Chromebooks - any good if not connected to wifi?
Chromebooks - any good if not connected to wifi?
Author
Discussion

NiceCupOfTea

Original Poster:

25,608 posts

282 months

Friday 9th November 2018
quotequote all
Looking for something small/light/cheap to use on the go for Word and displaying PDFs etc. Considered a Windows 10 Surface Pro type thing or even an iPad but so expensive for what I need it for. Currently use an old Hudl2 Android 8" tablet with bluetooth keyboard.

I gather they are OK but need a permanent wifi connection to be much use. I'll spend a fair bit of time out of reach of wifi, will it still be useable? What's storage like? Can it be expanded with a decent size microSD card? Eventually I would want to have a large amount of data (in PDFs) on it.

And finally, are there any with a 2-in-1 form factor where I could fold the keyboard back to view PDFs etc.?

Slushbox

1,484 posts

136 months

Friday 9th November 2018
quotequote all
There's the Lenovo Yoga ChromeBook, has a flip lid. Also availble in a 128GB SSD version so plenty of storage.

Don't know if they run Word as an Android app yet. Google Docs will export PDFs.

Mine annoyed me by slightly fiddly need to set up 'CloudPrint' on my printer, which didn't like it.

Mine was also fairly limited offline though you could take notes. May have improved since then.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Lenovo-N23-Yoga-Chromeboo...

https://support.google.com/chromebook/answer/32146...


Corso Marche

1,907 posts

232 months

Friday 9th November 2018
quotequote all
PDF's are not a problem, just get something with decent storage. Or use fast Micro SD cards with large capacity. Or an external SSD or HDD.

Office will depend on what Word files you use, and what you do with them. They'll edit Word files using an offline Office extension from Google, but if there's complex formatting there'll always be hassle with formatting being displayed correctly. If your files are simple then there will be few issues.
If you have an Office 365 subscription then you can run the official Office android apps, if they have enough functionality for you.
The other option is using an office suite on Linux such as Libre Office etc, but again there will be formatting issues unless your Word docs are simple. Linux apps now run side-by-side with Chrome OS apps, web apps, and Android apps, so there is no geekery involved.
You can also run MS Office 2016 for Windows using Crossover for Chrome OS, just like with Crossover on Mac or Linux, but the earlier options above are simpler and more robust.

My Pixelbook is my sole computing device now, because as above it's virtually platform agnostic at this point allowing me to use apps from 4 different OS platforms. FWIW, I've given up on Word and solely use Google Docs, as my use doesn't require Word.

Lots of convertible form factor Chromebooks available, depending on budget.


Edited by Corso Marche on Friday 9th November 07:46


Edited by Corso Marche on Friday 9th November 07:47

Slushbox

1,484 posts

136 months

Friday 9th November 2018
quotequote all
^^^

Useful post, thank you. I recently considered a Chromebook for general use and travelling, but need Word and Publisher. Also have two subs to Office 2016 I wanted to use.

Ignorance prevailed: Argos had a Lenovo 330s Windows 10 laptop for £299 with a 125GB ssd, so I bought that. I think a Chromebook would have worked for me.

NiceCupOfTea

Original Poster:

25,608 posts

282 months

Friday 9th November 2018
quotequote all
Thanks guys, been looking at the newish Asus Chromebook flip c3xx which looks good, albeit a bit steep for a Chromebook. Word files not that complicated but they do use a template which has some funky formatting.

I also use a couple of proprietary windows apps but I looked into the surface pro route and it would be very expensive for a decent spec.

NiceCupOfTea

Original Poster:

25,608 posts

282 months

Friday 9th November 2018
quotequote all
I have been using word mobile on android for the editing, I assume that will run on Chrome OS...

Slushbox

1,484 posts

136 months

Friday 9th November 2018
quotequote all
NiceCupOfTea said:
Thanks guys, been looking at the newish Asus Chromebook flip c3xx which looks good, albeit a bit steep for a Chromebook. Word files not that complicated but they do use a template which has some funky formatting.
You could run them into Google Docs on a PC before purchasing a C.B. to check, possibly?

Brainpox

4,331 posts

182 months

Friday 9th November 2018
quotequote all
I'm a big proponent of Chromebooks/Google Docs but compatibility with Word is still way off tbh.

Corso Marche

1,907 posts

232 months

Friday 9th November 2018
quotequote all
NiceCupOfTea said:
I have been using word mobile on android for the editing, I assume that will run on Chrome OS...
Yes, it runs fine.

Slushbox

1,484 posts

136 months

Wednesday 21st November 2018
quotequote all
November 2018.

Greed has triumphed over logic. I scored an Asus 'ruggedized' C202SA ChromeBook from Amazon in the Black Friday grab-fest. £129.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/ASUS-C202SA-GJ0027-11-6-i...

It's the base model but has an Intel N3060 processor, 2GB of RAM, and a 16GB 'hard drive.' Media storage can be added to the SD card slot. I have added 32GB for a tenner.

C202SA appears to be indestructable. If it were a car it would be a Suzuki Jimny. Blue legends on keytops annoy. It's spill-proof and bash-proof. It has a nice keyboard travel. 11.6" screen OK for portabiilty and browsing, not so good for novel writing. NetFlix and Amazon vids run stutter free in the Chrome browser.

The Amazon C202SA comes with a £10 credit for Office 365. Word and Excel need a subscription, but Outlook/OneDrive do not.





Edit:

I returned the CB after a couple of days. The cons were that the 11.6" screen was too small, and the Files browser wouldn't pick up a shared drive. Also the CB wouldn't see my ZTE 3G dongle. Apparently the Huawei dongles work fine

I'd still consider one for a travel laptop, but overall, preferred Windows 10 machines as they are much more versatile and I can use Office/Publisher off-line with them.

If you're mostly a Google Docs/email user, then a CB might work well for you. They do appear to have evolved a lot in the last couple of years.




Edited by Slushbox on Saturday 24th November 07:11

Corso Marche

1,907 posts

232 months

Wednesday 21st November 2018
quotequote all
Nice summation. £140 on a Chromebook is likely better spent than £140 on a new Windows machine though, all things considered.
You're obviously comfortable with it. It's possible to install a software centre so you can install Linux apps with a mouse click if you were looking for convenience, rather than using the command line each time, or even just download the debian package for the app and launch it with a double click.
As you've discovered 2GB of RAM is barely sufficient, 4GB is capably sufficient on ChromeOS, but as with everything the more RAM the better. 2GB restricts you to 1 or 2 tasks at a time. But still, £140 for a ruggedised and usable machine with that amount of storage is still damn cheap !

Corso Marche

1,907 posts

232 months

Wednesday 21st November 2018
quotequote all
Slushbox said:
The embedded 'running Linux as a VM' is not so useful as apps can't access the SD card.
Shared access to folders for Crostini/android/ChromeOS has just made it's way into the beta channel of the OS, where the user decides what folders are shared. Once fully tested it'll probably hit stable OS releases sometime in the spring, at a guess. I think Crostini just received access to USB devices in the beta channel too, but not checked for certain as of yet.

NiceCupOfTea

Original Poster:

25,608 posts

282 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
Well I bought an Asus C302 in a black Friday deal for £400.

Had it a couple of days and the jury is still out.

Pluses:
Great screen
Small & light
Great battery life
Great screen

Minuses:
Lots of things that I never consdered would be a thing, are things.
- access to the filesystem is clunky, built in Files app won't let you at the internal storage, and OneDrive access is flaky. I have installed a couple of Android apps for files, FX which doesn't seem to work as well as it does on Android, and Solid Explorer which comes recommended but I have found it to be flaky.

- syncing doesn't work very well. GoogleDrive on my W10 laptop keeps everything local so you can use all files fine when you are out of wifi reception, syncing when you are back online. I had assumed that it would work the same on Chrome OS, but you have to specify which files you want available offline. You can't even specify a folder to be available offline. As a result I think I am going to have to keep the files locally and use an Android app like FolderSync or OneSync to syncronise them to Google Drive or OneDrive.


I get that they are designed to use the cloud and be always connected, but this is the UK, and you can be out of phone reception plenty, let along wifi access. Offline access is very important to me. I thought I would be OK as the things I needed access to when out and about are a few dozen small word files and a bunch of big PDFs that won't need syncing. The PDFs are not a problem as they life on the microSD card, but syncing the Word files is very annoying.

I don't think I'm going to send it back, but right from the word go I am having to bodge things with apps and it doesn't seem that I want to do anything particularly odd (working offline). I would be very hacked off if I'd spent a grand on a Pixelbook though. I also don't know what else I could use to do the job - 4 figures on a Surface Pro, or £1100+ on an iPad Pro with 256GB of storage. I wonder whether a cheap 10" Android tablet and an old netbook paired together might have done the job just as well though!

Some Guy

2,687 posts

122 months

Tuesday 27th November 2018
quotequote all
I have an Asus C302 as well. Its primarily used as a media machine when traveling (music, movies and internet), or viewing work documents (PDFs and Drawings) when at customer sites. For that, its pretty ideal. I dont bother syncing it and keep everything I need locally (256GB memory card)

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 27th November 2018
quotequote all
On my second c302. First one lasted about a year until one of the hinges broke. Bought a replacement about two weeks ago with the M7 processor rather than the M3 in the standard version.

Hardly any faster - should have saved the money and just got another standard version which at £400 I think is good value.

Corso Marche

1,907 posts

232 months

Tuesday 27th November 2018
quotequote all
I'm not sure why you'd want access to the OS files on Chrome OS. That's the exact opposite of the ethos of Chrome OS.
The Files app is to manage user files; offline/locally cached/online on Google Drive/on a shared network etc

Once you know to mark files for offline access it's not an issue. Not for me anyway.

I had a C302 on trial for a couple of months in 2017 and it's a nice machine. It was what helped me in making a decision to jump to a Pixelbook this year.
If you find Chrome OS isn't for you just install Gallium OS on it and you can have the best of both worlds. I ran Gallium OS on the C302 I had as a trial and it was flawless. I even ran Windows 10 in a virtual machine, and whilst it was too slow for productive use, it was still acceptable to view Word files or the like if you had to.

As is, if you have an Office 365 subscription just install the OneDrive app and Word. OneDrive and Word should then sync everything automatically, just as on a Windows machine.

Edited by Corso Marche on Tuesday 27th November 10:11

NiceCupOfTea

Original Poster:

25,608 posts

282 months

Tuesday 27th November 2018
quotequote all
I don't want to access OS files (although it is nice to be able to get in there), but it would be nice to have a Documents folder on the tablet itself - there's only a Downloads one that the system will delete stuff from as and when. It would be nice to have transparent access to Google drive and OneDrive.

I do actually use Android Word already but OneDrive doesn't hold files offline at all unfortunately.

I will solve the problem by using Android Word and saving files on the SD card (although this isn't as simple as it ought to be) with an app to sync with the cloud when I am connected. It should work but it's unnecessarily complicated and would be easily sorted with a better File app and a tweak to enable files to be cached locally from the cloud by selecting a folder. At the moment you have to set it for each one individually which is just silly.

AJB88

16,006 posts

202 months

Tuesday 27th November 2018
quotequote all
You do have access to Google Drive from the file manager as long as your logged into an account. In my 4+ years of using ChromeOS I have never had the OS delete files "as and when" either.

Corso Marche

1,907 posts

232 months

Tuesday 27th November 2018
quotequote all
NiceCupOfTea said:
I don't want to access OS files (although it is nice to be able to get in there), but it would be nice to have a Documents folder on the tablet itself - there's only a Downloads one that the system will delete stuff from as and when. It would be nice to have transparent access to Google drive and OneDrive.

I do actually use Android Word already but OneDrive doesn't hold files offline at all unfortunately.

I will solve the problem by using Android Word and saving files on the SD card (although this isn't as simple as it ought to be) with an app to sync with the cloud when I am connected. It should work but it's unnecessarily complicated and would be easily sorted with a better File app and a tweak to enable files to be cached locally from the cloud by selecting a folder. At the moment you have to set it for each one individually which is just silly.
I've not lost anything in circa 4 years of use either, but I use a micro SD card as storage on one CB, and the internal storage capacity on the Pixelbook is more than ample for my use.
What I can confirm from seeing it on my wife's machine and students machines is that if the internal storage comes close to full the machine will slow to a crawl and become unusable before it deletes anything. So you'll know well in advance that something is up. This happens because the Files app is continuously caching content locally from frequently used and recently accessed files on Drive.
Incidentally, you can also set your download location to wherever you like e.g. a folder in Google Drive, an SD card, an external drive, a network drive etc It doesn't have to be on the internal storage. So you could create whatever folder structure you wish, have the Downloads folder nested in it somewhere, and leave the internal storage for caching and Play store apps.

As an experiment I've just knocked off the wi-fi on my smaller CB which only has 16GB internal storage, and it allowed me to open the most recent versions of all my GSuite files since the 28th October, so it seems to store a cache of approx. 1 month locally.
I do my GDrive management in the Files app, and also manage over 3TB of files on my NAS (usually accessing it 4-5 times a week).

According to MS the OneDrive app will sync files and folders locally for offline access. You just have to select the folder(s) (or files) to be stored for offline use.
See the link below, hopefully it helps;
https://support.office.com/en-us/article/read-file...

Edited by Corso Marche on Tuesday 27th November 19:46

NiceCupOfTea

Original Poster:

25,608 posts

282 months

Wednesday 28th November 2018
quotequote all
Oh wow - that's not what I'd managed to turn up in my research last night, so that gives me some hope. Thanks chaps!