Why is it that you can easily get wi-fi range extenders...
Why is it that you can easily get wi-fi range extenders...
Author
Discussion

guindilias

Original Poster:

5,245 posts

151 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
But not Bluetooth range extenders?
Just wondering, I have a Wi-fi extender which is brilliant (just like a radio repeater station I suppose) - but nothing for Bluetooth?

bigandclever

14,423 posts

269 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
Avantree oasis?

techguyone

3,137 posts

173 months

Friday 12th October 2018
quotequote all
That's because Bluetooth was purposely designed to be a short range medium unlike Wi-Fi If you're requiring vast distances I'd suggest not using Bluetooth and using Wi-Fi

Edited by techguyone on Friday 12th October 21:58

guindilias

Original Poster:

5,245 posts

151 months

Saturday 13th October 2018
quotequote all
Oh, I have Wi-Fi coverage, just curious why Bluetooth, which even dumbphones have, doesn't have extenders? Except for the one mentioned above, but I can buy a wifi extender that reaches 300m on a good day, but the bluetooth only extends by 50m for twice the price.
I don't NEED one, just curious!

bigandclever

14,423 posts

269 months

Saturday 13th October 2018
quotequote all
What’s the market for Bluetooth extenders?

devnull

3,873 posts

188 months

Saturday 13th October 2018
quotequote all
Yep, as above, Bluetooth was always designed to be short range.

guindilias

Original Poster:

5,245 posts

151 months

Saturday 13th October 2018
quotequote all
bigandclever said:
What’s the market for Bluetooth extenders?
People like me, who have loads of Bluetooth plugs etc., which could now be reused on other things now that I have Wi-Fi everything.
On my vast, semi-detached 3 bedroomed house estate, Bluetooth barely reaches upstairs from the front room, if I'm lucky. How am I meant to summons my Malaysian servants from their quarters, when they only have dumbphones?
I only bought two servants, now I'll need 2 more, at a much greater expense than a simple Bluetooth extender. Now I'll have to employ an extra servant just to summons the other two.

Oh, for the days when every room had a bell button that would ring a bell in the appropriate room. Gone are the days of yore - now I may even have to raise my voice, like a caveman. frown

vsonix

3,865 posts

194 months

Saturday 13th October 2018
quotequote all
It's a valid enough question, I know Bluetooth is meant as a nearfield type thing but there are times when it just isn't powerful enough. For instance, if I stream music from iPad to BT amplifier in my kitchen, it's fine if I'm sitting at the table, but if I walk over to the other side of the kitchen with the iPad because I'm using it to display a recipe I'm cooking, BOOM. Dropouts.
Or, I have a Bluetooth OBD scanner for my car and want to record a datafeed while I'm driving. My only OBD port is under the hood - the Bluetooth system isn't strong enough to keep a stable connection with my tablet inside the car.
But then every time I go to pair my car radio with my phone, I can see every single device in a 200m radius come up as a potential connection.

There are definitely times when my 'Personal Area Network' could do with a bit of a signal boost...

guindilias

Original Poster:

5,245 posts

151 months

Saturday 13th October 2018
quotequote all
Is your car OBD1? OBD2 cars must have a socket within reach of the driver's seat, and accessible without any tools. So if there isn't one above the pedals, it could be in the internal fusebox or behind the ashtray (a favourite of many makers).

They still don't make bloody Bluetooth range extenders though - I thought I might find one on Japanese sites - but of course most city people live in apartments bout the size of a bathroom, so it's not an issue there or in China.

Gawd, the sufferings of the middle classes... furious

Digger

17,073 posts

222 months

Sunday 14th October 2018
quotequote all
Isn’t the latest Bluetooth (5 is it ? ) supposed to improve on these minor flaws?

techguyone

3,137 posts

173 months

Sunday 14th October 2018
quotequote all
Yes but with some other issues.

The maximum range is longer. The Bluetooth 5 spec allows low-energy transmissions to sacrifice data rate for more range. A lot more range: up to four times the range of Bluetooth 4.2 LE, for a maximum of around 800 feet.

If you;re streaming a high quality audio source say to a bluetooth speaker, it may struggle if the data rate craps out.

Things like walls too, seriously make Bluetooth not so good. It was originally designed so you could have things like a bluetooth headset connected to your phone so you could go handsfree in your car etc, or for close range transference of files

Edited by techguyone on Monday 15th October 11:01

captain_cynic

17,657 posts

126 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
techguyone said:
That's because Bluetooth was purposely designed to be a short range medium unlike Wi-Fi If you're requiring vast distances I'd suggest not using Bluetooth and using Wi-Fi
This,

Complete lack of demand. Bluetooth also lacks bandwidth, BT 3.0 even uses Wifi (802.11) to do data transfers, BT is only used to negotiate the connection. For all the applications you'd want to use Bluetooth over longer ranges, wifi does it better.

Digger

17,073 posts

222 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
OK, so, super dumb question time.

How come you don't see any WiFi speakers, meaning one's you can connect to directly via WiFi wireless technology without having to connect and setup the speaker via the router or a bridge (Sonos for example)?

Does Bluetooth have lesser bandwidth compared with a WiFi connection?

I haven't thought this through have I?! smile

captain_cynic

17,657 posts

126 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
Digger said:
OK, so, super dumb question time.

How come you don't see any WiFi speakers, meaning one's you can connect to directly via WiFi wireless technology without having to connect and setup the speaker via the router or a bridge (Sonos for example)?

Does Bluetooth have lesser bandwidth compared with a WiFi connection?

I haven't thought this through have I?! smile
Wifi is only a data transfer protocol. Bluetooth has an audio transfer protocol (although it's terrible, anyone using Bluetooth speakers clearly doesn't care about reproduction quality).

In order to make a Wifi speaker, you need a different component to the networking hardware to decode the audio signals where as the Bluetooth chip will decode audio signals. Whilst this is easy to do with audio Coder/Decoders being cheap as chips you also need to ensure that the correct encoding is sent to it, so most Wifi speakers end up being complete general purpose computing devices like Amazon's Echo.

Bluetooth has a lower bandwidth because it uses a narrower frequency, BT 5.0 has a range of 2 Mhz which limits it to 2 mbps (Megabytes per second). Wifi G (802.11g) uses 20 mhz and has a maximum of 54 mbps, Wifi N (802.11n) can use up to 40 Mhz, giving it up to 300 mbps. This can be further increased by techniques such as MIMO (Multiple Input and Multiple Output) which sends concurrent signals on different frequencies.

vsonix

3,865 posts

194 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
guindilias said:
Is your car OBD1? OBD2 cars must have a socket within reach of the driver's seat, and accessible without any tools. So if there isn't one above the pedals, it could be in the internal fusebox or behind the ashtray (a favourite of many makers).

They still don't make bloody Bluetooth range extenders though - I thought I might find one on Japanese sites - but of course most city people live in apartments bout the size of a bathroom, so it's not an issue there or in China.

Gawd, the sufferings of the middle classes... furious
OBD1 only, so I have to use the port under the bonnet with a round to rectangular adapter.
I just want to do some live logging so I can better understand/eventually make tweaks to my ECU map. I've thought about finagling it so the BT/OBD adapter sits on the scuttle by the wipers but that doesn't work either.

And the best helpful advice I could get from the forums was to wire an internal OBD2 port in as there is space for one as USA cars of the same model were required to have OBD2 as early as MY95/96, but I would need to get to the relevant bit of the loom and splice one in which is approaching the limits maybe not of my ability but what I am prepared to do in the open air on my drive, as I've no garage.

sgrimshaw

7,587 posts

281 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
Are you using an OBD1 to OBD2 cable then plugging in the BT dongle?

If so, would an OBD2 extension be an easier option to get the BT dongle into the car?

budgie smuggler

6,088 posts

190 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
captain_cynic said:
Wifi is only a data transfer protocol. Bluetooth has an audio transfer protocol (although it's terrible, anyone using Bluetooth speakers clearly doesn't care about reproduction quality).

In order to make a Wifi speaker, you need a different component to the networking hardware to decode the audio signals where as the Bluetooth chip will decode audio signals. Whilst this is easy to do with audio Coder/Decoders being cheap as chips you also need to ensure that the correct encoding is sent to it, so most Wifi speakers end up being complete general purpose computing devices like Amazon's Echo.

Bluetooth has a lower bandwidth because it uses a narrower frequency, BT 5.0 has a range of 2 Mhz which limits it to 2 mbps (Megabytes per second). Wifi G (802.11g) uses 20 mhz and has a maximum of 54 mbps, Wifi N (802.11n) can use up to 40 Mhz, giving it up to 300 mbps. This can be further increased by techniques such as MIMO (Multiple Input and Multiple Output) which sends concurrent signals on different frequencies.
Not to be a but this is nearly all wrong.

edit: aren't you the same person who insisted the best way to st was to be sitting bolt upright? hehe

Digger

17,073 posts

222 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
budgie smuggler said:
Not to be a but this is nearly all wrong.

edit: aren't you the same person who insisted the best way to st was to be sitting bolt upright? hehe
Perhaps you could make the effort to not be a , and correct his detailed post accordingly.

budgie smuggler

6,088 posts

190 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
Digger said:
Perhaps you could make the effort to not be a , and correct his detailed post accordingly.
It's pretty difficult to do that since so much is wrong but okay.

The quality from bluetooth with aptx or aptx-hd is absolutely fine. If you do not believe me go and look up the ABX (double blind) tests on HydrogenAudio. Aptx-HD in particular is very nearly lossless, so the comments on quality are baseless. If anybody wants to argue this point, let me see your ABX logs.

There are several streaming technologies for wifi (AirPlay & DLNA for example), but it is true that they are not built in to the wifi spec (not that that makes any difference?)

My hifi amp has both airplay and DLNA built in, and you'll find most modern receivers have this so it is untrue that it most which have it are devices like the echo dot. (edit to add, I forgot - there are also many speakers which can use wifi streaming e.g the Sonos One, B&W have one, Panasonic do one, Sony do one etc etc, they tend to be higher end devices because it's more expensive to implement).



The frequency of bluetooth is not 2MHz but 2.4 GHz. The frequency of 802.11g is not 20MHz but also 2.4GHz. 802.11n uses either 2.4 or 5GHz and not 40MHz.

The bandwidth of bluetooth is almost nothing to do with the frequency but rather that it was designed to be a low power simple and physically small technology.

The last bit about 2 and 54 MBPS is mixing up two different units, megabits per second and megabytes per second.


Edited by budgie smuggler on Monday 15th October 17:05

captain_cynic

17,657 posts

126 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
budgie smuggler said:
It's pretty difficult to do that since so much is wrong but okay.

The quality from bluetooth with aptx or aptx-hd is absolutely fine. If you do not believe me go and look up the ABX (double blind) tests on HydrogenAudio. Aptx-HD in particular is very nearly lossless, so the comments on quality are baseless. If anybody wants to argue this point, let me see your ABX logs.
Incorrect, Bluetooth has to compress audio, it cannot do uncompressed audio because it simply lacks the bandwidth. APTX is still compressed. Compression always affects audio quality.

Bluetooth is designed for low power, short range use, in order to achieve this it sacrifices quality.

budgie smuggler said:
There are several streaming technologies for wifi (AirPlay & DLNA for example), but it is true that they are not built in to the spec (not that that makes any difference?)

My hifi amp has both airport and DLNA built in, and you'll find most receivers have this so it is untrue that it most are for devices like the echo dot.
Which ones are part of the 802.11 specification.

None, all require a separate processor (or a full SOC as the Echo you mentioned has).



budgie smuggler said:
The frequency of bluetooth is not 2mhz but 2.4 ghz. The frequency of 802.11g is not 20Mhz but also 2.4ghz. 802.11n uses either 2.4 of 5GHZ and not 40MHz.
Here you demonstrate you've got no idea what you're on about. For 802.11g:

2.4 GHz is the FREQUENCY
20 MHz is the FREQUENCY BAND

I.E. Chanel 1 is specified as 2.401 GHz - 2.423 GHz which is 22 MHz wide
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11g-2003#Ch...

Seems you're the one mixing up your terms here.

budgie smuggler said:
The bandwidth of bluetooth is almost nothing to do with the frequency but rather that it was designed to be a low power simple and physically small technology.
Except that the freqency range or band determines how much data you can send through one connection. Ultimately the frequency band width (see what I did there) limits your bandwidth. This is why we use things like MIMO to increase throughput without changing the frequency width.

The term "bandwidth" literally means the width of the frequency band.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bandwidth_(signal_pr...

budgie smuggler said:
The last bit about 2 and 54 mbps is mixing up two different units, megabits per second and megabytes per second.
Yep, a typo, you've got me there. Should be megabits per second. Grab onto that, hold it with all your might as all you've got is that I made a typo.

budgie smuggler said:
Like I said almost all wrong.
Except it wasn't and all you've shown is that you don't understand the technologies involved.

In fact by mentioning the Echo Dot... You've inadvertently demonstrated I was correct. Apart from a typo... You've got that typo to hold onto. Please regale us again about how you found a typo.