Mobility of NAS drives
Discussion
I've got a WD MyCloud NAS - has two 4Tb drives which I run in RAID 1. I'm pretty sure that WD use their Red drives in it.
In WD's bumpf, they make clear that the drives are fully swappable, from each other and into other MyCloud enclosures.
So far... so good.
What I want to know is, if I took them out of the WD enclosure, and put them into a Windows server (which already has an SSD for the OS) would they be happy, and still have all my files on them and get straight back into their existing RAID relationship?
And if the answer is 'yes, they'd be fine', if the new server had four bays, and I popped another couple of 4Tb drives in with them, would they sort themselves into an 8Tb RAID 1 array, with no loss of existing data?
In WD's bumpf, they make clear that the drives are fully swappable, from each other and into other MyCloud enclosures.
So far... so good.
What I want to know is, if I took them out of the WD enclosure, and put them into a Windows server (which already has an SSD for the OS) would they be happy, and still have all my files on them and get straight back into their existing RAID relationship?
And if the answer is 'yes, they'd be fine', if the new server had four bays, and I popped another couple of 4Tb drives in with them, would they sort themselves into an 8Tb RAID 1 array, with no loss of existing data?
In a Raid 1 configuration the same data is written to both drives.
Putting one (or other) of them in the server should (as WD say) allow your data to be seen.
Unless the server has some Raid software or hardware, then putting them both in will not necessarily allow them to operate in a Raid configuration with redundancy (so you would see two copies of your data).
Putting even more drives in without Raid controller software/hardware will give you greater capacity, but without the redundancy of a Raid array.

Putting one (or other) of them in the server should (as WD say) allow your data to be seen.
Unless the server has some Raid software or hardware, then putting them both in will not necessarily allow them to operate in a Raid configuration with redundancy (so you would see two copies of your data).
Putting even more drives in without Raid controller software/hardware will give you greater capacity, but without the redundancy of a Raid array.

V8mate said:
Just didn't know if there was any difference between the operation of WD's controller, and how their NAS OS formatted the drives, compared with a Windows server.
That I don't know. It's more than likely that they will use a standard format for the disks - your WD documentation may confirm this, and whether it is compatible with the formats supported by your Windows Server.I would be surprised if this will work. For a start, it's likely that the drives are formatted to ext4 which is a Linux format and not immediately usable by Windows. You can get ext4 drivers for Windows but those I've tried have been read-only and pretty flaky at that.
Even if the drives were formatted to NTFS or FAT32, then RAID tends not to be compatible across controllers so putting both drives in and expecting the array to work is a non-starter.
Personally the only way I'd try this would be to set up the new RAID array in the target server and then leave it copying files for a few days.
Even if the drives were formatted to NTFS or FAT32, then RAID tends not to be compatible across controllers so putting both drives in and expecting the array to work is a non-starter.
Personally the only way I'd try this would be to set up the new RAID array in the target server and then leave it copying files for a few days.
deckster said:
I would be surprised if this will work. For a start, it's likely that the drives are formatted to ext4 which is a Linux format and not immediately usable by Windows. You can get ext4 drivers for Windows but those I've tried have been read-only and pretty flaky at that.
Even if the drives were formatted to NTFS or FAT32, then RAID tends not to be compatible across controllers so putting both drives in and expecting the array to work is a non-starter.
Personally the only way I'd try this would be to set up the new RAID array in the target server and then leave it copying files for a few days.
That's a great idea. KISS.Even if the drives were formatted to NTFS or FAT32, then RAID tends not to be compatible across controllers so putting both drives in and expecting the array to work is a non-starter.
Personally the only way I'd try this would be to set up the new RAID array in the target server and then leave it copying files for a few days.
Put the two new drives into the new server. Copy the data across, then chuck the old drives in and let Windows format them before adding them (now blank) to the RAID array.
Cheers
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


