Netgear Orbi??
Author
Discussion

W8PMC

Original Poster:

3,385 posts

269 months

Tuesday 3rd January 2017
quotequote all
Looking for solutions to our terrible WiFi availability throughout the house & stumbled across the Orbi before Xmas.

Given i'm now getting sick & tired of the poor coverage in our house i'm looking to change to what i hope would be a more far reaching & stable solution. Has anyone any experience of the Orbi before i chuck £400 at this solution only to find it doesn't improve anything?

Current setup is an Openreach DSL Modem with a Nighthawk 7500 wifi router & Netgear extender upstairs (this offers 2 further access points for devices upstairs).

W8PMC

Original Poster:

3,385 posts

269 months

Friday 6th January 2017
quotequote all
I guess not. Did expect a few on here would have the system as it's been out a few months now so not sure if the fact they don't is a bad sign.

The online reviews look positive but wanted a more realistic opinion before pumping £400 into a solution that may not improve on my current setup.

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Friday 6th January 2017
quotequote all
There's more folks on here using the Ubiquiti stuff. Same sort of idea, but less funky design, and more enterprise features.

W8PMC

Original Poster:

3,385 posts

269 months

Wednesday 18th January 2017
quotequote all
Took delivery of the Netgear Orbi 2 unit system yesterday & it's transformed coverage throughout our house. Everything appears quicker but more importantly devices are connected throughout the house with no loss of signal.

Far better than the Nighthawk X4 7500 & Extender solution i was running before.

AC43

13,728 posts

239 months

Friday 11th May 2018
quotequote all
W8PMC said:
Took delivery of the Netgear Orbi 2 unit system yesterday & it's transformed coverage throughout our house. Everything appears quicker but more importantly devices are connected throughout the house with no loss of signal.

Far better than the Nighthawk X4 7500 & Extender solution i was running before.
Having tried and given up on wifi extenders and IP over powerline solutions I took delivery of an Orbi and 2 x extenders yesterday.

First impressions are very good.

Pro's; Full speed internet throughout the house, seamlessly.

Con's; Not cheap, large units.

Overall, removes a lot of ballache.

w8pmc

Original Poster:

3,385 posts

269 months

Friday 11th May 2018
quotequote all
AC43 said:
Having tried and given up on wifi extenders and IP over powerline solutions I took delivery of an Orbi and 2 x extenders yesterday.

First impressions are very good.

Pro's; Full speed internet throughout the house, seamlessly.

Con's; Not cheap, large units.

Overall, removes a lot of ballache.
They do make life so much easier, however i'm now suffering connectivity issues between the Satellite units which is frustrating as 80% of the time we have no problem, but for 20% of the time, one or 2 of them will drop out.

As daft as it sounds, we've no power sockets in more central locations within the house, so the Main unit is front right of the house, 1st satellite is back left with another upstairs in a bedroom which is fairly central & the last at the very back of the house to give coverage in the Sun Lounge & back garden. I'm still trying to work out where i can move them too & improve connectivity.

That said, the key offending item that we needed improved connectivity was Sky Q at the front & rear of the house & that now works perfectly.

AC43

13,728 posts

239 months

Friday 11th May 2018
quotequote all
w8pmc said:
AC43 said:
Having tried and given up on wifi extenders and IP over powerline solutions I took delivery of an Orbi and 2 x extenders yesterday.

First impressions are very good.

Pro's; Full speed internet throughout the house, seamlessly.

Con's; Not cheap, large units.

Overall, removes a lot of ballache.
They do make life so much easier, however i'm now suffering connectivity issues between the Satellite units which is frustrating as 80% of the time we have no problem, but for 20% of the time, one or 2 of them will drop out.

As daft as it sounds, we've no power sockets in more central locations within the house, so the Main unit is front right of the house, 1st satellite is back left with another upstairs in a bedroom which is fairly central & the last at the very back of the house to give coverage in the Sun Lounge & back garden. I'm still trying to work out where i can move them too & improve connectivity.

That said, the key offending item that we needed improved connectivity was Sky Q at the front & rear of the house & that now works perfectly.
Yeah I found getting the positions right a little tricky too. The layout is a bid odd in my rental house. It's long front to back downstairs but also very narrow and on three floors. Loads of brick walls.

The base unit has to go by the front door. I've found a socket in one of the bedrooms in the centre to server the first floor. Struggling a little trying to get one to synch to the back of the house in a sensible position

Still, at least I'm just starting on the electrical plan for the new place. I'll be able to position them sensibly in there. Plus I'll be able to cat 5 all the heaviest, stationary points to take some of the load off the wifi network too.

EDIT; latest experiment shows that two are plenty good enough for this 2,000 sq ft house.

The main one at the front of the ground floor and the satellite in the centre of the first floor. The latter bounces signal down through the floor to the rear of the ground floor and of course up into the loft.

The new house will pose some additional challenges. 50% bigger, very dense floors (stuffed with insulation and layered with ply/sound deadening underlay/engineered oak), plenty of steels and some studs with (probably) foil-backed boards.

I'm off to see the builder/sparks/AV guy later to discuss.

Edited by AC43 on Friday 11th May 10:54

jonnyb

2,590 posts

283 months

Friday 11th May 2018
quotequote all
I have just got the BT mesh adaptors, and have been really impressed with them. Only had then a week, but first impressions are very good. They have solved our Wi-fi issues in the snug that all sorts of powerline/extenders failed to do.
If I was building a new house now I would hard wire every room for internet. It’s dead easy from scratch, and you can run Wi-fi access points in the really hard to reach areas.

Bikerjon

2,211 posts

192 months

Friday 11th May 2018
quotequote all
jonnyb said:
I have just got the BT mesh adaptors, and have been really impressed with them. Only had then a week, but first impressions are very good. They have solved our Wi-fi issues in the snug that all sorts of powerline/extenders failed to do.
If I was building a new house now I would hard wire every room for internet. It’s dead easy from scratch, and you can run Wi-fi access points in the really hard to reach areas.
The BT mesh system is very good - a few little hiccups with some of the app/firmware updates but overall an excellent and fast system that mostly comes top of the comparison reviews. I'm actually running this system at the moment and things like band steering work far better for me than the more expensive and pro level Ubiquiti gear (which I also use a lot) I must try the Orbi system soon too as the plug-in extenders look quite neat.

wilbo83

1,552 posts

196 months

Friday 11th May 2018
quotequote all
Great to hear positive reviews, I am currently debating between Orbi RBK40 and the BT system at the moment, likely to go for the Orbi as I like the idea of Tri-band using one 'lane' for the units to talk to each other with no interference.

jonnyb

2,590 posts

283 months

Friday 11th May 2018
quotequote all
I looked at the Orbi RBK53, but couldn’t quite justify the £400 price tag. I don’t game over Wi-fi, that’s hard wired, as is the main TV for 4K streaming.
So the Wi-fi is just for surfing the internet, and the daughters iPad. I think the BT system was a good compromise between price and speed. If I was gaming over Wi-fi then the Orbi or Linksys Velop would be the way to go.

AC43

13,728 posts

239 months

Saturday 12th May 2018
quotequote all
wilbo83 said:
Great to hear positive reviews, I am currently debating between Orbi RBK40 and the BT system at the moment, likely to go for the Orbi as I like the idea of Tri-band using one 'lane' for the units to talk to each other with no interference.
Hmm.....my satellites have dropped out today.....

AC43

13,728 posts

239 months

Saturday 12th May 2018
quotequote all
jonnyb said:
I looked at the Orbi RBK53, but couldn’t quite justify the £400 price tag. I don’t game over Wi-fi, that’s hard wired, as is the main TV for 4K streaming.
So the Wi-fi is just for surfing the internet, and the daughters iPad. I think the BT system was a good compromise between price and speed. If I was gaming over Wi-fi then the Orbi or Linksys Velop would be the way to go.
That's a good point; I'm in a rental and there's no internet access point for the TV/PS4 and yes, that batters the wifi. And the kids constantly stream video to TV's and iPads (again, no access points for the TV). And I've got Spotify fired up a lot,

I went over to the new house yesterday to make sure the sparks puts at least two if not more anywhere there's going to be a TV/amp/console/desk/etc.

Anyway, back to re-synching the satellites....grrrr....


wilbo83

1,552 posts

196 months

Saturday 12th May 2018
quotequote all
AC43 said:
Hmm.....my satellites have dropped out today.....
Any ideas what's causing them to drop out? Just wondered if it's a common thing or something specific. Are you happy with their performance when they don't drop out? On paper, the stats seem so much better than the competition, albeit with a higher price tag.

dhutch

17,963 posts

228 months

Saturday 12th May 2018
quotequote all
AC43 said:
... I'm just starting on the electrical plan for the new place. I'll be able to position them sensibly in there. Plus I'll be able to cat 5 all the heaviest, stationary points to take some of the load off the wifi network too.
I will going to say while your putting in cables,you can't beat a wired network even these days.

Daniel

Dromedary66

1,924 posts

169 months

Saturday 12th May 2018
quotequote all
Very pleased with the RBR40 and one RBW30 satellite in my house. I get consistent transfer speeds of 210 Mbps between machines in different corners and floors of the house. And this is through concrete floors. Haven't needed to use the other RBW30 but nice to know the ability to extend is there.

Previously the Sky Q router could manage 5-10 Mbps on a good day.

Only had it a few weeks but so far so good.

AC43

13,728 posts

239 months

Saturday 12th May 2018
quotequote all
wilbo83 said:
AC43 said:
Hmm.....my satellites have dropped out today.....
Any ideas what's causing them to drop out? Just wondered if it's a common thing or something specific. Are you happy with their performance when they don't drop out? On paper, the stats seem so much better than the competition, albeit with a higher price tag.
I've no idea but I'm not surprised. Of all the online reviews 80% said the Orbi was the best thing ever and other 20% said it was the worst with endless dropouts, etc.

The base station itself is fantastic. It sends out a very powerful signal, way way better than the Virgin router. But, of course, so it should given than ISP routers are usually pretty rubbish.

The problem I and others seem to experience is the difficulty in pairing the base station with satellites and/or keeping the connection.

I managed to get both of min synced yesterday (eventually) but they'd both disconnected themselves when I got up. Tried re-syncing one of them earlier to no avail. I'll have another go today/tomorrow but if that doesn't work they'll be going back and I'll revert to the IP over powerline Devolo's. They also drop out after a while and give me grief but I usually get a few weeks/months out of them before they do it. Not just a few hours....

At the pirce that's just not on.

Podie

46,650 posts

306 months

Saturday 12th May 2018
quotequote all
Been running the BT Mesh since Christmas - replacing Apple Airport Extremes.

Far superior to the Applie kit, and not a single drop out since installation. No coverage black spots either.

AC43

13,728 posts

239 months

Sunday 13th May 2018
quotequote all
Update. All 3 Orbis running fine today. Will keep fiddling about and monitoring them. Really hope they stabilise are they are phenomenal when working properly.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 13th May 2018
quotequote all
I’ve had 1 Orbi router and 2 satellites for about 3 months, there have been no real issues to report back, but coverage across my house and garden is great.

There have been at least two firmware updates, I’ve done these manually rather than the auto update.