Port Forwarding?
Author
Discussion

br d

Original Poster:

9,072 posts

257 months

Thursday 4th October 2018
quotequote all
I play a game that I have a port forwarded for. A few weeks ago it stopped working, all the port checkers showed it as closed. It was a pretty good Asus router but rather than mess about I bought a new one, an Asus RT-AC86U.
After setting everything up this wont open the port either. I have been very careful to put the info in correctly in the Routers settings and I haven't changed anything else on my network.
All the sites say it's probably a firewall issue but I can completely disable the Firewall on the PC, the firewall in the router and my anti-virus software so the PC is wide open and still the port is closed.

Anything obvious I should be trying?

GlenMH

5,473 posts

274 months

Thursday 4th October 2018
quotequote all
Stupid question... but: I have an asus router and there is a toggle switch in the UI to turn port forwarding on or off.

br d

Original Poster:

9,072 posts

257 months

Thursday 4th October 2018
quotequote all
GlenMH said:
Stupid question... but: I have an asus router and there is a toggle switch in the UI to turn port forwarding on or off.
Yeah that's on. Been through all the settings pretty thoroughly and everything seems right. Odd that it worked for a couple of years and then just stopped seeing the port with no changes to anything, that's why I changed the router rather than faff with tons of settings.

robbieduncan

1,993 posts

267 months

Thursday 4th October 2018
quotequote all
I assume your router requires a target IP to forward to? Is your PC on DHCP or static IP? If DHCP are you actually forwarding to the correct internal IP?

captain_cynic

17,660 posts

126 months

Thursday 4th October 2018
quotequote all
Could it be your ISP?

They sometimes block ports to stop viruses or spam.

What port is it?

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 4th October 2018
quotequote all
Have you tried reinstalling the game? The install process sometimes open the ports on the local machine (albeit not the router itself).

Are you sure the issue is the port forwarding and it's not that the game isn't listening on that port (check with a "netstat -an" in a cmd window).

Some routers don't allow you to add say a port and an IP because that port is already open in a list they "helpfully" already have open for you like say: RDP or CallOfDuty or ... etc. So when you try to add your port it doesn't add it as it is already open but as a standard thing like "WorldOfWarcraft" or something.

br d

Original Poster:

9,072 posts

257 months

Thursday 4th October 2018
quotequote all
I have set a static IP, it's been on one since I first set the game up. The game is Elite Dangerous and the port is 5100 which is recommended by Frontier (game developers).

The game doesn't open ports, I think the vast majority of players don't bother with it but I find I have a lot less issues in game with it open.

In the past I have just set up the forwarding and then confirmed it with any of the online port checkers. I've reinstalled the network adapter and updated all drivers and firmware.

I don't think reinstalling the game would help as the port should open regardless. I've tried many other ports just to test and so far only 80 works.