Mesh Networks / whole home wi-fi
Mesh Networks / whole home wi-fi
Author
Discussion

beedj

Original Poster:

485 posts

244 months

Wednesday 6th June 2018
quotequote all
I need to fix various issues with deadspots in my house and inability to create guest network with my existing powerline/homeplugs (also limited as I have two separate distribution boards).

Spent a few hours looking at Mesh options , think I've narrowed it down to one of

My house is two-storey, long (c.30m) with several (300 year old) solid internal walls, and the incoming telephone line is close to one end so I think I'll need a three-unit system and one that is true-mesh - ie. third unit talks to second (daisy chain) rather than only to base unit (hub/spoke)

Think I've narrowed it down to the NETGEAR Orbi RBK23 or TP-LINK Deco M5 - both in the £200-250 price range. There's a higher spec Orbi RBK53 but £400 and I'm not sure if it gives me anything more than higher speeds - I only get c.10Mb into the house (rural area) so not sure I'd get any benefit

Reading this back it sounds like I know what I'm talking about - not really, all gleaned from an hour or two on google & amazon etc and I'd welcome any advice or experiences with this kit


NormalWisdom

2,184 posts

190 months

Wednesday 6th June 2018
quotequote all
I have the DECO - In now for 3 months, no issues whatsoever - App is very simple to use, set-up equally so and now get a minimum of 80mbps all over the house

the_g_ster

384 posts

226 months

Wednesday 6th June 2018
quotequote all
Go out and get two Ubiquiti wireless access points.

Got fed up with mine at home, so put box in modem mode, and into an AC Pro.

It goes like stink, Netflix doesn't drop out anymore, very pleased. Comes with POE injectors too so you can put in celilngs, on walls etc etc.

Superleg48

1,525 posts

164 months

Wednesday 6th June 2018
quotequote all
I would second the Ubiquiti advice. I have 5 Ubiquiti Pro APs all hardwired into two separate 8 port Ubiquiti Tough Switch Pros along with some hardware using other available ports. The Ubiquiti APs are managed by a Cloud Controller and the two switches are hard wired into a Draytek Router. This in turn is hard wired into the Service Providers Router via an external firewall unit (I have a leased line set up and get 30/100 which was the only way to get more than about 5mbps - also rural). The performance is stonking with no drop outs etc.

Previously I had Luxar APs and physical Controller and this set up was awful.


kev1974

4,030 posts

160 months

Thursday 7th June 2018
quotequote all
Another vote for Ubiquiti Unifi APs partnered with a Ubiquiti Cloud Key. All hard wired back to a decent POE switch (avoid cheap 8 port POE from Netgear and the like, it is often under powered - their 24 port stuff is OK).

I am a big fan of their "In Wall" APs for residential use as they look a bit less corporate than the round ones, but the "In Wall" models do look best if you are able to mount them on a pattress box.

As well as being able to manage it all via web page, the Unifi app is surprisingly good too.

beedj

Original Poster:

485 posts

244 months

Thursday 7th June 2018
quotequote all
Thanks all. Go the ubiquiti ap’s need to be hard wired back to the incoming router? - if so then not really an option for me with the number of solid walls, wooden flooring throughout and the whole house decorated over last 18 months

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 7th June 2018
quotequote all
There’s another thread about this - https://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&...

craig1912

4,707 posts

143 months

Thursday 7th June 2018
quotequote all
beedj said:
Thanks all. Go the ubiquiti ap’s need to be hard wired back to the incoming router? - if so then not really an option for me with the number of solid walls, wooden flooring throughout and the whole house decorated over last 18 months
I believe they are (or to a switch) as that’s also how they get their power.

OldGermanHeaps

5,192 posts

209 months

Thursday 7th June 2018
quotequote all
craig1912 said:
I believe they are (or to a switch) as that’s also how they get their power.
You can do wireless uplink or mesh as well.

AC43

13,728 posts

239 months

Thursday 7th June 2018
quotequote all
brickwall said:
I've used the Netgear Orbi systems in a few places now - they're excellent. A doddle to set up, fast, and reliable.

Only tip I'd say is to over-spec it slightly - so if you're trying to cover 4,000sq ft pick the 6,000 sq ft system, etc. I find performance drops at the outer extremities of the quoted range.
I'm doing this - I'm going to go belt and braces and have 4 x RBK53's doing a 2,800 sq ft house all connected back to an ethernet switch.

I'll have two on the ground floor and two upstairs. Not sure what will give me best coverage so the upstairs ones will either both go in the first floor or I'll have one on the first floor and one in the loft

Having said that if I'd known about Ubiquiti's I'd have gone down that route (IIRC they are ceiling mounted?).

The problem I'm having is that I've worked out three of the five possible mounting points but I haven't finalised the room layouts for the other two.

And the builder wants me to commit today....



NormalWisdom

2,184 posts

190 months

Wednesday 29th August 2018
quotequote all
TP-Link Deco M5 down to £169.99 on Amazon today

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Deco-M5-Replacement-Antiv...

NDA

25,845 posts

256 months

Wednesday 29th August 2018
quotequote all
I have the BT Whole Home mesh system - 4 discs in an old house. It works very well - not had any problems and the signal is strong throughout the house.

Otispunkmeyer

13,838 posts

186 months

Wednesday 29th August 2018
quotequote all
if you want thorough.... Smallnetbuilder website seems to go overboard. But well worth reading their reviews IMO.