Discussion
So I have large storage on my PC and large storage on my Mac.
But only moderate storage with drop box - so pretty soon I''l not be able to use DB to back up all my media files (pics and videos)
So I'm thinking a 4TB drive under the stairs with the router that both PC & Mac send back ups too - is that what a NAS does? And if so, is any one type better than another? Dont need it fast, just to back up the two systems overnight.
But only moderate storage with drop box - so pretty soon I''l not be able to use DB to back up all my media files (pics and videos)
So I'm thinking a 4TB drive under the stairs with the router that both PC & Mac send back ups too - is that what a NAS does? And if so, is any one type better than another? Dont need it fast, just to back up the two systems overnight.
Is not strictly what you asked but I looked into this ages ago and ended up subscribing to backblaze for backups rather than getting a nas. The cost is small compared to a nas with minimal effort required. In my view a better backup as well but as with anything I'm sure others will have a different view.
You can use a NAS for that if you want to, though that's not really what a NAS is there to do.
I have a couple of NAS drives sitting next to the router. They hold all our audio and video media, photos, docs, everything. The only things stored locally on the computers and laptops in the house are operating systems, applications and any downloads that accidentally don't get pointed to the NAS.
I have a couple more NAS drives that serve as backups to the two onsite. Once everything is set up, you can forget about it. It just does its thing in the background.
ETA: as to what's a good NAS, I can only speak to what I have. I bought Western Digital DL4100s. I use RAID5 to stripe across the drives. I've had one drive failure (out of 16 drives) in two+ years. No interruption to data access, no loss of data. Popped the drive out, put a new one in, let it rebuild itself (took about 10 hours) and all was good. No one apart from me noticed anything different throughout.
You can get them (or the PR4100/EX4100 variants) refurb'd on ebay and they are fine. The ones that say they are from North America ship from Poland so there's no duty/VAT on import. Ironically the failed drive was from one I had bought new from a retailer.
No doubt someone who actually knows about IT (vs dabbles) will be along soon with some other suggestions.
I have a couple of NAS drives sitting next to the router. They hold all our audio and video media, photos, docs, everything. The only things stored locally on the computers and laptops in the house are operating systems, applications and any downloads that accidentally don't get pointed to the NAS.
I have a couple more NAS drives that serve as backups to the two onsite. Once everything is set up, you can forget about it. It just does its thing in the background.
ETA: as to what's a good NAS, I can only speak to what I have. I bought Western Digital DL4100s. I use RAID5 to stripe across the drives. I've had one drive failure (out of 16 drives) in two+ years. No interruption to data access, no loss of data. Popped the drive out, put a new one in, let it rebuild itself (took about 10 hours) and all was good. No one apart from me noticed anything different throughout.
You can get them (or the PR4100/EX4100 variants) refurb'd on ebay and they are fine. The ones that say they are from North America ship from Poland so there's no duty/VAT on import. Ironically the failed drive was from one I had bought new from a retailer.
No doubt someone who actually knows about IT (vs dabbles) will be along soon with some other suggestions.
Edited by anonymous-user on Friday 14th September 11:16
You can use a NAS to store all your files and create shares per user, so it functions like cloud storage but without the ongoing costs.
NAS boxes give several options, they usually offer extra 'apps' like media servers, back up to cloud services, backup to other NAS boxes and external drives, FTP servers, Web servers etc. .
A 'two drive' option will generally offer RAID features - so adding say 2 x 4TB drives in RAID1 will only give 4TB of storage, but the drives will be mirrored to each each other. If one drive fails, the other still has the data and can restore it when the 'bust' drive is replaced.
This halves the chance of data loss, but doubles the storage cost. Most NAS boxes will accept a single drive so you can upgrade later. Or 2 x 4TB drives can make a single 8TB share (RAID 0) but with no provision for data loss.
As to drives, there are many opinions. WD RED drives are certified for NAS use (heat+vibration) but there's a lot of choice and some people say they have no problem using cheaper drives.
Favoured NAS brands are Synology, and Qnap but there are plenty of others. I have a Zyxel NAS326 with a pair of 1TB (RAID 1) Seagate Barracudas in it which works well. (£100 + drives).
Max capacity on some cheaper NAS boxes (Zyxel) is 32TB overall.
If the home is prone to power cuts, adding a UPS to the NAS and router power supply is useful.
All about RAID:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_RAID_levels
Edited by Slushbox on Friday 14th September 11:43
Tiggsy said:
You say its not what a NAS is meant for - is that not what you are using yours for?
Yes and no. I have four. No because two are my data/media servers. Those two are accessed by computers/laptops/Apple TVs/Sonos etc regularly and are heavily used file/media servers. Yes because the other two are the off site backups that take backup copies of the first two, which is more or less what you propose to do.
I can pull at least three HD video streams plus Sonos streams off the first two simultaneously, and have users accessing files, and no one would know anyone else is in the house doing anything. I don't know, but I suspect that it would be difficult to have that level of simultaneous access to data stored on a laptop/computer's hard drive that was connected to a network.
Greg66 said:
Tiggsy said:
You say its not what a NAS is meant for - is that not what you are using yours for?
Yes because the other two are the off site backups that take backup copies of the first two, which is more or less what you propose to do. The question you should ask is: how can I backup my important data to somewhere else (i.e. a remote site or the 'cloud')? You don't want your PC, your Mac and the NAS being in the same building that gets burned down.
Hi - I have a very similar setup. Once thing, it DOES need to be fast if you are backing up your computers. Trust me, you'll notice, and not all ethernet controllers (built into the NAS) are equal.
I use a Netgear ReadyNAS. It's a Network Attached Storage box , but it is also a RAID controller - so you put two inexpensive hard discs in it (Redundant Array of INEXPENSIVE DISCS) :-) and it will morror them, giving you the security that if one dies, the other will still have everything on it. This is very important if you are using it to store your backup data.
You set up shares , so on your PC and Mac you'll be able to add drive mappings to it - i.e. you'll add a P: drive for your pictures, an M: drive for your music etc. To you it'll look like you it will look like you are storing and accessing local data, but it won't be, it'll be on the NAS.
I keep all my photos, documents etc on it, and then I have my PC auto backup to it once a week (the NAS box has a built in backup app).
Then... once a month, I have it auto-back up its contents to a cheap USB 3 pocket drive (The Ready nas has a few USB 3 ports on it). This drive is then taken with me when I go on holiday. Now if I'm burgled, I still have the data.
And because its fast, the drives appear like they are local.
Trust me, I've tried NAS drives (raid and normal) and they are slow with big transfers unless you hunt down NAS boxes with fast network cards / processors. Mine is around twice as fast as cheap ones I've used. (I get a constant 30Mb/sec on transfers over Gigabit ethernet)
p.s. I also run a Torrent client on the NAS - this means I can download torrents with my PC turned off.
I use a Netgear ReadyNAS. It's a Network Attached Storage box , but it is also a RAID controller - so you put two inexpensive hard discs in it (Redundant Array of INEXPENSIVE DISCS) :-) and it will morror them, giving you the security that if one dies, the other will still have everything on it. This is very important if you are using it to store your backup data.
You set up shares , so on your PC and Mac you'll be able to add drive mappings to it - i.e. you'll add a P: drive for your pictures, an M: drive for your music etc. To you it'll look like you it will look like you are storing and accessing local data, but it won't be, it'll be on the NAS.
I keep all my photos, documents etc on it, and then I have my PC auto backup to it once a week (the NAS box has a built in backup app).
Then... once a month, I have it auto-back up its contents to a cheap USB 3 pocket drive (The Ready nas has a few USB 3 ports on it). This drive is then taken with me when I go on holiday. Now if I'm burgled, I still have the data.
And because its fast, the drives appear like they are local.
Trust me, I've tried NAS drives (raid and normal) and they are slow with big transfers unless you hunt down NAS boxes with fast network cards / processors. Mine is around twice as fast as cheap ones I've used. (I get a constant 30Mb/sec on transfers over Gigabit ethernet)
p.s. I also run a Torrent client on the NAS - this means I can download torrents with my PC turned off.
RodgerDodger iterated :'I get a constant 30Mb/sec on transfers over Gigabit ethernet.'
That would make it the slowest NAS .... in the world. :-)
Do you mean 30 Megabytes/sec. MB, not Mb?
Current boxes run much faster, if both ends of the link can handle it. Zyxel NAS326 runs at plus 90MB/s, on both read and writes, with a pair of 7200 rpm drives in it. (Multiple transfers/backups will slow this.)
Some of the older Synology units were/are woefully slow. The user forums have the story. Enabling media servers or other services like Twonky slows them down, also.
Side-note: the home ADSL/FTTC routers supplied by ISPs often have only 10/100 ports which slows NAS boxes down. You can add a Gigabit ethernet switch between NAS and pooters, for full-fat Gigabit ethernet.

That would make it the slowest NAS .... in the world. :-)
Do you mean 30 Megabytes/sec. MB, not Mb?
Current boxes run much faster, if both ends of the link can handle it. Zyxel NAS326 runs at plus 90MB/s, on both read and writes, with a pair of 7200 rpm drives in it. (Multiple transfers/backups will slow this.)
Some of the older Synology units were/are woefully slow. The user forums have the story. Enabling media servers or other services like Twonky slows them down, also.
Side-note: the home ADSL/FTTC routers supplied by ISPs often have only 10/100 ports which slows NAS boxes down. You can add a Gigabit ethernet switch between NAS and pooters, for full-fat Gigabit ethernet.
Edited by Slushbox on Sunday 16th September 08:14
I went nerdy home built, so took a HP Microserver (before QNAP + others were a real option) and did the following:
Got a N40L (Gen 7), though you can go Gen 8, do not go Gen 10 as HP seem to be going a different way and its not NAS.
https://www.ebay.co.uk/bhp/hp-microserver
Then you can go easy... SSD powered off the motherboard as the OS leave the 4 HDs alone for pure storage (safest option) and go from there, want 5 drives, maybe 6 or 8, go for it. Also CPU and RAM can be upgraded at will.
Operating systems can be freeNAS or what I have is WHS2011 which sits there happily and I use for plex.
Mine is 6TB (2 x 2TB non raided and 2x 2TB raided)... My next upgrade is 4x 6TB as I found a way to do it on the cheap, then I will probably ditch the N40L and upgrade to the newer Gen8.
This is the kind of stuff you can do if you like to get hands dirty.
https://blog.monstermuffin.org/hp-microserver-gen8...
You can go a step further:
https://datahamster.com/2017/10/08/building-a-free...
Please note all the above means you have your data safe if in the same property as the PC/Laptops, all my important data is in the cloud as well as the NAS, the NAS is then additionally used for media server.
Got a N40L (Gen 7), though you can go Gen 8, do not go Gen 10 as HP seem to be going a different way and its not NAS.
https://www.ebay.co.uk/bhp/hp-microserver
Then you can go easy... SSD powered off the motherboard as the OS leave the 4 HDs alone for pure storage (safest option) and go from there, want 5 drives, maybe 6 or 8, go for it. Also CPU and RAM can be upgraded at will.
Operating systems can be freeNAS or what I have is WHS2011 which sits there happily and I use for plex.
Mine is 6TB (2 x 2TB non raided and 2x 2TB raided)... My next upgrade is 4x 6TB as I found a way to do it on the cheap, then I will probably ditch the N40L and upgrade to the newer Gen8.
This is the kind of stuff you can do if you like to get hands dirty.
https://blog.monstermuffin.org/hp-microserver-gen8...
You can go a step further:
https://datahamster.com/2017/10/08/building-a-free...
Please note all the above means you have your data safe if in the same property as the PC/Laptops, all my important data is in the cloud as well as the NAS, the NAS is then additionally used for media server.
Slushbox said:
RodgerDodger iterated :'I get a constant 30Mb/sec on transfers over Gigabit ethernet.'
That would make it the slowest NAS .... in the world. :-)
Do you mean 30 Megabytes/sec. MB, not Mb?
Current boxes run much faster, if both ends of the link can handle it. Zyxel NAS326 runs at plus 90MB/s, on both read and writes, with a pair of 7200 rpm drives in it. (Multiple transfers/backups will slow this.)
Some of the older Synology units were/are woefully slow. The user forums have the story. Enabling media servers or other services like Twonky slows them down, also.
Side-note: the home ADSL/FTTC routers supplied by ISPs often have only 10/100 ports which slows NAS boxes down. You can add a Gigabit ethernet switch between NAS and pooters, for full-fat Gigabit ethernet.

Well spotted. I checked. I was copying a movie file from one share on the NAS to another share on the NAS . So it was copying from the Nas to my pc, and being written from my pc back to the Nas, all at the same time. Hence the 30. :-)That would make it the slowest NAS .... in the world. :-)
Do you mean 30 Megabytes/sec. MB, not Mb?
Current boxes run much faster, if both ends of the link can handle it. Zyxel NAS326 runs at plus 90MB/s, on both read and writes, with a pair of 7200 rpm drives in it. (Multiple transfers/backups will slow this.)
Some of the older Synology units were/are woefully slow. The user forums have the story. Enabling media servers or other services like Twonky slows them down, also.
Side-note: the home ADSL/FTTC routers supplied by ISPs often have only 10/100 ports which slows NAS boxes down. You can add a Gigabit ethernet switch between NAS and pooters, for full-fat Gigabit ethernet.
Edited by anonymous-user on Sunday 16th September 08:14
update, just tested mine: on pc to nas copies. 40MB/s write, 80MB/s read. That's from a 7 year old Ready Nas Duo that cost me around £120 + two £50 drives.
Edited by anonymous-user on Sunday 16th September 10:15
"update, just tested mine: on pc to nas copies. 40MB/s write, 80MB/s read. That's from a 7 year old Ready Nas Duo that cost me around £120 + two £50 drives."
That's more better. :-)
On big file transfers with multiple folders to the PC my Zyxel drops to about the same.
As SSD's become cheaper there's a growing trend to replace NAS spinners with them. Less power consumption/heat/noise.
I'm not sure how long they'd function, running 24/7 with all the media servers, web servers and other crap running on my NAS. :-)
Also a lot of the cheaper NAS boxes now support APC uninteruptable power supplies (UPS). A USB cable connects the two and the NAS auto-shuts down 'safely' when the power dies.
^^^ HP Proliant.
I looked at these a couple of years ago when they were £99 on Amazon, but missed the chance, hence the Zyxel. (Other brands are available.)
That's more better. :-)
On big file transfers with multiple folders to the PC my Zyxel drops to about the same.
As SSD's become cheaper there's a growing trend to replace NAS spinners with them. Less power consumption/heat/noise.
I'm not sure how long they'd function, running 24/7 with all the media servers, web servers and other crap running on my NAS. :-)
Also a lot of the cheaper NAS boxes now support APC uninteruptable power supplies (UPS). A USB cable connects the two and the NAS auto-shuts down 'safely' when the power dies.
^^^ HP Proliant.
I looked at these a couple of years ago when they were £99 on Amazon, but missed the chance, hence the Zyxel. (Other brands are available.)
Edited by Slushbox on Monday 17th September 08:48
I run a Synology DS214Play (latest version is 218Play - https://www.amazon.co.uk/Synology-DS218play-Bay-De... with x2 6Tb WD Red hdds.
Stored all our music, photos and videos on there. Great to access when you're stuck in a shoddy hotel for work and want to watch a film!
Stored all our music, photos and videos on there. Great to access when you're stuck in a shoddy hotel for work and want to watch a film!
Tiggsy said:
You say its not what a NAS is meant for - is that not what you are using yours for?
It’s a discussion that regularly pops up on these pagesA NAS is a storage device, not a backup device.
Cue a lot of people popping up saying theirs is because they have five hundred copies of the files, they don’t trust cloud backup etc etc

Slushbox said:
RodgerDodger iterated :'I get a constant 30Mb/sec on transfers over Gigabit ethernet.'
That would make it the slowest NAS .... in the world. :-)
Do you mean 30 Megabytes/sec. MB, not Mb?
Current boxes run much faster, if both ends of the link can handle it. Zyxel NAS326 runs at plus 90MB/s, on both read and writes, with a pair of 7200 rpm drives in it. (Multiple transfers/backups will slow this.)
Some of the older Synology units were/are woefully slow. The user forums have the story. Enabling media servers or other services like Twonky slows them down, also.
Side-note: the home ADSL/FTTC routers supplied by ISPs often have only 10/100 ports which slows NAS boxes down. You can add a Gigabit ethernet switch between NAS and pooters, for full-fat Gigabit ethernet.
Hi. Could you explain (in very simple terms) where to plumb in a gigabit switch into a home setup?That would make it the slowest NAS .... in the world. :-)
Do you mean 30 Megabytes/sec. MB, not Mb?
Current boxes run much faster, if both ends of the link can handle it. Zyxel NAS326 runs at plus 90MB/s, on both read and writes, with a pair of 7200 rpm drives in it. (Multiple transfers/backups will slow this.)
Some of the older Synology units were/are woefully slow. The user forums have the story. Enabling media servers or other services like Twonky slows them down, also.
Side-note: the home ADSL/FTTC routers supplied by ISPs often have only 10/100 ports which slows NAS boxes down. You can add a Gigabit ethernet switch between NAS and pooters, for full-fat Gigabit ethernet.
I currently don't have a NAS but am planning on incorporating this into my setup. Ultimately, I am looking to move my PC into a home office in the garden, so was planning on using powerline adapters out of the back of the (non ISP supplied) router, to then allow the router to be connected via ethernet cables, through the mains wiring, straight to the router.
Where would the switch (and the NAS drives) sit in this setup? Without the switch, could I simply plug the NAS drives into the back of the router?
thanks
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



