Non genuine toner cartridges - experiences?
Non genuine toner cartridges - experiences?
Author
Discussion

egomeister

Original Poster:

7,614 posts

294 months

Saturday 25th August 2018
quotequote all
Looks like I need a new B&W toner for my printer (Brother DCP-9015CDW).

Has anyone had experience of non genuine toner cartridges? They seem to be available for a tenth of the price of a genuine part, which would be great but I'm a little sceptical of the quality... do they end up causing problems with the drum/transfer unit?

twister

1,595 posts

267 months

Saturday 25th August 2018
quotequote all
Not sure about third party toner for printers that have seperate drums, my Samsung uses an all in one toner+drum and it's quite happily printing away on its third or perhaps fourth third party toner. Print quality seems just as good as I remember from the original toner that Samsung supplied in the box, and number of pages printed always seems about in line with the expected total, so for me it's a no brainer to keep on using them instead of originals.

GlenMH

5,473 posts

274 months

Saturday 25th August 2018
quotequote all
I have been using 3rd party cartridges in my Brother MFD. Over 10000 pages in and I have had only 2 problems with them, which is not bad considering the cost savings....

Durzel

13,029 posts

199 months

Sunday 26th August 2018
quotequote all
Some printers don't take kindly to compatible cartridges.

I've had a couple of Xeroxs - one was fine with them, but the more recent purchase simply doesn't recognise any non-genuine toners at all.

My basic understanding is that manufacturers can't stop people being able to use compatible cartridges, but there's nothing stopping then releasing new firmware updates that "improve security" and unfortunately are incompatible with older chips or whatever....

Lexmark is supposedly very bad for this, but I'd assume any newish printer that identifies genuine toners might be finicky with remanufactured/compatible ones.

Jonny_

4,731 posts

238 months

Monday 27th August 2018
quotequote all
We've been using an Oki colour laser multifunction thing at home for about a year now, it's been run on £35-per-set compatible toner from Amazon from day one and - thus far - no problems at all. Brand name was "Do It Wiser" IIRC.

Will say that having never fed it with genuine Oki toners, I've no basis for comparing print quality between genuine and compatible toner. Comparing prints with the much more expensive Xerox machines at work, though, the quality appears just as good to my untrained eye.

egomeister

Original Poster:

7,614 posts

294 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
Thanks for the info everyone. My main concern was whether the cheap toners end up not transferring properly and make a mess of the insides of the printer as suggested by some of the Amazon reviews. The majority of feedback seems positive and PH confirms that so I'll give it a go.

Nigel_O

3,901 posts

250 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
I tried compatibles in a Kyocera m6030cdn - print quality was poor, toner usage was high and excess toner got everywhere inside the printer - we had to get an engineer out to strip and clean it

Only ever used genuine toner since then (although I'm not paying for it, so its an easier decision...)

sparkythecat

8,112 posts

286 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
twister said:
Not sure about third party toner for printers that have seperate drums, my Samsung uses an all in one toner+drum and it's quite happily printing away on its third or perhaps fourth third party toner. Print quality seems just as good as I remember from the original toner that Samsung supplied in the box, and number of pages printed always seems about in line with the expected total, so for me it's a no brainer to keep on using them instead of originals.
I've had the same experience with my 10yr old Samsung ML 240 printer. It soldiers on regardless of whatever cheap toner cartridge that I put in it without any apparent loss of print quality.
I did once have to dismantle it and flash the eprom to zero the page counter. It had maxxed out and couldn't go any higher.

zedx19

3,050 posts

171 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
Worth noting that whilst the printer maybe fine and the initial print quality may look fine, the print is likely to be less robust so likely to fade much quicker. This is in my experience anyway on Epson genuine Ecotank ink compared with cheap fakes. The black in particular fades much quicker on cheap inks compared with the genuine one.