In Office365 we trust
Author
Discussion

Mojooo

Original Poster:

13,291 posts

211 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
I currently work for a large public sector employer - one that holds a lot of personal/sensitive information.

Our old IT system was quite good and secure
1) if we were in one of our buildings we could login with a user/ass
2) if we were outside/working at home we need the user/pass plus a PIN number plus a randomly generated number which comes from an app on our phone

Our IT have decided we are going to move over to Oiffce 365 and also use Sharepoint for all of our files. This essentially means that all our files are now held on Microsofts servers and we can login from anywehere to access our files and use Office365 to use Word/Excel etc.

This is of course great for flexibility which is why it was brought in.

I am amazed though that my employer (generally being quite safe) has done this move as there are a lot more security risks. For exmaple, if just one person loses their username/pass then potentially all files from that dept could be available for viewing. My own Sharepoint site has 50,000 documents.

The general argument is that well all emails/social media are held online and its MS that holds the data so its all good but both Facebook and Google have both recently had data losses as far as I recall.

The other thing is, and I am not sure how it does it - but MS must know all of our passwords because if I go to their website when I am at work I only need to put my email in and it automatically logs me in. So there are two points the user/pass could be lost - the user and MS.

Is anyone else going this way?

andyb28

1,168 posts

149 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
My company look after a number of NHS clients along with other general B2B clients.

Everyone is going in this direction pretty much. We have completed loads of migrations from Exchange / File Servers into the Cloud.
I understand your concerns, they are all things that could happen, but depending on how the sharepoint data is setup, there are ways to protect it better.

There are risks in all solutions when it comes down to humans and the way they use their services I guess.
Perhaps the benefits just do outweigh the negatives for this kind of setup.

More than happy to talk this through with you in more detail if you want an outside point of view.

Andy

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
Your perspective may be somewhat simplified. The amount of thought about access controls and data access rules will have been quite a lot, and certainly more than "give the password list to the boys in Redmond" hehe

sjg

7,690 posts

296 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
The usual setup is for servers within your network to handle the authentication - hence why when you're on the network, presumably signed in to a domain-joined PC, those servers can seamlessly log you in.

Many enable multi-factor authentication in Office 365 and then you get prompted for a number (or to authorise from the app if you use Microsoft's own auth app) for access from elsewhere. There's also lots of controls you can place around what can be accessed, from where and by whom - e.g. logged in with MFA but from a non-company device, get read-only access in a browser only, or to require that the most secure stuff can only be accessed from a company site on a company device.

Microsoft do security in the cloud much better than most orgs do on-premises IME. Simply being able say the data is on servers you control (and can see and touch) doesn't mean it's particularly well secured from threats.

blueg33

47,008 posts

255 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
We are going the same way next year. Our company has alot of construction contracts with the MOD and other sensitive clients. Apparently, they are all satisfied with the security protocols we will be running. Access to sensitive folders will still be controlled so people can only see stuff they are meant to see.

Mojooo

Original Poster:

13,291 posts

211 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
randlemarcus said:
Your perspective may be somewhat simplified. The amount of thought about access controls and data access rules will have been quite a lot, and certainly more than "give the password list to the boys in Redmond" hehe
True but at the end of the day, right now, if someone has my password they can log directly in and access all files on my Sharepoint site (which is a departmental wide one).

Maybe they will bring in 2 factor authorisation - which makes sense.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Monday 15th October 2018
quotequote all
Mojooo said:
randlemarcus said:
Your perspective may be somewhat simplified. The amount of thought about access controls and data access rules will have been quite a lot, and certainly more than "give the password list to the boys in Redmond" hehe
True but at the end of the day, right now, if someone has my password they can log directly in and access all files on my Sharepoint site (which is a departmental wide one).

Maybe they will bring in 2 factor authorisation - which makes sense.
Sounds like an "implementation issue" to me - we have Office 365 and I can only access the company server on a company device, and only then using the Authenticator app on my company phone to generate a PIN. The ability to lock it down is there but it has to be used.

mikeiow

8,205 posts

161 months

Tuesday 16th October 2018
quotequote all
The Microsoft MFA will certainly be the step that makes it a bit more secure......although it drives me up the wall:
Doesn’t seem to matter how often I click the “don’t ask for 7 days” checkbox, invariably I’m asked again within a day or two. Add to that I use an ipad and mobile for email, and you can imagine I spend half my life now authenticating.....or losing the will to perform work!

You want security holes, try using Microsoft OneNote.
Should be called AllNotes: there is no way to share a single note without giving the target access to ALL your notes. Shockingly non-enterprise!
Plus it grumbles about being unable to sync this or that, when most of the time I can see from other devices it IS syncing them.
Sorry, I find Microsoft infuriating these days....I think I need to get away from this industry!

Australiam

277 posts

160 months

Tuesday 16th October 2018
quotequote all
There are many factors at play here, which hopefully your security, design and risk team have worked through.These will require 3rd party security solutions to implement.

Options may include:

1 - 2FA as already mentioned. For most larger organisations, this will be combined with Single Sign on to alleviate the pain (and poor security) that comes as a result of many cloud based app's / many paswords
2 - Device Pinning - Making sure that only the devices that your company want you using, have access to the data. For example, they could decide that you can use your personal iPad, but you can only view data in o365, not to download it
3 - Application Encryption - they may decide that all data going into o365 is encrypted, so only people accessing via an approved route can see the data. This is often invisible to the user. One such example would be that when you try to login to o365 (often via an SSO solution) you are diverted through a reverse proxy, which has the keys on it. It means that anyone not on your VPN, not using your SSO, or on a correct device (all dependant on what your company has chosen) will not gain access.
4 - Data Centre focussed encryption - so that data stored at the DC can be locked, so that if the cloud provider suffers a breach, or subpoena the DC host cannot get access to anything not encrypted.
4 - Access controls - Using a solution, to control what you as a user can do with your data. For example, removing your ability to share files stored in OneDrive with anybody external to the group or organisation (as determined by your company)
5 - Policy - Especially when it comes to BYOD & Email (as these two are particularly difficult areas (esp for smaller organisations) to control.

So in summary, these and other mechanisms should have been considered, with the company deciding its preferred approach and attitude to risk.

For smaller organisations - it can be difficult, as all of these mechanisms come at cost, but there are still many steps that can be taken to reduce risk.




geeks

11,899 posts

170 months

Tuesday 16th October 2018
quotequote all
Sounds like they are using Conditional Access and or claims rules to decide how the logon request is dealt with. A 2FA solution should be implemented here as is best practice these days it's not even complicated to implement!

Hopefully they have DLP implemented as well or they could be in for a world of hurt!

Freakuk

4,896 posts

182 months

Tuesday 16th October 2018
quotequote all
All of the above, and you can still use a VPN to access 365 to add another layer of security.

MS employ lots of security controls now and as has been mentioned are probably more secure than your current on-premise solutions, GDPR would IMO driven a lot of the advancements in MS's direction.

Durzel

13,029 posts

199 months

Tuesday 16th October 2018
quotequote all
davepoth said:
Mojooo said:
randlemarcus said:
Your perspective may be somewhat simplified. The amount of thought about access controls and data access rules will have been quite a lot, and certainly more than "give the password list to the boys in Redmond" hehe
True but at the end of the day, right now, if someone has my password they can log directly in and access all files on my Sharepoint site (which is a departmental wide one).

Maybe they will bring in 2 factor authorisation - which makes sense.
Sounds like an "implementation issue" to me - we have Office 365 and I can only access the company server on a company device, and only then using the Authenticator app on my company phone to generate a PIN. The ability to lock it down is there but it has to be used.
This.

The tools are available. If you allow people to log in with nothing more than your password then that's a faillure of implementation, not the system itself.

wombleh

2,411 posts

153 months

Tuesday 16th October 2018
quotequote all
It can be loads better but one big problem is a lot of places move to cloud and carry on exactly as they did before, just treating it like someone else's datacentre.

That ticks the cloud box, but it can be way more expensive, misses out on the benefits and can even be much higher risk.

Mojooo

Original Poster:

13,291 posts

211 months

Wednesday 17th October 2018
quotequote all
You might be onto something... in that if I use my work tablet at office.com I don't need 2FA as it must recognise my device somehow.

When I go to office.com from my home PC I have to register (so not sure if 2FA is needed or not).


geeks

11,899 posts

170 months

Wednesday 17th October 2018
quotequote all
Mojooo said:
You might be onto something... in that if I use my work tablet at office.com I don't need 2FA as it must recognise my device somehow.

When I go to office.com from my home PC I have to register (so not sure if 2FA is needed or not).
Conditional access then, sounds like it has been done at least half correctly.