Think I am done with Apple
Author
Discussion

Otispunkmeyer

Original Poster:

13,835 posts

186 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
Not really looking for advice, just ranting!

I bought an iPad Pro 10.5 off eBay. 6 months old, seller with perfect feedback and plenty of sales. Wasn't a shop. Just a guy selling on a device he didn't really use due to his predicament with going in and out of hospital all the time. I got it, and noticed almost right away a large number of stuck-on red sub pixels. Painfully obvious on any dark image. I planned to use this for LR mobile photo editing. It has a dark UI and I have lots of dark images. So on a device like this, it is unacceptable I think.

To be fair to the seller, he may not have noticed if he never viewed much with a dark background. Certainly in day to day stuff (email, web browsing) you don't see it. He also packaged the thing up, in its original packaging, to the extent you'd be forgiven for thinking it was new. The screen protectors and sheathing and everything.

No worries. Won't bother the seller with this. Apple warranty for 6 months still. I'll send it in. They rejected the repair because its "bent/twisted". Sent me 1 horribly compressed jpg that shows a straight line of something black with a red arrow pointing at something. I can't tell what I am looking at and I can't figure their excuse for sending a 6 kb jpeg image in this day and age either. I just can't see how this has happened, I looked over the thing fastidiously when I got it. It was straight as a die.

Seller confirms he kept it in the rigid case he sent with it (as have I) and I have no reason to believe he hasn't been careful with it. He barely used it.

Basically, an imperceptible "bend" has meant they can only replace the whole thing. That'll be £426 please.

No thanks Apple. Tighter than two coats of paint.

I dunno what to do with it now. Its not worth what I paid due to the fault. It won't be repaired FOC either. And now using it for what I intended is very annoying because I have a big red blob looking at me the whole time I'm doing my photos. I guess I just have to keep it or take the hit.

We've gradually weened off Apple products as they seemed to become less and less worth it. But the iPads were different because they really do, do it best. But after this episode, I doubt I'll be bothering with Apple at all now. I know they won't mind...sitting on $270bn+ in cash. But they really do rub you the wrong way sometimes. Heck, even the discounted replacement isn't charitable in any way once you realise they would give you a good £300 for recycling it anyway.

Seller did offer to take it back, but wants to help see if we can get it done through Argos first (where he bought it from). Maybe I just send it him back and start over. That or take it to an Apple store. But I may just end up at square 1.


Edited by Otispunkmeyer on Tuesday 2nd October 14:18

kmpowell

3,557 posts

259 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
So to summarise:

OP buys a 6mth old second-had Apple product from eBay, which transpires to be faulty.
OP wants Apple to fix it FOC.
Apple rejects the claim because it's broken.
OP has no way of proving it isn't broken due to not owning the thing from new.
OP has the hump and is now feeling it's unjust and is "done with Apple".

All sounds very reasonable and balanced to me... rolleyes

Otispunkmeyer

Original Poster:

13,835 posts

186 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
kmpowell said:
So to summarise:

OP buys a 6mth old second-had Apple product from eBay, which transpires to be faulty.
OP wants Apple to fix it FOC.
Apple rejects the claim because it's broken.
OP has no way of proving it isn't broken due to not owning the thing from new.
OP has the hump and is now feeling it's unjust and is "done with Apple".

All sounds very reasonable and balanced to me... rolleyes
I knew this would be the first response. Typical PH.

The device is perfect externally. I just cannot see how they've managed to conjure up enough "damage" to write it off. Just doesn't feel right.

Even the seller is surprised and annoyed and has offered to take it back off me for full refund.

Edited by Otispunkmeyer on Tuesday 2nd October 15:01

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
As above really, but the seller sounds decent and it's got to be worth returning it to him and see whether he can convince Argos to exchange it?

nealeh1875

1,162 posts

123 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
At least the original seller is being reasonable and will take it back.

Can you claim on home insurance or gadget insurance via the bank maybe?

Or try taking it in directly. can they see how old/new it is from the serial maybe? worst option is the seller takes it back which seems very fair

Otispunkmeyer

Original Poster:

13,835 posts

186 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
Coin Slot. said:
As above really, but the seller sounds decent and it's got to be worth returning it to him and see whether he can convince Argos to exchange it?
That is my option for now. I actually feel bad for him because he's been rather excellent.

Shuvi McTupya

24,460 posts

278 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
nealeh1875 said:
At least the original seller is being reasonable and will take it back.

Can you claim on home insurance or gadget insurance via the bank maybe?

Or try taking it in directly. can they see how old/new it is from the serial maybe? worst option is the seller takes it back which seems very fair
I suspect that when you take it into the apple store they will say, no problem we will send it for repair.

Then they will put the serial number into their system and it will be flagged up as a broken ipad and it will be a 'computer say's no' situation.

I think option 1..let the seller return it to argos and wash your hands of it.

Personally i probably would never have noticed the issues and would have been happy with it!

WyrleyD

2,355 posts

179 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
Or you could contact Apple in Ireland and escalate the problem. I had the same with a macbook Pro when, for the second time, the screen failed (completely pixelated), so took it to the place that replaced the last screen and they swiftly said "no chance, you've broken it by bending it" yeah right! Not happy with that response I escalated it to Apple in Ireland and got hold of someone I could discuss it with and in the end got it repaired for free at another reseller repair centre which they arranged for me.

devnull

3,873 posts

188 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
I'll say one thing - Apple decides with stuck / dead pixels are virtually unheard of.

I wonder if the iPad had its screen replaced by a less than credible source?

The_Jackal

4,854 posts

228 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
Accept the sellers offer of taking it back.
Remember you would not have bought it had you known about the pixels, let alone pay that price.
You've been given an out, take it. Dont make life more difficult for yourself.

Fastchas

2,854 posts

152 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
I don't understand why you're faffing about with it...send it back to the seller for him to refund and sort it out. Whether or not he meant to sell a dodgy item, it's up to him to put it right with you so take him up on his offer.
No blame lies with Apple from my POV.

CanAm

14,201 posts

303 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
nealeh1875 said:
Can you claim on home insurance or gadget insurance via the bank maybe?
No, because the 'damage' did not occur during the OP's ownership of the goods.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
CanAm said:
nealeh1875 said:
Can you claim on home insurance or gadget insurance via the bank maybe?
No, because the 'damage' did not occur during the OP's ownership of the goods.
Although accidentally dropping out of an upstairs window onto the driveway might just do the job wink

deckster

9,631 posts

286 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
CanAm said:
nealeh1875 said:
Can you claim on home insurance or gadget insurance via the bank maybe?
No, because the 'damage' did not occur during the OP's ownership of the goods.
Although accidentally dropping out of an upstairs window onto the driveway might just do the job wink
Absolutely. Because no insurance investigator is ever going to think it suspicious when you put in a claim for a second hand item that you've just bought and is flagged by the manufacturer as being faulty.

shopper150

1,583 posts

225 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
Good luck with trying to get a Samsung repaired when you move over to them....

theboss

7,567 posts

250 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
Why not just buy a new one instead of taking your chances on eBay?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 2nd October 2018
quotequote all
deckster said:
Absolutely. Because no insurance investigator is ever going to think it suspicious when you put in a claim for a second hand item that you've just bought and is flagged by the manufacturer as being faulty.
HaHa

Uncool

486 posts

312 months

Thursday 4th October 2018
quotequote all
Couple of things. Firstly Argos are usually pretty good at returns. Maybe the seller can get it swapped.

Secondly, on the 10.5 is the touchscreen and LCD all 'one unit' or is there an air gap? If it's 'one unit' like I suspect it may be possible to rub the screen gently with some cotton buds to agitate the pixels into life.

Secondly, there are apps that you can use that cycle the colours on the screen very quickly to free up pixels too. At least there are apps on PC and Android. Anything similar in the Apple app storE?

Otispunkmeyer

Original Poster:

13,835 posts

186 months

Thursday 4th October 2018
quotequote all
Ok hear me out on this.

I just got it back.

Now, if this iPad is indeed bent...I think my understanding of straight and level needs redefining.

Unless they knock these things out the factory to the kind of "level" as per Rick and Morty "true level"

https://youtu.be/IMeain2cvBM

Then I don't think anyone normal would class mine as bent. I've had my straight edge on all 4 sides, back and front, and I am genuinely struggling, with my engineers cap on, to see how you could judge it as bent. I think I'd need to get my micron slip gauges from work to figure it out!




robbocop33

1,207 posts

138 months

Thursday 4th October 2018
quotequote all
kmpowell said:
So to summarise:

OP buys a 6mth old second-had Apple product from eBay, which transpires to be faulty.
OP wants Apple to fix it FOC.
Apple rejects the claim because it's broken.
OP has no way of proving it isn't broken due to not owning the thing from new.
OP has the hump and is now feeling it's unjust and is "done with Apple".

All sounds very reasonable and balanced to me... rolleyes
Unless it happens to you ofcourse. But you just buy goods, find out they are faulty, don't get annoyed, throw it in the bin, cheerfully exclaim 'C' est la Vie' and buy another one immediately!