Credit Card Fraud
Author
Discussion

SS9

Original Poster:

477 posts

190 months

Wednesday 31st October 2018
quotequote all
I've recently been a victim of Credit Card fraud (I say victim - the transactions have been removed from my account so I wouldn't really class myself as a victim).

The transactions stood out because they appeared on a card I haven't used for 6+ months.

When speaking to the fraud team, they stated that the transactions were done 'online' (aliexpress.com) and that the IP address of the transactions mapped to somewhere in Poland. The transactions were in US dollars and attracted a foreign transaction fee.

This got me thinking.... How did the bank know the transactions were carried out in Poland? I'd always assumed the bank would see the transactions happening from where the website was hosted?

There's a fair chance I'm missing something obvious (which would be embarrassing given I work in IT!). Is there a protocol where the merchant has to pass on transaction details to banks at point of sale or something?!

KrazyIvan

4,341 posts

206 months

Wednesday 31st October 2018
quotequote all
I assume they can request the info from the website to prove the validity of the purchaser

Ransoman

884 posts

121 months

Wednesday 31st October 2018
quotequote all
The IP address of the purchaser might have been located in Poland, but the fraudster was most likely using a VPN to hide his origin. He could have been located anywhere in the world.

SS9

Original Poster:

477 posts

190 months

Wednesday 31st October 2018
quotequote all
KrazyIvan said:
I assume they can request the info from the website to prove the validity of the purchaser
The fraud team person I spoke with did a lookup in real time whilst I was on the phone. It sounded as though the details of origin IP of any online transaction are passed to the bank at point of sale. Something I never appreciated happened until now.

WinstonWolf

72,863 posts

270 months

Thursday 1st November 2018
quotequote all
Ransoman said:
The IP address of the purchaser might have been located in Poland, but the fraudster was most likely using a VPN to hide his origin. He could have been located anywhere in the world.
Yup, I use a VPN to watch iPlayer when I'm abroad. The internet *thinks* I'm in the UK but I'm not...

eltawater

3,554 posts

210 months

Thursday 1st November 2018
quotequote all
SS9 said:
KrazyIvan said:
I assume they can request the info from the website to prove the validity of the purchaser
The fraud team person I spoke with did a lookup in real time whilst I was on the phone. It sounded as though the details of origin IP of any online transaction are passed to the bank at point of sale. Something I never appreciated happened until now.
Some websites can pass on the origin IP of the customer to their payment processor as part of the payment transaction request. This information can be used to assess levels of fraud or unusual patterns of transactional behaviour and flag the potential fraud risk back to the merchant website, who can then take a decision on whether or not to accept the transaction. Same goes for cardholder address, email address etc.

captain_cynic

17,656 posts

126 months

Thursday 1st November 2018
quotequote all
I believe that originating IP is also included in the transaction information for online transactions. So the merchant and payment provider know the IP the transaction was originated from.

But this.

Ransoman said:
The IP address of the purchaser might have been located in Poland, but the fraudster was most likely using a VPN to hide his origin. He could have been located anywhere in the world.

NDA

25,837 posts

256 months

Thursday 1st November 2018
quotequote all

I paid for someone's flights and holiday last year. The website (Jet2) who took the booking on my card could not tell me 'under data protection' rules who the passengers were or the destination.

However, a website, Expedia, phoned me to take authorisation for a further booking in Tenerife - and that's how the fraud was discovered. Expedia were very helpful, although they still couldn't tell me the name of the people

However, my bank did. Names of passengers, airline, destination hotel, dates etc. All information that the Police took no interest in.

My card refunded my money and I have no idea how my card was compromised.

bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Thursday 1st November 2018
quotequote all
Yes I had similar. Several transactions on my Lloyds Bank Amex card all in US $’s for internal US flights and goods. Easy to spot the fraudulent transactions as they were in $’s.

sgrimshaw

7,587 posts

281 months

Thursday 1st November 2018
quotequote all
Again similar situation for me.

In my case the card had never been used, had been in my safe since delivery.

When I asked how the fraudsters might have got the card details they admitted that it's often trial and error ... they keep trying different numbers until one works, then they do the same on the expiry date etc.


captain_cynic

17,656 posts

126 months

Thursday 1st November 2018
quotequote all
sgrimshaw said:
Again similar situation for me.

In my case the card had never been used, had been in my safe since delivery.

When I asked how the fraudsters might have got the card details they admitted that it's often trial and error ... they keep trying different numbers until one works, then they do the same on the expiry date etc.
Contactless?

The contactless protocol sends out your card number, expiry date and name in encryption so weak it may as well be clear text.

And this isn't some super secret protocol, you can develop an application from the free specifications available from Visa and MasterCard's web sites. You can use off the shelf NFC hardware (like the hardware found in most, if not all Android phones these days). The whole thing was designed with security as an afterthought. I've got an app on my phone written by a security researcher, secured and censored to PCI-DSS standards that can retrieve your card details using my phone's built in NFC transceiver.

This is why I physically disable contactless on all my cards (using a Stanley knife to cut the induction loop) but I'm still concerned as I've had no control over it through the post.

55palfers

6,396 posts

195 months

Thursday 1st November 2018
quotequote all
captain_cynic said:
Contactless?



This is why I physically disable contactless on all my cards (using a Stanley knife to cut the induction loop) but I'm still concerned as I've had no control over it through the post.
Where is the induction loop please? I shall do the same.

Every time I get a new card it's contactless, despite me telling the issuer I never, ever, under any circumstance want Contactless.

Then I have to phone, press 1, press 6, press 4, press 3, wait, wait, wait then "answer a few security questions" to get a non-Contactless card.

This option looks much simpler.

captain_cynic

17,656 posts

126 months

Thursday 1st November 2018
quotequote all
55palfers said:
Where is the induction loop please? I shall do the same.

Every time I get a new card it's contactless, despite me telling the issuer I never, ever, under any circumstance want Contactless.

Then I have to phone, press 1, press 6, press 4, press 3, wait, wait, wait then "answer a few security questions" to get a non-Contactless card.

This option looks much simpler.
Here's a rather brute force instruction set that kind of explains it.
https://www.instructables.com/id/How-to-Disable-Co...

And a less brutal one:
https://robinminto.com/blog/post/2014/03/21/Disabl...

You only need to use a small incision rather than gouging out huge parts of your card but it needs to be deep enough to cut the layer with the induction loop. I usually have to take a few passes before it's deep enough.

Induction loops can be in different configurations so if you run a torch behind your card you should be able to see them. If you cant, trial and error is best to the right of the chip. The chip will still work without the loop BTW.

Induction loops on a card (as seen via a CT scanner)

The_Jackal

4,854 posts

228 months

Thursday 1st November 2018
quotequote all
Pre 2000 I knew that there were employees within the banks passing info on customers to gangs, including PIN numbers.
I would hope that technology, security and procedures would stop that these days but you never know.
I've seen cheques cashed with extra digits added in pencil as well where the words didn't match the amount.
No point worrying though because there is nothing you can do if you are unlucky enough to be hit. Just hope your bank is sympathetic and helpful.

simion_levi

257 posts

253 months

Thursday 1st November 2018
quotequote all
NDA said:
I paid for someone's flights and holiday last year. The website (Jet2) who took the booking on my card could not tell me 'under data protection' rules who the passengers were or the destination.

However, a website, Expedia, phoned me to take authorisation for a further booking in Tenerife - and that's how the fraud was discovered. Expedia were very helpful, although they still couldn't tell me the name of the people

However, my bank did. Names of passengers, airline, destination hotel, dates etc. All information that the Police took no interest in.

My card refunded my money and I have no idea how my card was compromised.
When this happened to me, I contacted the fraud team at the airline involved (Wizzair) in the faint hope that it might bugger up the travel plans for a scumbag, or their associate. The flight was scheduled a day or so later and they were very keen to get me to email across a simple declaration that I, as the cardholder, had not authorised payment for the tickets, so they could have a welcoming committee waiting for the passenger.

SS9

Original Poster:

477 posts

190 months

Friday 2nd November 2018
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies folks... You've confirmed my suspicions regarding the sharing of data. All makes sense and now I've thought it through it's obvious to be honest.

sgrimshaw

7,587 posts

281 months

Friday 2nd November 2018
quotequote all
captain_cynic said:
Contactless?
No, it was a while ago ... card was not contactless.

55palfers

6,396 posts

195 months

Saturday 3rd November 2018
quotequote all
captain_cynic said:
Here's a rather brute force instruction set that kind of explains it.
https://www.instructables.com/id/How-to-Disable-Co...

And a less brutal one:
https://robinminto.com/blog/post/2014/03/21/Disabl...

You only need to use a small incision rather than gouging out huge parts of your card but it needs to be deep enough to cut the layer with the induction loop. I usually have to take a few passes before it's deep enough.

Induction loops can be in different configurations so if you run a torch behind your card you should be able to see them. If you cant, trial and error is best to the right of the chip. The chip will still work without the loop BTW.

Induction loops on a card (as seen via a CT scanner)
Thank you.

Thats What She Said

1,180 posts

119 months

Saturday 3rd November 2018
quotequote all
simion_levi said:
NDA said:
I paid for someone's flights and holiday last year. The website (Jet2) who took the booking on my card could not tell me 'under data protection' rules who the passengers were or the destination.

However, a website, Expedia, phoned me to take authorisation for a further booking in Tenerife - and that's how the fraud was discovered. Expedia were very helpful, although they still couldn't tell me the name of the people

However, my bank did. Names of passengers, airline, destination hotel, dates etc. All information that the Police took no interest in.

My card refunded my money and I have no idea how my card was compromised.
When this happened to me, I contacted the fraud team at the airline involved (Wizzair) in the faint hope that it might bugger up the travel plans for a scumbag, or their associate. The flight was scheduled a day or so later and they were very keen to get me to email across a simple declaration that I, as the cardholder, had not authorised payment for the tickets, so they could have a welcoming committee waiting for the passenger.
Names of passengers / hotels / dates etc wouldnt be of any use to the police (neither would a welcoming committee).

The fraudsters that buy the tickets with stolen credit card details never actually travel anywhere. They contact the airline/hotel before the travel date and give a story saying they cant travel on that date, so would like a flight/hotel credit.

The fraudsters then go onto Craiglist / forums etc and sell the flight / hotel credit (with a made up story explaining why they cant use it) to an unsuspecting victim. The unsuspecting victim pays for the flight / hotel credit using an untraceable payment method (Western Union etc).

Fraudster gets money, victim gets a flight / hotel credit they cant use, because by that time the airline / hotel is made aware it was gained from a fraudulent payment.

NDA

25,837 posts

256 months

Saturday 3rd November 2018
quotequote all
Interesting.

I clearly don't have a criminal mind!