Good price for a laptop!
Author
Discussion

KrazyIvan

Original Poster:

4,341 posts

206 months

Sunday 18th November 2018
quotequote all
So what's a good price for a laptop these days.

Short story is the boy (14) and a few of his mates have started teaching themselves mobile gaming code (using Stencly). one of them has a half decent laptop and 2 have old hand me downs. He wants its for coding, compiling as well as some basic video editing (different hobby) and some 3d art drawing using a free programme whos name i cant remember.

His 1st suggestion is this

https://www.laptopsdirect.ie/msi-gp73-leopard-8re-...

Seems like a good laptop and spec and should last him a few years.

But it's a bit above budget, and yes it has to be a laptop, as I am pushing his school to allow them to do it in their after school club.

But before I blow my hard earned on helping him strike it rich, thought I'd see what the general consensus is.

deckster

9,631 posts

286 months

Sunday 18th November 2018
quotequote all
That's a pretty decent gaming laptop but not great for coding.

If it's genuinely for coding, he needs a much bigger SSD, lose the HDD completely, double the RAM, and get rid of the graphics card.

It won't run Fortnite nearly so well, but will be a much better bet for actual work.

KrazyIvan

Original Poster:

4,341 posts

206 months

Sunday 18th November 2018
quotequote all
deckster said:
That's a pretty decent gaming laptop but not great for coding.

If it's genuinely for coding, he needs a much bigger SSD, lose the HDD completely, double the RAM, and get rid of the graphics card.

It won't run Fortnite nearly so well, but will be a much better bet for actual work.
Appreciate that, will look into a different setup, he won't be gaming on it, other then running the mobile games there working on.

dern

14,055 posts

310 months

Sunday 18th November 2018
quotequote all
deckster said:
That's a pretty decent gaming laptop but not great for coding.

If it's genuinely for coding, he needs a much bigger SSD, lose the HDD completely, double the RAM, and get rid of the graphics card.

It won't run Fortnite nearly so well, but will be a much better bet for actual work.
Can't agree with this. Haven't run Stencly but I code Java/Javascript/Python for work and code with C# and Unity for a hobby and that spec with be really good. I've done a bit of C++ and Unreal too but only to view as an alternative to Unity. You definitely don't need more memory than 16Gb, it'll be fine for all sorts of work. It will be quicker with and SSD instead of the standard harddrive but it's not required. The graphics card will enable you to run unity and unreal to write 3d games if he gets that far without having to upgrade and will enable him to run blender and the like to do 3d modelling.

mikef

6,158 posts

282 months

Sunday 18th November 2018
quotequote all
dern said:
deckster said:
That's a pretty decent gaming laptop but not great for coding.

If it's genuinely for coding, he needs a much bigger SSD, lose the HDD completely, double the RAM, and get rid of the graphics card.

It won't run Fortnite nearly so well, but will be a much better bet for actual work.
Can't agree with this.
Indeed. It’s spurious advice. I work with hundreds of developers who get a dev laptop with 16Gb RAM, 512GB SSD and i7 CPU, either a Dell XPS or a MacBook Pro. I’ve never once had a request for more memory or internal storage. The graphics card makes sense if developing games. Just use the HDD for file history; down the line it can be replaced with a second SSD, they get cheaper and bigger all the time. This is easily enough spec for dev work and probably also a nice gaming machine which may be what he really wants

KrazyIvan

Original Poster:

4,341 posts

206 months

Sunday 18th November 2018
quotequote all
No helping guys hehe interesting take as his little group were initially looking at unreal as the engine and due for the cost (and lack of coding experiance) I talked them out of it, as I had concerns at the cost of a laptop to run it well.

Appreciate all views on this as I am not keen to blow nearly €1.5k on somrhing that is not right for its primary purpose.

The 3d software is called Blender by the way. Not sure if that needs to be taken into account.

dern

14,055 posts

310 months

Sunday 18th November 2018
quotequote all
I run blender on a similar spec machine and it runs fine. I do not have commercial experience of unity or unreal but am doing this as a hobby. I've been writing commercial code for just shy of 30 years and my main language is java with about 20 years and I did C for about 10 before that.

I've chosen Unity to continue with because...

C# is closer to what I'm used to to, Java.
It's free up until you start making $100k a year.
There are loads of good courses on it and loads of building block in the asset store.
I've found it 'friendlier' to use than Unreal.
The graphics are good enough for the sort of games I can build on my own.

I didn't like Unreal as much because...

I don't have as much experience with C++ and found that it was a huge step backwards compared to what I've been doing over the last 20 years in terms of ease of use and ability to make progress quickly. This will completely be down to personal experience and preferences.
I really didn't like the way it crashed the Unreal Editor if I made a mistake in my code.
Compile time was slow.
However, the graphics were pretty amazing.

This is a very good course on learning C# while learning Unity and is £9.99 at the moment.
https://www.udemy.com/the-ultimate-guide-to-game-d...
They also do a companion course on blender if they're not all over that already.

Just one comment though... if you want to create 2D games and go easy on the particle systems you can use a less powerful and cheaper laptop. It just might get frustrating though.

KrazyIvan

Original Poster:

4,341 posts

206 months

Sunday 18th November 2018
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice guys. Chatting to the boy he's really not after it for gaming, has a ps4 (same as his mates) for that.

He has some experience with scratch (same guys who developed stencly) and I think this may be a good starting point, as it will be easier to get their ideas (at least basic to mid) into actual games. Kinda hoping he will be able to build on this in to more complex programming and a good future.