Using old gen 1 SD cards with computer
Using old gen 1 SD cards with computer
Author
Discussion

jakesmith

Original Poster:

9,497 posts

202 months

Friday 2nd November 2018
quotequote all
I bought a San Disk 2GB SD card to use in my old Audi (it has a limit of 2GB per card)
The issue is my laptop can't write to them - it starts copying files but then fails
The eBay seller will accept it back but also questioned my sanity for thinking it would work on a modern latop
Any clues here? Is my laptop trying to write to it too fast, is there some freeware I can use to make this work? I've had a look on Google but not found a lot so far

xeny

5,540 posts

109 months

Saturday 3rd November 2018
quotequote all
I don't see why it wouldn't work. How new is the laptop? Have you tried a USB card reader as well as the built in slot? Have you tried reformatting the card?

I think I've got a couple of 512MB cards unused I can experiment with....

The_Jackal

4,854 posts

228 months

Saturday 3rd November 2018
quotequote all
SD isn't obsolete, that seller is just flogging dodgy cards bought in bulk from China, probably knows nothing about actual computers or technology.

twister

1,594 posts

267 months

Saturday 3rd November 2018
quotequote all
Mmm, whilst older readers may not be able to read newer cards, I've never had any problems with older cards being readable on newer readers.

jakesmith

Original Poster:

9,497 posts

202 months

Sunday 4th November 2018
quotequote all
Thanks for this! The seller is adamant that they are right so I have asked eBay to step in to help
It's a white-knucked ride and I'll be back to update y'all


deckster

9,631 posts

286 months

Sunday 4th November 2018
quotequote all
The_Jackal said:
SD isn't obsolete, that seller is just flogging dodgy cards bought in bulk from China, probably knows nothing about actual computers or technology.
I suspect this, very much.

There is no reason why your laptop should fail to write to a genuine SD card whatever the capacity. Fakery is rife in the SD-card world and eBay in particular is full of hookey cards.

S6PNJ

5,866 posts

312 months

Sunday 4th November 2018
quotequote all
Download and run https://www.softpedia.com/get/System/System-Miscel...

This will write and read from your card to its stated capacity and will tell you if it is fake or not.

jakesmith

Original Poster:

9,497 posts

202 months

Sunday 4th November 2018
quotequote all
S6PNJ said:
Download and run https://www.softpedia.com/get/System/System-Miscel...

This will write and read from your card to its stated capacity and will tell you if it is fake or not.
Ahh wish I'd seen that before - I have just sent it back for a refund.
Seller is saying they are rejecting my return but I think they are not familiar with eBay as now for faulty returns eBay is heavily skewed in favor of the buyer and they send me a return label which the seller pays for and they automatically refund me when the return is delivered
They were saying I would have to pay return postage & their paypal fees etc. I tried to explain the process but they didn't want to know!

jakesmith

Original Poster:

9,497 posts

202 months

Sunday 4th November 2018
quotequote all
Here is the thread in case you can't sleep. I tried to be humorous and friendly and respectful throughout
Start from the bottom and a virtual pint to anyone who can be arsed to read it!!
eBay have now settled in my favour and provided FOC a return label




Here's what happened
Nov. 4 :A return request was initiated

Nov. 4 :Case opened
CommentsHello, I believe these cards are faulty. SD is not a legacy standard and should be compatible with my laptop. The seller is stating that I will have to return them at my own expense and then they will deduct a proportion of the refund to allow for PayPal fees which I believe is not in line with eBay policy on faulty refunds The seller has been responsive but we have not managed to agree a process that I believe will see me treated in line with eBay policy

Nov. 1 :You sent a message
CommentsHello and hi Are you certain. That shouldn’t have been the case. If you look at the refund it should have only cost you what you banked from the initial payment. So for example if you sold something for £10 and got to keep £9.50, it usually only costs you £9.50 to refund the buyer £10. Also did you follow the eBay process to cancel the second transaction with the buyer. If you do that then you get the final value fee refunded and that’s 10% so much higher than the PayPal fee I don’t know the circumstances of your transaction but that is certainly how I have experienced it for the last several years Thank you very much I hope this was informative and helpful

Nov. 1 :The seller sent you a message
CommentsNo, it wasn't a disputed transaction. The person hit the button twice to place the order. The order hadn't been posted. The buyer asked for a refund which I did (because I'm a nice person). I hit the refund button. I got charged by Paypal, in other words I paid back more than I had received. I disputed this with Paypal, they told me the Paypal fees are payable on refunds.

Nov. 1 :You sent a message
CommentsDear Linda Thank you very much for this last message which is both useful and informative. Without wanting to sound patronising, I would advise you to check out eBay and PayPal’s processes around cancelled sales. If a sale is cancelled by mutual agreement and a refund is made, the full final value fee is refunded. If the PayPal transaction is refunded by opening PayPal and clicking the ‘refund’ button, the seller receives the proportion of the fee back that relates to the refund The only circumstances where this doesn’t apply is if the buyer escalates the transaction to a claim and eBay settles it in the favour of the buyer in which case the final value fee is not refunded I am only telling you this to help you out If you refund my money you will not pay a PayPal fee so there is no need to deduct this from my refund. I’m not sure why you experienced something different to this but if you look into the circumstances I’m sure it will become clear. Maybe you didn’t refund the buyer via the ‘refund’ button or maybe it was a disputed transaction Again I am only trying to help you here I do hope you find this information helpfully and useful and interesting Many thanks

Nov. 1 :The seller sent you a message
CommentsHi As I have previously mentioned I do not accept returns because these are genuine items. On this occasion I have offered to possibly give you a partial refund if you return them to me and I find they have not been tampered with. The partial refund will consist of the price you paid less Paypal fees providing they have not been tampered with in which case I will give you what I consider to be fair. I feel that I am being very fair in this instance especially as considering you have made claims of 'fake' 'faulty' and in your last message you implied I may be dishonest in my findings should you return them. I have sold many of these SD cards and not had any claims that you are making with regard to faults/fakes. You are welcome to contact Ebay if you wish but either way you will have to return them to me before any sort of refund can be considered. With best regards Linda

Nov. 1 :You sent a message
CommentsHello and thank you for your messages so far I like you and would like to sort out this matter Please can you confirm your proposed solution and we can do that to fix this problem I am happy to escalate this to eVay but also am happy to try and fix it without eVay Many thanks and goodbye for now All the best.

Oct. 29 :You sent a message
CommentsHello again and thank you for this useful and interesting information. A particularly fascinating background and thank you very much for telling me about it. One of my good friends was part of the team responsible for developing BS 6001-1999+A1:2011 and he often discusses that, and our other interest, semiconductors, over a warm drink. I wonder if you are familiar with the latest revision of ISO Amendment 1:2011? It seems that despite the best intentions and an ongoing dialogue, that we have maybe reached an impasse. I fear that if I return the SD cards to you that they may fail some form of inspection and that you do not feel that a refund is in order. I know in my heart that I have not interfered or tampered with the cards. I have only tried to use them on an ancient laptop, the exact purpose of which, is a secret that I will not reveal This is my largest concern you see. I would like with your enthusiasm, to allow eBay to decide the outcome of this case and would ask that you maintain a friendly demeanor for this next step. Thank you

Oct. 29 :The seller sent you a message
CommentsHello again The last message I sent did quote Ebay's policy on returning items. Those words were copied & pasted for you. Having had extensive experience within Quality Management Systems and Quality Assurance within the engineering industry myself and using BS6001 as a standard, unless a complete batch is faulty - which it is not, the likelihood of two consequtive items being faulty is highly remote.

Oct. 29 :You sent a message
CommentsHello, and thanks you for your message which I have received this afternoon. I am very sorry but I am finding you to be unnecessarily confrontational and unhelpful I am afraid. I have only tried to help you and have been polite throughout. Unfortunately the terms of trading on eBay are set by eBay and not yourself and I believe you are not complying with eBay policy with regards to this I am concerned about your suggestion of returning these items to you outside of eBay's process, and your talk about deciding about partial refunds, as it leaves me unfairly exposed. Can you please send me a returns label as per eBay's policy so that I can return the SD cards to you for a refund. If this is not possible I will have to escalate this to eBay who will be the arbiter of who owes what. In this situation if eBay decide in my favour the seller does not receive a credit for the FVF - just letting you know out of fairness to you Many thanks again for your help and I do hope we can resolve this in a respectful and amicable manor without the need for any further antagonistic comments. I was only mentioning my background in semiconducters to make you feel more comfortable with the situation & I am very sorry that you don't think it is relevant Thanks again for all your help and looking forward to resolving this soon

Oct. 29 :The seller sent you a message
CommentsHello again In response to your last message 1) I do not accept either card to be faulty - I don't need to look at them 2) I do not accept returns so the policy is: "We ask the buyer to return the item to you within 14 working days* from when they first opened the return. The buyer is instructed to pack the item carefully and return it in the same condition as it was received. Learn more about the item condition policy for returns." 3) Refunds incur Paypal fees - I found this out when I refunded someone after they messaged me to say they had ordered twice, I refunded more than they paid me - Paypal fee incurred. 4) You are an IT professional and have a masters degree in semi conductor engineering? Not really necessary to state this because its irrelevant and even so why did you try to format the SD cards - they don't need it. 5) I have been very kind to you by offering to take back the SD cards at your expense, and upon receipt I will consider whether to make a partial refund if they have not been tampered with. I have not changed my mind on that, but I am not paying the postage when I know for a fact that the items are NOT faulty. They were sent in protective cases so couldn't have been damaged in transit. 6) As I understand it you did not purchase the item, it was purely sent to your address? I suggest you settle for what I have offered after all if you haven't tampered with the item it will merely cost you the return postage.

Oct. 29 :You sent a message
CommentsHi there, thank you very much for your last message. Firstly, I am very sorry that you feel that way - but I believe that eBay policy allows the return of faulty goods to the vendor - you have not even seen the returned product yet so I'm not sure how you can be certain about whether they are faulty or not. You also earlier said you would accept them back but now seem to have changed your mind? I am very sorry to say that I do not believe you are being very helpful to me I am afraid. I am also very sorry but I don't believe you can 'dismiss' a refund' as part of this process, I am able to close the claim but at the moment am unfortunately not able to do so. You are not leaving me with any alternative but to escalate this to a claim with eBay It is worth noting that when a vendor makes a refund, your paypal and final value fees are also refunded as part of that - but not if the buyer escalates it to a claim that eBay upholds. I am just trying to help you out by making you aware of this - I do suggest you appraise yourself of eBay's policies as they have changed in the last few years I would appreciate it if you were more helpful to me please and send me a returns label as these cards do not appear to work. As I said before I am an IT professional (and have a masters degree in semiconductor engineering) so do know my stuff! Many thanks and in keen anticipation of your reply

Oct. 29 :The seller sent you a message
CommentsHi, I do not know of such a policy. And as far as your claim is concerned I do not accept that one of the SD cards is faulty and certainly not two. Therefore I am dismissing your request.

Oct. 28 :You sent a message
CommentsPlease can you send me a return label as per eBay's policy Many thanks

Oct. 26 :The seller sent you a message
CommentsHi, You're quite welcome to return them if you wish but I will need to check whether they've been tampered with and decide on a partial refund or not. As for being an IT specialist - I can assure you that they are not faulty, neither are they fake. I sell many of these and to many companies who are extremely happy with them. They are the original SanDisk SD cards - the first ever made and quite frankly I'm surprised you thought they would work on a laptop unless it's extremely old. As for the packaging, they come in a protective case so don't need any other protection and I send them this way to keep the costs down.

Oct. 26 :You sent a message
CommentsHello there and thanks for your message I’m an IT Professional and have worked in IT since the 1990’s. I know full well how to select the correct SD card you see. They came in opened packaging wrapped in newspaper so hardly meet anyone’s definition of new and / or even maybe authentic Would like like to return them for a refund please as they are faulty

Oct. 26 :The seller sent you a message
CommentsHi As it says on my advert "please make sure these are the correct items for you as I do not accept returns". I sell these items brand new and considerably cheaper than elsewhere, but they are not faulty. I suggest that you have purchased the wrong type of card for your use. My SD cards have a read/write speed of '2' Perhaps you should read your instruction manual to see what speed you require. Unfortunately as I sell them brand new I do not accept returns and also Paypal charge me so I end up paying more than what I have received. Apart from that you would have to post them back to me at your cost by recorded delivery. It would probably be cheaper for you to resell. Like I said the SD cards are brand new and direct from the manufacturer so they are certainly not faulty in any way. Hope this helps regards

Oct. 26 :You requested a return
CommentsHello Unfortunately these SD cards do not seem to work, every time I try to copy files to them I get write errors unfortunately I have tried formatting them & using a different laptop but no joy I m afraid