Can I install 2 routers on 1 phone line?
Discussion
I've gone onto fibre broadband. Fibre upto the box in the street and copper to the house. My provider has sent me another router.
Can I connect this router to one of the spare sockets in the house and leave the original router in place? The two routers would have different usernames.
If I could it would mean that I could access internet upstairs on one router and downstairs on the other.
Can I connect this router to one of the spare sockets in the house and leave the original router in place? The two routers would have different usernames.
If I could it would mean that I could access internet upstairs on one router and downstairs on the other.
What are you trying to achieve by having two routers that you can’t do with one? Is it that the WiFi doesn’t reach upstairs? If so then the router you put upstairs has to be connected to the one downstairs either wirelessly or with a network cable and put into a different ‘mode’ which it might not support - do you know the make and models of the routers? If it is a WiFi issue you’re trying to solve then there are more elegant and easier to configure solutions dependent on budget.
BigTZ4M said:
What are you trying to achieve by having two routers that you can’t do with one? Is it that the WiFi doesn’t reach upstairs? If so then the router you put upstairs has to be connected to the one downstairs either wirelessly or with a network cable and put into a different ‘mode’ which it might not support - do you know the make and models of the routers? If it is a WiFi issue you’re trying to solve then there are more elegant and easier to configure solutions dependent on budget.
The situation at the moment is...1. Master socket is in the kitchen
2. WiFi cannot be accessed in every room when the current router was tested in the kitchen.
3. Current router is located near the middle of the house upstairs and is connected to a secondary socket.
4. Downstairs Sky box is hardwired via ethernet cable into the current router.
5. Downstairs Sky box does not have WiFi, so must be hardwired into a router. We also have an upstairs Sky box, but it is WiFi.
I would like to connect the new router to the master socket (to get the best phone signal)
I don't want to re-route the downstairs Sky box ethernet cable, I'd rather leave it connected to the old router and run everything else from the new router.
Current router : Netgear Wireless-N 300 Modem Router DGN2200
New router : Sagem FAST 5364-3.T8 (supplied by TalkTalk)
OldGermanHeaps said:
You cant have thwm on the same phone line, that will cause lots of problems. You could run an ethernet cable and turn off dhcp and routing functions and use the second router as an ap, but thats a pure bodge, just get a repeater, or a proper ap.
This is what I thought, but I thought that I would ask rather than just toss a good router in the recycling (eBay
).BigTZ4M said:
So if I understand correctly, your only reason for wanting to use a second router is to put it in the kitchen for the best phone signal? You can just plug your phone into the master socket, you don’t need to do anything with a router.
By phone signal, I mean phone line signal.I've not used my landline for phone calls in about three years.
The best signal will be at the master socket because that is the shortest distance to the box in the road. Additionally, there are no additional connections or lengths of wire to add resistance or potentially interference to the signal.
So if you really want the router in the kitchen and not to reroute any existing Ethernet I’d recommend a Netgear Orbi mesh system. You place a number of units around the house and each unit can provide wired and wireless access. They talk to each other via a dedicated wireless backhaul. You can have the router in the kitchen, full speed wireless around the house and wire in your Sky boxes if they are near a unit.
1) Put new router where you like.
2) Add a dual-band wifi extender to a mains socket. If you want an ethernet port try this:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Universal-Extender-Broadb...
2) Add a dual-band wifi extender to a mains socket. If you want an ethernet port try this:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Universal-Extender-Broadb...
Edited by Slushbox on Sunday 2nd September 07:15
I would put your new router on your master socket and the old router can be used as a wifi extender i.e. connect the old router using some Powerline adapters. Place it where the wifi range isn't sufficient and connect your devices in that part of the house to that wifi rather than the one on the new router.
You'll need to connect to the old router by cable and switch off its dhcp. This will mean that it won't issue any IP addresses, it will just take what its given from the new router. I think that's about all the setup you need. Maybe check that both routers don't use the same channel to avoid interference.
You'll need to connect to the old router by cable and switch off its dhcp. This will mean that it won't issue any IP addresses, it will just take what its given from the new router. I think that's about all the setup you need. Maybe check that both routers don't use the same channel to avoid interference.
OldGermanHeaps said:
You could run an ethernet cable and turn off dhcp and routing functions and use the second router as an ap, but thats a pure bodge, just get a repeater, or a proper ap.
Genuine question - how is configuring a second router to act as an access point a "pure bodge"? It's worked perfectly for me. It seems a waste to spend money on an access point if you already have a router which is easily configured to achieve the same result.Because the wifi hardware in an isp supplied combo router/modem/ap is pretty much always the absolute bare minimum they can get away with. To top that off the thing will be constantly trying to connect to the isp, consuming resources. If it gets reset for whatever reason it will bring the network down with conflicting dhcp servers. Its just plain the wrong tool for the job. Its like using a butterknife as a flat blade screwdriver.
tim0409 said:
Genuine question - how is configuring a second router to act as an access point a "pure bodge"? It's worked perfectly for me. It seems a waste to spend money on an access point if you already have a router which is easily configured to achieve the same result.
I personally don’t think it is more of a bodge than a repeater for the reasons you state that you are repurposing the router as a wireless access point.The reason I’d say both are a bodge (although bodge is a bit strong) is that roaming between two APs not part of the same ecosystem can be less than optimal. My experience of using an all Ubiquiti AP ecosystem is much more seamless than when I had Apple airports with a BT homehub in a mixed environment. It’s the reason I suggested a mesh system - one provider doing all the WiFi is a nice experience and mesh is easier than implementing multiple wired APs.
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



