iPhone xs v iPhone xr
Author
Discussion

Chrisgr31

Original Poster:

14,299 posts

286 months

Thursday 18th October 2018
quotequote all
I was looking at an iPhone xs last week, which would be to replace my Sony phone which is now 3 years old. Dont really need a new phone, and certainly not one with all the features as most surfing etc is done on my iPad.

However feels its time for a new phone and as my daughter as an iPhone 7 I think I should have a better phone than her!

Whilst in the shop they mentioned the iPhone xr is released tomorrow and maybe I should wait for it. Its a slightly lower spec than the iPhone xs in particular the screen, and only as single camera each side against the dual camera on the xs. However is also cheaper.

So any thoughts on whether the xr is value for money against the xs?

33q

1,630 posts

154 months

Thursday 18th October 2018
quotequote all
I planned to go for the XR but I went for the XS as screen is very slightly smaller and the telephoto camera won me over

I really like the XS but I'm still not sleeping well having committed to a £999 phone!

tim0409

5,985 posts

190 months

Thursday 18th October 2018
quotequote all
I've read quite a lot about the Xr and the general consensus is that it's an excellent alternative to the Xs.

Chrisgr31

Original Poster:

14,299 posts

286 months

Thursday 18th October 2018
quotequote all
33q said:
I planned to go for the XR but I went for the XS as screen is very slightly smaller and the telephoto camera won me over

I really like the XS but I'm still not sleeping well having committed to a £999 phone!
Must admit the price of the XS is a bit off putting, but then the screen is excellent

Scobblelotcher

1,724 posts

143 months

Thursday 18th October 2018
quotequote all
tim0409 said:
I've read quite a lot about the Xr and the general consensus is that it's an excellent alternative to the Xs.
I had planned to go for the Xr but that screen quality is important to me (I know it’s subjective) and I think it would annoy me given it’s a long way behind the quality of the XS range. For many it may not be an issue but it is for me. It’s a shame as the hardware is similar apart from the camera.


MYOB

5,131 posts

169 months

Friday 19th October 2018
quotequote all
Isn't anyone thinking about the size of the XR? It's bigger than the XS and may not suit many.

Wait until you can see one before you decide.

funinhounslow

2,023 posts

173 months

Friday 19th October 2018
quotequote all
Just to muddy the water a bit...

The XR lacks 3d touch, a 2x zoom lens and has the same pixel density as the iPhone 8.

Depending on how important these are to you the 8+ might be a better shout.

As noted above you probably need to see them all in the flesh to make a final decision. But on paper I think the 8+ still makes a compelling case at its current price.

GTO-3R

8,008 posts

244 months

Friday 19th October 2018
quotequote all
I'm going looking at an XR on my lunch break today with a view to ordering if I like it. I'm not fussed about having the latest screen but the reason I'd go for the XR over the 8 is the tech inside and future proofing myself a bit. I'll be having it for the next 3-4 years so it needs to keep up with future updates!

alorotom

12,794 posts

218 months

Friday 19th October 2018
quotequote all
I’m debating changing my X for the XR as I really fancy a coloured phone again and am sick of the X silver (I always use my phones without a case)

Ill probably go for the red or yellow but will have a better look in person probably over the next week or so and go from there.

Ruskie

4,532 posts

231 months

Friday 19th October 2018
quotequote all
If you can get a good deal on a X I would consider that. It’s absolute phone perfection IMO. I don’t need anything else again.

GTO-3R

8,008 posts

244 months

Friday 19th October 2018
quotequote all
No physical phones in until next Friday rolleyes

Not sure how they expect people to part with at least £750 without even seeing it tbh!

Walter Sobchak

5,739 posts

255 months

Friday 19th October 2018
quotequote all
I decided to go for it and pre ordered an XR in red today, I still think it’s expensive but couldn’t part with £999 for the XS, it will be a great replacement for my rather battered and broken 6S Plus I think.
I will let you know what I think when I get it.

Chrisgr31

Original Poster:

14,299 posts

286 months

Friday 19th October 2018
quotequote all
alorotom said:
I’m debating changing my X for the XR as I really fancy a coloured phone again and am sick of the X silver (I always use my phones without a case)
That's another issue, why spend £1k on a phone and then shove it in a case so no one can see it! The guy in the shop the other day did say a selling point for the XR was the choice of colour.

Of course one advantage of the 8plus is it will be easier to say my daughter shouldnt have an XR or XS next Christmas!