ADSL cable extension or ethernet cable extension?
ADSL cable extension or ethernet cable extension?
Author
Discussion

Lemming Train

Original Poster:

5,567 posts

103 months

Monday 27th August 2018
quotequote all
I need to run a cable between the PC and phone socket a distance of approx 10 metres. I can either buy a 10 metre ADSL cable and have the router where the PC is or I can buy a 10 metre ethernet cable and keep the router near the phone socket. Are there any signal loss issues I need to be aware of with either of them before buying please?

(I am aware there are other connectivity options).

Merry

1,512 posts

219 months

Monday 27th August 2018
quotequote all
Much over muchness really. Adsl cable will be easier to hide.

You planning on using the WiFi on the router at all? Location could make a difference to its range and dictate which option you go for.


eliot

12,000 posts

285 months

Monday 27th August 2018
quotequote all
Ethernet. Keep your phone line as short as possible

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 27th August 2018
quotequote all
absolutely keep the phone line as short as possible. the ethernet can be as long as you like.

Dr Mike Oxgreen

4,473 posts

196 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
Keep your phone line short. If that means your WiFi is located in a sub-optimal place, switch WiFi off in your ADSL router and get a separate WiFi access point that you can put elsewhere (with a hard Ethernet connection to the router or to a conveniently located switch).

Merry

1,512 posts

219 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
Dr Mike Oxgreen said:
Keep your phone line short. If that means your WiFi is located in a sub-optimal place, switch WiFi off in your ADSL router and get a separate WiFi access point that you can put elsewhere (with a hard Ethernet connection to the router or to a conveniently located switch).
Bit of an expensive option though.

That copper cable has come an awful long way, and you'll be using one to connect your router anyway. 9/10 any speed issues emerging from the socket are with the socket itself or connectors therein. Length of the cable won't make a difference. Or the difference it will make will be negligible.

I'd run which ever is easiest and cheapest. If that's ethernet, use that, if not use the adsl cable.

theboss

7,572 posts

250 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
By all means use an "ADSL cable" and situate the DSL router/modem away from the master socket, but make sure you buy one formed of twisted pairs.

e.g. 10m of Cat5e terminated with RJ11 connectors:

https://www.amazon.co.uk/TechWareGames-RJ11-RJ11-H...

The flat wire which most RJ11 'ADSL cables' seem to consist of, resembling a cheap telephone extension, or the wire provided with most modems, can have a degrading effect on any xDSL implementation, and I wouldn't personally touch with a barge pole especially 10 meters of the stuff. Even the existence of this stuff to form extensions the router isn't connected to, can harm your download speeds.

The cable BT use between your home and the cabinet / exchange is a form of twisted pair cable which is much more conducive to carrying xDSL signals than a cheap extension wire, so they are not comparable.

Lemming Train

Original Poster:

5,567 posts

103 months

Tuesday 28th August 2018
quotequote all
Thanks. Divided opinion then. I went for 10m of Belkin ethernet cable in the end and will run it under a carefully placed rug across the hallway. It's only a temporary thing until some work in the house is completed.