why I went for it back then but hey ho... cool story etc...Moral of the story = review your Direct Debits!
DanielSan said:
I used to work for them and the amount of people who forget to cancel insurance is frightening. One good thing is I never saw a case where the didn't refund it when a long period had elapsed like yours.
They certainly seemed very keen to close the complaint, no quibbling at all. I can only assume the regulator is breathing down their neck on this one...TwigtheWonderkid said:
If someone tried to take £35 out of my account that I didn't want taken out, I'd notice at the end of the 1st month it was taken out. How anyone can let £700 be taken over 5 years and not cotton on is beyond my comprehension.
Without wishing to sound all powerfully directorial it represents a tiny fraction of the accounts outflow so not really noticeable. Coupled with the fact that it was quarterly meant the odd check I carry out didn't fall on that month.DoubleSix said:
Apparently new agreements have a maximum life of 5 years.
I can't say that's wrong, but there's no mention of that at a brief scan of the DD website. I've got one on my desk to do and there's no comment on that about its life.Arguably it's a bad thing - if yours had just stopped, and they didn't contact you, you'd probably never have known they'd been taking the debits.
DoubleSix said:
TwigtheWonderkid said:
If someone tried to take £35 out of my account that I didn't want taken out, I'd notice at the end of the 1st month it was taken out. How anyone can let £700 be taken over 5 years and not cotton on is beyond my comprehension.
Without wishing to sound all powerfully directorial it represents a tiny fraction of the accounts outflow so not really noticeable. Coupled with the fact that it was quarterly meant the odd check I carry out didn't fall on that month.Sheepshanks said:
DoubleSix said:
Apparently new agreements have a maximum life of 5 years.
I can't say that's wrong, but there's no mention of that at a brief scan of the DD website. I've got one on my desk to do and there's no comment on that about its life.Arguably it's a bad thing - if yours had just stopped, and they didn't contact you, you'd probably never have known they'd been taking the debits.
Rather, the young lady at the insurance company explained that these insurance agreements now have a maximum term of 5 years to avoid the situation I got caught out by. A quick Google shows that to be correct.
Still, most people dont keep their phone for 5 years so need to be aware to cancel on replacement.
DoubleSix said:
They certainly seemed very keen to close the complaint, no quibbling at all. I can only assume the regulator is breathing down their neck on this one...
It's easy to spot a genuine mistake with stiff like that, and that amount of time it's pretty obvious what's happened. Always easier just to do the refund than the hassle of dealing with the complainants and everything that goes with it. I had similar one with P4U a while ago on a policy in my dad's name. Exactly same thing, had been going out for 3-4 years. They just said they'd refund i, no quibble or anything.
DoubleSix said:
Wasn't talking about DDs which are of course perpetual for obvious reasons.
Rather, the young lady at the insurance company explained that these insurance agreements now have a maximum term of 5 years to avoid the situation I got caught out by. A quick Google shows that to be correct.
Still, most people dont keep their phone for 5 years so need to be aware to cancel on replacement.
Ah, I see. The same thing applies though - if you got past the point where it just stopped you'd probably never then pick up the past debits.Rather, the young lady at the insurance company explained that these insurance agreements now have a maximum term of 5 years to avoid the situation I got caught out by. A quick Google shows that to be correct.
Still, most people dont keep their phone for 5 years so need to be aware to cancel on replacement.
Do a lot of people buy 'phone insurance anyway? I always thought it was a bit of a scam.
Sheepshanks said:
Ah, I see. The same thing applies though - if you got past the point where it just stopped you'd probably never then pick up the past debits.
Do a lot of people buy 'phone insurance anyway? I always thought it was a bit of a scam.
Indeed. I never opt for phone insurance so initially figured it had been applied fraudulantly but they were able to produce the contract so.... Do a lot of people buy 'phone insurance anyway? I always thought it was a bit of a scam.

LordGrover said:
I'm somewhat surprised when people don't check their statements regularly. It doesn't take a couple of minutes to scan the transactions. I've never had anything substantial, but over the years I've spotted erroneous debits by amazon, paypal, even the bank itself.
I had this from Greenflag after i phoned to change cover to my new car, only to be told it expired 4 years previously. The woman on the phone asked why i hadn't noticed the money being taken every month. I pointed out that £8 a month is somewhat easy to overlookGassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


