OS on 5900 RPM HDD. Any good?
Author
Discussion

Penelope Stoppedit

Original Poster:

11,209 posts

140 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
I have a 5900 RPM HDD that I am considering running an OS on. Is there any point in me trying?
Has anyone here done this?
Thank you in advance

Defcon5

6,479 posts

222 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
ISnt a fairly average HDD 7200rpm?

bitchstewie

68,520 posts

241 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
It'll work.

It'll also be a turd compared to an SSD so it's relative I guess smile

Penelope Stoppedit

Original Poster:

11,209 posts

140 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
Thanks, does this mean it's a no goer?

bitchstewie

68,520 posts

241 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
It means if it's all you have it'll work but it'll be a turd vs. an SSD and SSD's aren't expensive.

If you have the money get an SSD. If you don't you've just got to wait a little longer I guess smile

Funk

27,818 posts

240 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
It'll work, it'll just be really slow. Laptop hard drives were 5900rpm for years until SSD became the norm (5900rpm disks have a lower power draw). With SSDs so cheap, why bother with the older slower disk?

Penelope Stoppedit

Original Poster:

11,209 posts

140 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
OK, thanks for the replies
I have SSD's in two desktops but I never do and never will use an SSD above 120 Gb as I am very unlucky and if an SSD is going to fail without warning it will be one of mine
The 5900 RPM HDD is 2Tb

Brainpox

4,332 posts

182 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
If you stuck to a lightweight Linux distro it would probably be just about bearable.

Anything heavier than that will be painful to use.

Personally I'd use it as a backup drive and not much else.

Penelope Stoppedit

Original Poster:

11,209 posts

140 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
OK, I have been convinced it's not worth it but may go ahead and do it as a test without expecting a good result
I was thinking about installing Debian

bitchstewie

68,520 posts

241 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
Penelope Stoppedit said:
OK, thanks for the replies
I have SSD's in two desktops but I never do and never will use an SSD above 120 Gb as I am very unlucky and if an SSD is going to fail without warning it will be one of mine
The 5900 RPM HDD is 2Tb
Spinning disks can randomly fail too. Just make a backup if it's something important.

Penelope Stoppedit

Original Poster:

11,209 posts

140 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
bhstewie said:
Penelope Stoppedit said:
OK, thanks for the replies
I have SSD's in two desktops but I never do and never will use an SSD above 120 Gb as I am very unlucky and if an SSD is going to fail without warning it will be one of mine
The 5900 RPM HDD is 2Tb
Spinning disks can randomly fail too. Just make a backup if it's something important.
Thanks, point taken

bitchstewie

68,520 posts

241 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
Veeam Endpoint is worth looking into if you need something simple and good.

If it were me I'd go with an SSD for boot and use Veeam to dump a scheduled backup onto the spinning disk.

Penelope Stoppedit

Original Poster:

11,209 posts

140 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
bhstewie said:
Veeam Endpoint is worth looking into if you need something simple and good.

If it were me I'd go with an SSD for boot and use Veeam to dump a scheduled backup onto the spinning disk.
I often feel I am too concerned about breakages when computing, perhaps using a backup software will encourage me to buy bigger SSD's in the future
Thanks for the post's

bitchstewie

68,520 posts

241 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
I don't think you can be too paranoid tbh, well OK I guess you can but most people don't do anything about backup then look rather shocked when they realise their digital life is fked over something they could have done either for free or not a lot of money.

Penelope Stoppedit

Original Poster:

11,209 posts

140 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
bhstewie said:
I don't think you can be too paranoid tbh, well OK I guess you can but most people don't do anything about backup then look rather shocked when they realise their digital life is fked over something they could have done either for free or not a lot of money.
Yes I know what you mean, my partner in crime just fked up a days work, lost forever

Funk

27,818 posts

240 months

Wednesday 25th October 2017
quotequote all
SSDs are, on the whole, very reliable. The issue is that when they die, there's no way of getting anything off them so backups are key. This is easier to do then ever though, with loads of software options or even just cloud syncing using Google or Microsoft.

Penelope Stoppedit

Original Poster:

11,209 posts

140 months

Thursday 26th October 2017
quotequote all
Funk said:
SSDs are, on the whole, very reliable. The issue is that when they die, there's no way of getting anything off them so backups are key. This is easier to do then ever though, with loads of software options or even just cloud syncing using Google or Microsoft.
OK I will try a bigger SSD in the future, but knowing my luck.....

TonyRPH

13,552 posts

199 months

Friday 27th October 2017
quotequote all
The 5900 RPM drive will be fine.

One of the companies I do IT work for insist on running 'all in one' PCs with basic drives* (they won't buy an SSD for them!!), and although they are slow to boot, once running they are ok (this with Windows 10).

  • these range from 320GB to 1TB drives - all 5900 RPM as far as I know.

maffski

1,905 posts

190 months

Friday 27th October 2017
quotequote all
It will be absolutely fine. Yes a little slower than SSD but depending on the rest of the hardware the difference will be somewhere between barely noticeable and non existent.

Penelope Stoppedit

Original Poster:

11,209 posts

140 months

Friday 27th October 2017
quotequote all
TonyRPH said:
The 5900 RPM drive will be fine.

One of the companies I do IT work for insist on running 'all in one' PCs with basic drives* (they won't buy an SSD for them!!), and although they are slow to boot, once running they are ok (this with Windows 10).

  • these range from 320GB to 1TB drives - all 5900 RPM as far as I know.
maffski said:
It will be absolutely fine. Yes a little slower than SSD but depending on the rest of the hardware the difference will be somewhere between barely noticeable and non existent.
My thanks go out to the both of you as they already have done to those that give it a "Slow Slow Slow"
This could be the start of a great debate

Without sounding rude towards the "Slowers" - Will you kindly give a liitle more detail about how slow?
There are 2 posts above this one that state this is a goer and the first one is of hands on experience whereas the second one does seem to come from someone with much confidence in it being a goer

Thank you to everyone that's given their opinion

Too much Slower or Goer, that is the question


Edited by Penelope Stoppedit on Friday 27th October 17:16