Gaming PC or Xbox one X
Author
Discussion

rallyeS2

Original Poster:

205 posts

220 months

Tuesday 25th September 2018
quotequote all
Hi all,

Looking for some advice really. It’s been a while since I’ve done any PC based gaming but am considering getting back into it.

Currently we are an Xbox only household (old iMac for the boring stuff) and my son and I play Fortnite together. I will be getting the new COD blackout when it is released having been impressing with the beta.

I currently have a 1st gen Xbox and he has a One S.

I’m considering an upgrade to the one x for me as we have a 4K hdr tv and the Xbox one is a bit laggy for Fortnite...

Would I be better spending a bit more and getting a gaming PC / monitor setup for these 2 games? I feel Fortnite especially looks more fun to play with fully mappable keys and the accuracy of a mouse...

All advice welcome especially on spec for a PC build.

Thanks

Andy

HRL

3,361 posts

250 months

Tuesday 25th September 2018
quotequote all
Depends on budget.

A gaming PC explicitly for 4K is going to cost you an arm and a leg.

I’m currently about to buy an Nvidia 2080Ti for the princely sum of £1100. That’s to get a solid 4K/60 on almost anything.

You can pick up the last card, the 1080Ti for about £500 but either way a new PC will cost much more than an X1X.

geeks

11,899 posts

170 months

Tuesday 25th September 2018
quotequote all
Financially an xbone x makes more sense, especially if it is just for a couple of games for the odd evening here and there. If you want VR or to spend serious amounts of time gaming then a PC makes more sense.

Jinx

12,023 posts

291 months

Tuesday 25th September 2018
quotequote all
For just gaming it is hard not to recommend the Xbox one X. But if you will do more than just play games (even if this is just getting involved with the modding community) then a PC can't be beat. If you play a lot of games then the prices and sheer volume of titles available make the PC king.
4K though is a tough sell given the horse power you will require. For 4k 60fps then only the £1,100 RTX 2080ti will cut it, if you can cope with 30 fps (normal console frame rate) then either the RTX 2080 or the older 1080Ti will do (£700 and about £600 respectively).
A decent CPU (i7 8600K or Ryzen 2700X) will also be needed to get the best out of the afore mentioned GPUs so in the end you will be looking at a £2K outlay for proper 4K gaming. (or cheat and hang around the Dell outlet site until an Alienware with the spec you want pops up - like what I did - pic on the desktop thread).
The new Intel chips are out soon so it may be best to wait and either go for the new 8 core or the price dropped 6 core or amd processor.


rallyeS2

Original Poster:

205 posts

220 months

Tuesday 25th September 2018
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies so far guys, the one x seems hard to beat for the money. What is the score with “gaming monitors” these days if I were to build a setup with separate monitor (we have a room I could setup for gaming) and not worry too much about 4K?

Loyly

18,295 posts

190 months

Tuesday 25th September 2018
quotequote all
Get both. I have an One X for console gaming and will soom be buying a new PC for gaming. They do different things so having both is the only option for me.

rallyeS2

Original Poster:

205 posts

220 months

Tuesday 25th September 2018
quotequote all
Loyly said:
Get both. I have an One X for console gaming and will soom be buying a new PC for gaming. They do different things so having both is the only option for me.
That would be ideal!! Sadly the “financial director” is a tricky one to slip such purchases past!

Hoofy

80,188 posts

313 months

Wednesday 26th September 2018
quotequote all
Money no object, I'd go down the PC route, especially if you want to play FPS games.

rallyeS2

Original Poster:

205 posts

220 months

Wednesday 26th September 2018
quotequote all
That’s the thing, I’ve priced up a decent spec gaming PC and I’m realistically looking at a grand for the PC plus monitor, keyboard and mouse...

For the same money, I can probably get a simulator style gaming chair, new 4K tv, steering wheel / pedals and an Xbox one x once I trade in my old Xbox...

The question is, will either help me get a solo win on bloody Fortnite?!! shoot

captain_cynic

17,657 posts

126 months

Wednesday 26th September 2018
quotequote all
As a gamer, I'd go PC over console.

You can spec up a decent AMD build for £760.
https://uk.pcpartpicker.com/guide/gtYcCJ/modest-am...

You don't need to go for the full 1080/2080. A 1060 6GB or if you stretch your budget, 1070 will do 4K easily. As graphics cards age the fastest of all components, I've taken the policy of buying mid range and replacing it every 2nd generation (so I'll replace my 970 with a 2070). They usually are still capable of playing most games at high settings when I replace them.

In that build I'd probably get cheaper RAM and spend more on a bigger or faster SSD.

WRT PC vs console gaming, if you're a serious gamer who buys a lot of games (2 a month) PC is cheaper long term as initial costs are high but ongoing prices are much lower. Consoles are cheaper for casual gamers, cheaper to buy into but have higher ongoing costs (XBL/PSN subscriptions, replacement peripherals/consoles, no steam sales).

rallyeS2

Original Poster:

205 posts

220 months

Monday 1st October 2018
quotequote all
Thanks for the links and info above guys. I’ve done some further speccing up... it’s amazing how “budget creep” kicks in and before you know it the build is up to silly figures! I think I am going to probably get a one x in the meantime if there are some good deals on HUkD then see what Black Friday deals are about on components / monitors etc... I can trade my old Xbox in for a reasonable amount off the new console at Game...

I’m struggling to convince the wife we need a gaming room in the loft as she’s convinced she will only see my son and I when we are hungry!!

Interestingly on the fortnite front, all keys are now custom mappable on Xbox which makes building a bit easier albeit not PC speed...

rallyeS2

Original Poster:

205 posts

220 months

Wednesday 17th October 2018
quotequote all
Bit of an update on this... after procrastinating for way too long and missing a couple of good deals, I finally went for an XBox one X bundles with Forza 7 / horizons 4, state of decay 2 and COD black ops 4... All games I wanted anyway apart from state of decay so pretty pleased. Started the setup at lunch and left it updating... may be able to get playing sometime later hopefully!!

Jinx

12,023 posts

291 months

Wednesday 17th October 2018
quotequote all
rallyeS2 said:
Bit of an update on this... after procrastinating for way too long and missing a couple of good deals, I finally went for an XBox one X bundles with Forza 7 / horizons 4, state of decay 2 and COD black ops 4... All games I wanted anyway apart from state of decay so pretty pleased. Started the setup at lunch and left it updating... may be able to get playing sometime later hopefully!!
The new age of console gaming - leave it plugged in on standby or every time you want to play there will be another update......

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 17th October 2018
quotequote all
Bit late I know, but bang for buck in PC world, have a look at old Xeon workstations....

6 cores at 3ghz (but will OC to 4+ if the Mobo and cooling will take it), 24gb ram, hdd etc.

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Dell-Precision-T5500-Wo...

(I think that seller does dual 6 core units (so 12 cores, 24 threads for a few extra quid but is out of stock)

Then nail on something like this

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Gigabyte-GeForce-GTX-10...tongue outf:0

£350 (sell the quardo GPU to recoup a few quid).

I know its not cutting edge and might not run 4K at 60FPS (does an XBoneX do that?) but it should be very competent and cheap.

I run something similar (2x quad core E5620s IRC at 2.6ghz with 16gb ram and an old GTX650) and can play Fortnite at a decent framerate!

Edited by anonymous-user on Wednesday 17th October 23:17

opieoilman

4,408 posts

267 months

Thursday 18th October 2018
quotequote all
Jinx said:
The new age of console gaming - leave it plugged in on standby or every time you want to play there will be another update......
I used to game all the time on a PC, then wife and kids came along and I haven't had a chance. My wife bought me a PS4 about 3 years ago and I reckon it's had less than 100 hours of use, partially due to the number of updates it's needed - as I don't use it often, pretty much every time I do, there is an update. Just ordered a new gaming laptop, so will hopefully be playing more soon.

Deep Thought

40,169 posts

228 months

Thursday 18th October 2018
quotequote all
opieoilman said:
Jinx said:
The new age of console gaming - leave it plugged in on standby or every time you want to play there will be another update......
I used to game all the time on a PC, then wife and kids came along and I haven't had a chance. My wife bought me a PS4 about 3 years ago and I reckon it's had less than 100 hours of use, partially due to the number of updates it's needed - as I don't use it often, pretty much every time I do, there is an update. Just ordered a new gaming laptop, so will hopefully be playing more soon.
This has been my problem in the recent past too. I got rid of a PS4 for that reason.

Have succumbed though and bought an XBox One X to play Forza Horizon 4 on. Not relishing the updating regime.

RizzoTheRat

29,164 posts

223 months

Friday 19th October 2018
quotequote all
rallyeS2 said:
it’s amazing how “budget creep” kicks in and before you know it the build is up to silly figures!
Glad it's not just me hehe I've just built a new PC and started off with something similar to CaptianCynic's link, plus a 1080p monitor. I ended up with an overclockable i5, GTX1080 and a 2k 165Hz monitor for nearly double my original build price rolleyes I could have bought 2 consoles and a big TV for less money but I find a lot of the games I prefer are better on PC than consoles.

xjay1337

15,966 posts

149 months

Friday 19th October 2018
quotequote all
rallyeS2 said:
Loyly said:
Get both. I have an One X for console gaming and will soom be buying a new PC for gaming. They do different things so having both is the only option for me.
That would be ideal!! Sadly the “financial director” is a tricky one to slip such purchases past!
Some XBox games you can play on PC... very few are Xbox Exclusive.
I play Forza 4 on my PC , I also have a PS4 - seems perfect compromise to me.
My PC was £850 for i5 8540, gtx1060 and 8gb ddr4.
I bought Monitor , mouse and keyboard previously. All in cost around £1200 and that's with decent monitor etc. I have 240hz Zowie.

Deep Thought

40,169 posts

228 months

Friday 19th October 2018
quotequote all
[redacted]

Deep Thought

40,169 posts

228 months

Friday 19th October 2018
quotequote all
Very impressed with the One X. Have it up in my study running off a 55 inch 4K TV and a Sony 80W 2.1 sound bar so well pleased.

Took only around 3 hours for Forza to be ready to be playable (i''d thought a day) and i got a good 3 hours playing time at it this afternoon,

I'm running with Microsoft Game Pass for £7.99 a month which i think is a good deal as i can bore of games quite quickly. It also remembered me from the last time i'd an XBox One S so i've around another 70 or so games i can download from there from my profile so all good.