Cheap Laptop - How Bad Could it Be?
Cheap Laptop - How Bad Could it Be?
Author
Discussion

Frankthered

Original Poster:

1,688 posts

211 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
I know it's an old question and I have searched a few old threads, so I think it's worth another go.

I'm about to start a new job that will involve me working away quite a bit. So, to keep me occupied in the evenings, I've been looking at picking up a cheap laptop. At home, we've been using Macs since about 2010 and I'd like to take the opportunity to pick up a Windows machine because there are a couple of pieces of Windows only software (fairly simple - Betfair trading apps) that I'd like to try out properly. Otherwise, it will just be basic browsing, email, maybe some Word/Excel stuff, nothing heavy duty.

I was looking at spending around £400-500 which looks like it would get me a basic i3 or i5, but then I started seeing cheaper machines with processors called "Pentium" and "Celeron" (I remember those names from the 90s!) and then some with AMD processors that I could probably pick up for around £300.

So there's the question - I guess that the Pentium is the entry-level processor and the Celeron is the entry-level of the entry-level, but how bad could one of these machines be?

I guess my requirements are fairly "entry-level", so I'm thinking that a cheaper machine might be fit for purpose.

Would I get away with this, or is it worth me stumping up the extra for a basic i3/i5?

GregK2

1,723 posts

177 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
Stump up the extra. IME cheap laptops are a false economy. Also an SSD is a must, wouldn't be without one.

deckster

9,631 posts

286 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
£500 is totally the sweet spot for laptop pricing. Much less than that and the machine will be painful to use, and it will definitely struggle with anything more than just basic web browsing. Much more than that, and you won't see any real gain unless you are using it for gaming or something meaty like programming or image processing.

There's far too much choice out there to recommend anything specific but as said aim for around £500 from a big name and you won't go far wrong.

Lazermilk

3,523 posts

112 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
Agree the SSD is a must for the operating system to be installed on, I added one to my wifes old HP laptop a couple of years ago as it was running very slowly, after the SSD was added it was a totally different machine and is still fast enough now for what she uses it for.

buggalugs

9,297 posts

268 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
The cheaper CPU’s often struggle with complex web pages. i3 minimum really. SSD preferable.

clockworks

7,821 posts

176 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
Are there no Android or iOS equivalents of the apps you want to use? £300 will get you a decent tablet, far more usable than a cheap laptop. Lighter, more robust, better battery life, etc. Not much good for typing on, but just as good for web browsing, and nicer for any apps that have a "mobile" or web-based version.

Harpoon

2,554 posts

245 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
eBuyer have a HP 250 G6 which is a Core i5, 4GB RAM and 128GB SSD for £350. SSD is a bit small perhaps but good spec for the money.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
Walk away from Celeron (very very low end), or Pentium (very very dated, and Celeron was part of the Pentium family). They really are painfully slow. Really painful. Also get an SSD with the OS on it. This means your laptop will switch on / boot instantly, and will still do so in years to come. This transforms how much you use your laptop.

I got a 15" i5 with SSD and touchscreen for £500 from Currys a few years back.

maffski

1,905 posts

190 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
I've got both a cheap laptop (AMD E1) and more powerful one (i5) - Whilst the cheap one is entirely usable it is likely to be frustrating at times. The bigger concern is memory - 4GB just isn't enough with windows - I'd rather have a slow processor and 8GB of ram than an i5 with 4GB.

My i5 has 8GB ram and my E1 has been upgraded with 16GB and an SSD - the i5 is better to use (although it really would benefit from an SSD). The higher price would also let you go for a full HD screen, useful if you're thinking of using it for movies.


mattley

3,039 posts

253 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all

CryptoSuperDave

30 posts

101 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
do you need a 'laptop'?

i have £2500 worth of laptop myself from work (couple years old now but is 32GB RAM, i7).. but end of the day when im done working my £300 chromebook is what i reach for.. in fact i even (often) take the chromebook out with me for work if i know i'll have a good wifi/4g signal - chromebook will rdp into my laptop at home and google's own rdp is top notch you'd not realise you werent sat at the actual pc.. 12 hour battery life, touch screen, slim, weighs fk all..i love it




CryptoSuperDave

30 posts

101 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
deckster said:
£500 is totally the sweet spot for laptop pricing. Much less than that and the machine will be painful to use, and it will definitely struggle with anything more than just basic web browsing.
haha, i told a friend of a friend about my chromebook.. as they were undecided about a cheap'ish laptop for their son (c3-400 range), 2 weeks later son turns up with his budget windows laptop, struggling to run things and asking for help.. i had 5 mins with it and was ready to throw the fking thing in the bin myself..

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
CryptoSuperDave said:
do you need a 'laptop'?

i have £2500 worth of laptop myself from work (couple years old now but is 32GB RAM, i7).. but end of the day when im done working my £300 chromebook is what i reach for.. in fact i even (often) take the chromebook out with me for work if i know i'll have a good wifi/4g signal - chromebook will rdp into my laptop at home and google's own rdp is top notch you'd not realise you werent sat at the actual pc.. 12 hour battery life, touch screen, slim, weighs fk all..i love it
Which chromebook do you have? I'm tempted to buy one instead of a new android tablet as I hate typing on a screen.

CryptoSuperDave

30 posts

101 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
Which chromebook do you have? I'm tempted to buy one instead of a new android tablet as I hate typing on a screen.
i have the Acer R13, was cheap but came out well in its reviews so took a punt, there are better ones/more expensive but honestly now i have it i feel the acer is fantastic value for money - everything is quick and snappy.. for 99% of usage its perfect and i really like it - i use it often in tablet/tent mode (eg half asleep on my chest watching netflix while the mrs watches love island on the wall mount tv.. but mostly do use as a laptop (only real gripe with it is no keyboard backlighting) .. ive dropped it a few times from falling asleep with it on me, waking to a thud isnt ever nice but it's stood up brilliantly to its drops!..(no marks, no issues.. possibly just very lucky)
has expansion slot for additional hdd space if needed (micro sd), but other than downloading extra movies (netflix/plex syncing) extra space shouldnt really be needed
im chuffed with it, had it about a year now and still prefer grabbing it than an 8x more pricey laptop (similar dimensions).. mainly as i dont ever need to grab the charger!.. 7-9hrs heavy RDP/remote use is easy when im out of office and 12 hrs light app usage/internet browsing is very typical. and never feels slow/sluggish despite its cheap price
without a doubt loads better ones out now but will certainly buy another chromebook when required. unless you need to use something that specifically requires windows to run i wouldn't bother anymore.. being able to go out all day and work without grabbing/packing a charger and plug hunting for me is reason enough, but it's more than just an efficient machine.. its not very often im impressed by 'budget' tech in honesty but my chromebook punt surprised me.. genuinely love it.




Michaelbailey

651 posts

137 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
Bought a acer laptop a couple of years back with a celeron processor. Genuinely one of the most disgraceful products i have ever purchased. Bought it as a gift for my partner and felt ashamed at how awful it was. From day one it was slow. After a week it was almost unusable. After a month it broke beyond repair. I went out and spent a £1,000 on a hp i7 laptop with a ssd. Buy nice or buy twice.

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
CryptoSuperDave said:
without a doubt loads better ones out now but will certainly buy another chromebook when required. unless you need to use something that specifically requires windows to run i wouldn't bother anymore.. being able to go out all day and work without grabbing/packing a charger and plug hunting for me is reason enough, but it's more than just an efficient machine.. its not very often im impressed by 'budget' tech in honesty but my chromebook punt surprised me.. genuinely love it.
Thanks, even more tempted now smile Already have a decent spec desktop and an older Elitebook laptop which work fine (mainly used for car diagnostics tbh) but my wife is getting annoyed with the amount I borrow her Samsung S2 tablet for browsing etc.

ajprice

33,629 posts

227 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
A few weeks ago I asked the PH hive mind about a cheap laptop for Sage accounts, with a basic idea of the spec that was wanted. If your passing the time includes gaming or a very portable laptop, this maybe isn't for you, but an i5 8GB RAM SSD laptop for around £300 is a pretty good deal.

https://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&...

Have a look at the refurbished machines from Amazon and outlet stores for something cheaper than list price.

Frankthered

Original Poster:

1,688 posts

211 months

Monday 20th August 2018
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies! It would seem that they can be that bad then!!

Just to address a couple of points - there are trading apps (at least one) for iOS/Android, but it doesn't have all the functionality that I'm looking for. Plus, I don't think I'd be comfortable trying to trade on a tablet just yet, so I will stick with a laptop - at least for now.

I have also looked at Chromebooks and agree they would be ideal for everything, except for the Windows software that I really want to run!

Thanks to everybody for their suggestions - I'm not entirely sold that I need SSD (my first computer was a ZX81, so that taught me patience!) but I certainly have some avenues to explore - I'll report back later in the week and let you know what I've decided!

thumbup


Edited by Frankthered on Tuesday 21st August 08:17

pokethepope

2,667 posts

219 months

Tuesday 21st August 2018
quotequote all
You absolutely need an SSD, it makes the world of difference

Zad

13,025 posts

267 months

Tuesday 21st August 2018
quotequote all
How can I put this. You need an SSD.

50 quid to turn wading through a waist-deep pool of treacle into something that actually works and just gets on with it.