Best way to record CCTV streams?
Discussion
I've got 4 or 5 cameras in a remote property I'd like to record 24/7 and be able to access the recordings immediately from home so local recording on SD card is not an option.
They're a mix of Foscam and Hikvision and are IP cameras set up with port forwarding on the local router so I can access them and record with local software such as iSpy already, but I need a solution which will save all the streams all the time for at least 1 week at a time so I don;t want to dedicate a PC here to do that task.
Should I FTP to cloud-based storage? If so, which one would be good for this task (I've no cloud storage at all currently other than Dropbox/Mega)
I already have a couple of NAS units at home with enough space but I'm not keen on opening up the FTP ports on those as I had a bad experience with that in the past. I could buy another NAS and dedicate it to the task, but it would need to be very secure.
Recommendations?
They're a mix of Foscam and Hikvision and are IP cameras set up with port forwarding on the local router so I can access them and record with local software such as iSpy already, but I need a solution which will save all the streams all the time for at least 1 week at a time so I don;t want to dedicate a PC here to do that task.
Should I FTP to cloud-based storage? If so, which one would be good for this task (I've no cloud storage at all currently other than Dropbox/Mega)
I already have a couple of NAS units at home with enough space but I'm not keen on opening up the FTP ports on those as I had a bad experience with that in the past. I could buy another NAS and dedicate it to the task, but it would need to be very secure.
Recommendations?
Why are SD cards not an option, for the Hikvsions at least?
Sounds like I have a very similar set up to you (a mix of Foscams & Hikvisions, in my case in a holiday home). I have a permanent VPN to the remote location and I have immediate access to anything the Hikvisions record, using iVMS.
Foscams are more of a problem as they don’t seem to allow remote access to SD card recordings but longer term I’m looking to dump them and replace with Hikvision as the Hiks are functionally so much better.
I did look into Cloud services. I suspect you’d end up paying for both the Hik & Foscam services but what really put me off was the impact on my broadband: having 4 cameras continually uploading to the cloud wouldn’t leave much for anything else.
Sounds like I have a very similar set up to you (a mix of Foscams & Hikvisions, in my case in a holiday home). I have a permanent VPN to the remote location and I have immediate access to anything the Hikvisions record, using iVMS.
Foscams are more of a problem as they don’t seem to allow remote access to SD card recordings but longer term I’m looking to dump them and replace with Hikvision as the Hiks are functionally so much better.
I did look into Cloud services. I suspect you’d end up paying for both the Hik & Foscam services but what really put me off was the impact on my broadband: having 4 cameras continually uploading to the cloud wouldn’t leave much for anything else.
Edited by duttonst on Monday 29th October 09:48
duttonst said:
Why are SD cards not an option, for the Hikvsions at least?
Sounds like I have a very similar set up to you (a mix of Foscams & Hikvisions, in my case in a holiday home). I have a permanent VPN to the remote location and I have immediate access to anything the Hikvisions record, using iVMS.
Foscams are more of a problem as they don’t seem to allow remote access to SD card recordings but longer term I’m looking to dump them and replace with Hikvision as the Hiks are functionally so much better.
I did look into Cloud services. I suspect you’d end up paying for both the Hik & Foscam services but what really put me off was the impact on my broadband: having 4 cameras continually uploading to the cloud wouldn’t leave much for anything else.
I'm not dumping the Foscams just yet. I went through 2 or 3 different PTZ cameras before going with the Foscams as they at least work most of the time. Sounds like I have a very similar set up to you (a mix of Foscams & Hikvisions, in my case in a holiday home). I have a permanent VPN to the remote location and I have immediate access to anything the Hikvisions record, using iVMS.
Foscams are more of a problem as they don’t seem to allow remote access to SD card recordings but longer term I’m looking to dump them and replace with Hikvision as the Hiks are functionally so much better.
I did look into Cloud services. I suspect you’d end up paying for both the Hik & Foscam services but what really put me off was the impact on my broadband: having 4 cameras continually uploading to the cloud wouldn’t leave much for anything else.
It is possible to extract clips from the Foscam's SD cards, but it's very slow and unreliable.
I had a look again at my Synology NAS packages and am testing Surveillance Station now. It looks like it could be the answer and is secure enough for my purposes. Doesn't seem to be having much impact on that NAS's performance with a couple of cameras recording all the time, so as long as it doesn't fill the disk up too quickly I'll probably go with that.
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


