CAD people, What's the best package to design a track car?
Discussion
Hi Pistonheads
If you have experience in using Car design software to model track/racing car - including simulation critical aspects such as chassis, suspension and aerodynamics - then I need your advise ;-)
Call me mad…but as a pet project at home, I want to build my own track car, just for the purse pleasure of it. Something similar in dimensions to a F3 car, but less complicated as in where the chassis is the body (like the Ariel Atom). Idea is to make the chassis (body) from Carbon Fiber make it structurally rigid and to keep the weight down.
Idea is to make the carbon fiber moulds in my garage and buy in the auxiliaries (like suspension, wishbones, dampers, engine, gearbox …).
Can anyone advise what’s the best CAD design software to us. Would be nice to be able to select and scale existing components (like wishbones, dampers, steering rack, seats, gearbox) so you don’t have to spend time drawing them yourself.
I’ve both Windows and Mac. Would AutoCad Alias be a good start?
Thanks very much in advance guys and girls for any advise, tips, or suggestions :-)
Have pleasant day
Dave
If you have experience in using Car design software to model track/racing car - including simulation critical aspects such as chassis, suspension and aerodynamics - then I need your advise ;-)
Call me mad…but as a pet project at home, I want to build my own track car, just for the purse pleasure of it. Something similar in dimensions to a F3 car, but less complicated as in where the chassis is the body (like the Ariel Atom). Idea is to make the chassis (body) from Carbon Fiber make it structurally rigid and to keep the weight down.
Idea is to make the carbon fiber moulds in my garage and buy in the auxiliaries (like suspension, wishbones, dampers, engine, gearbox …).
Can anyone advise what’s the best CAD design software to us. Would be nice to be able to select and scale existing components (like wishbones, dampers, steering rack, seats, gearbox) so you don’t have to spend time drawing them yourself.
I’ve both Windows and Mac. Would AutoCad Alias be a good start?
Thanks very much in advance guys and girls for any advise, tips, or suggestions :-)
Have pleasant day
Dave
My bet is that if it does exist, you can’t afford it. It would possibly cheaper to buy an X-Bow.
Just to design the tub, you would need the skill to rough out the design for suspension / engine pickups, to understand the loading inputs, in order to undestand static / dynamic loads followed by impact / rollover loads. Then you add ancillary for cooling etc and then a CFD package for the aero.
You might be far better off doing what most kit car manufacturers do and just guess what looks about right and double it.
Andy Bates probably has all the ancillary bits that you will need to complete the task.
Just to design the tub, you would need the skill to rough out the design for suspension / engine pickups, to understand the loading inputs, in order to undestand static / dynamic loads followed by impact / rollover loads. Then you add ancillary for cooling etc and then a CFD package for the aero.
You might be far better off doing what most kit car manufacturers do and just guess what looks about right and double it.
Andy Bates probably has all the ancillary bits that you will need to complete the task.
Im a draughtsman in civil engineering, we use autocad, revit, c3d etc and licences for these range from £3500-£9000 per seat!
Take a look at the autodesk website to see the full range of software they do, if you can sign up as a student you get to use ALL the software for free.
Also look at Catia and NX(somethingorother) as they are more mechanical engineering orientated.
You’ll also need analysis software unless you find a package with it built in.
Take a look at the autodesk website to see the full range of software they do, if you can sign up as a student you get to use ALL the software for free.
Also look at Catia and NX(somethingorother) as they are more mechanical engineering orientated.
You’ll also need analysis software unless you find a package with it built in.
Thank you AWRacing, FukeLreeman and Generationx for your wonderful feedback.
Before you read my answers to your questions (see near end), I think it would be polite of me to explain the design brief of the rack car and the chassis. Then you have a better picture of what I’m trying to do.
The chassis is not going to be a carbon fibre monocoque, like a F1, McLaren car or Alfa 4C.
Instead it’s going to be a tubular carbon fiber chassis/body similar to the Arial Atom, but with a 1 seater F3 layout (longitudinal engine and transmission layout in the rear). A very lightweight 1.6 Litre engine and transmission (120 kg) will be placed behind the bulk head with a low centre of gravity.
The chassis/body will consist of
All carbon fibre cross-member-frames will have M10 to M20 mounting nuts cast within them, to attach the wishbones, suspension, peddles, steering, seating, engine mounts, diff, and other auxiliaries. That's where CAD comes in, to get their placement and rigidity right.
This “for me anyway” - as I’m not a qualified mechanical engineer - makes the design simpler and easier to implement at home in my garage with CF sheet and moulds I create with a CNC machine out of stacked MDF or the like.
My focus is designing, and moulding the chassis (body) in carbon-fiber, all other mechanic parts and auxiliaries with be bought. For the chassis, would FEA help to make sure its torsional rigid in the right places especially where mounting point for the engine and the like are; and where vibration can occur. My biggest concern for the chassis is testing torsional rigidity, and figuring out where additional carbon fiber needs to be placed to enforce it, where engine parts and other load bearing CF cross-member-frames join. Know if I have made the longitudinal oval hollow carbon fibre tubes wit the correct wall thickness is important.
As for CFD, I don’t think I need terminal or fluid dynamics analysis, a the car has a naked chassis (well ventured), and all other parts like the engine, brakes etc will be purchases performance parts.
If you have any experience/pointers on how best to mould them, that would be very helpful. My idea is to use 4 layers of carbon-fiber sheets on the outside of the wall, then a honeycomb centre, and finally 4 layers of carbon-fiber on the inside of the wall. I’ll have to figure out some way of testing it. I’ve planned the wall thickness to be 3-4 mm overall and at mounting point increase to 8 mm to be safe. Would this make sense guys?
Whoooo AWRacing you really use allot of AutoCad software. Must be cool stuff. I currently use AutoCad Fusion 360, to Model 3D parts for around the house. I print them with my 3D printer (PRUSA i3). Fusion 360 does have other features like Generative Design, Render, Animation and Simulation. But I have never needed to try them yet, especially Simulation which - according to their info popup - helps determine how loads lead to deformation. They use a front bike fork as an example. So with that in mind, you all have made me aware of it...thanks guys. Could I use this feature to test the chassis oval tubes - if the software knows the torsional rigidity of carbon fibre in m3?
Gentlemen, If I can get a student licence for Catia, and I have additional questions on how best to use it, would you mind if I come back to pluck your brains, as ye’er all fountain of knowledge to me.
Excuse me guys if I many have used any incorrect lingo. I’m a Software engineer, and not a Qualified Mechanical or CAD engineer. But I dabble in both because I love what yee do and create, and want to do the same in my own little way during my spare time.
Many thanks again guys for your advise, tips and answers, I really really appreciate it.
Have a wonderful evening
Dave
Before you read my answers to your questions (see near end), I think it would be polite of me to explain the design brief of the rack car and the chassis. Then you have a better picture of what I’m trying to do.
Chassis Design Brief
The chassis is not going to be a carbon fibre monocoque, like a F1, McLaren car or Alfa 4C.
Instead it’s going to be a tubular carbon fiber chassis/body similar to the Arial Atom, but with a 1 seater F3 layout (longitudinal engine and transmission layout in the rear). A very lightweight 1.6 Litre engine and transmission (120 kg) will be placed behind the bulk head with a low centre of gravity.
The chassis/body will consist of
- 6 oval hollow carbon fibre tubes (H: 12 cm, W: 8cm, Wall thickness: 3-5mm ) going from front to rear along the longitudinal axis.
- and 7 carbon fiber cross-member-frames placed along the lateral axis from from to rear. The cross-member-frames are also hollow in the centre and vary in diameter from 0cm (front, rear) to 55cm in the centre (which the driver legs fit through), and the bulk-head cross-member-frame (which is larger. The engine rests behind the bulk head).
All carbon fibre cross-member-frames will have M10 to M20 mounting nuts cast within them, to attach the wishbones, suspension, peddles, steering, seating, engine mounts, diff, and other auxiliaries. That's where CAD comes in, to get their placement and rigidity right.
This “for me anyway” - as I’m not a qualified mechanical engineer - makes the design simpler and easier to implement at home in my garage with CF sheet and moulds I create with a CNC machine out of stacked MDF or the like.
FEA and CFD analysis
My focus is designing, and moulding the chassis (body) in carbon-fiber, all other mechanic parts and auxiliaries with be bought. For the chassis, would FEA help to make sure its torsional rigid in the right places especially where mounting point for the engine and the like are; and where vibration can occur. My biggest concern for the chassis is testing torsional rigidity, and figuring out where additional carbon fiber needs to be placed to enforce it, where engine parts and other load bearing CF cross-member-frames join. Know if I have made the longitudinal oval hollow carbon fibre tubes wit the correct wall thickness is important.
As for CFD, I don’t think I need terminal or fluid dynamics analysis, a the car has a naked chassis (well ventured), and all other parts like the engine, brakes etc will be purchases performance parts.
Moulding the oval carbon fiber tubes
If you have any experience/pointers on how best to mould them, that would be very helpful. My idea is to use 4 layers of carbon-fiber sheets on the outside of the wall, then a honeycomb centre, and finally 4 layers of carbon-fiber on the inside of the wall. I’ll have to figure out some way of testing it. I’ve planned the wall thickness to be 3-4 mm overall and at mounting point increase to 8 mm to be safe. Would this make sense guys?
CATIA software
AWRacing and Generationx: Catia looks the business, but way out of my price league :-). But if can get access to it with a student licence, I’ll check it out.Whoooo AWRacing you really use allot of AutoCad software. Must be cool stuff. I currently use AutoCad Fusion 360, to Model 3D parts for around the house. I print them with my 3D printer (PRUSA i3). Fusion 360 does have other features like Generative Design, Render, Animation and Simulation. But I have never needed to try them yet, especially Simulation which - according to their info popup - helps determine how loads lead to deformation. They use a front bike fork as an example. So with that in mind, you all have made me aware of it...thanks guys. Could I use this feature to test the chassis oval tubes - if the software knows the torsional rigidity of carbon fibre in m3?
Gentlemen, If I can get a student licence for Catia, and I have additional questions on how best to use it, would you mind if I come back to pluck your brains, as ye’er all fountain of knowledge to me.
Excuse me guys if I many have used any incorrect lingo. I’m a Software engineer, and not a Qualified Mechanical or CAD engineer. But I dabble in both because I love what yee do and create, and want to do the same in my own little way during my spare time.
Many thanks again guys for your advise, tips and answers, I really really appreciate it.
Have a wonderful evening
Dave
Edited by davster10 on Tuesday 20th November 20:58
I've not used Catia in about 10years, it's not too bad to grasp the basics (much like any software I guess) but in the time I used it I berely scratched the surface of what it can do so I'll leave that to the professionals.
Autocad is a lot simpler to use but then 'vanilla' CAD is a 'basic' program compared to Catia and the like. If you were to go down the Autodesk route then I'd guess you'd want something like Inventor for what you are proposing. They have a package called Helius Composite which might be what you need for analysis work.
Also take a look at a program called Solidworks.
I am happy to give pointers on Autodesk software but probably won't be much use for anything related to chassis design.
Autocad is a lot simpler to use but then 'vanilla' CAD is a 'basic' program compared to Catia and the like. If you were to go down the Autodesk route then I'd guess you'd want something like Inventor for what you are proposing. They have a package called Helius Composite which might be what you need for analysis work.
Also take a look at a program called Solidworks.
I am happy to give pointers on Autodesk software but probably won't be much use for anything related to chassis design.
It might be worth you talking with Andy Bates
http://www.abperformance.co.uk
His CAD space frame design demonstrates that you don’t need to go down a Carbon route to save weight and maintain strength. The frame that you would need to fabricate to hold the inline engine, transaxle and rear suspension would be substantial.
Another thing to consider with a track day car is that if a 500kg race car collides with a 1500kg road car, there tends to be only one winner, so TDOs tend not to allow single-seat open-wheel cars out with saloons. A road-going 612kg 2-seat transverse-engined Atom has been design to fill the grey areas of that requirement.
http://www.abperformance.co.uk
His CAD space frame design demonstrates that you don’t need to go down a Carbon route to save weight and maintain strength. The frame that you would need to fabricate to hold the inline engine, transaxle and rear suspension would be substantial.
Another thing to consider with a track day car is that if a 500kg race car collides with a 1500kg road car, there tends to be only one winner, so TDOs tend not to allow single-seat open-wheel cars out with saloons. A road-going 612kg 2-seat transverse-engined Atom has been design to fill the grey areas of that requirement.
I'm currently working or a motorsports development company, but have worked on race cars, oem sports cars, SUVs and marine too.
I've been using siemens NX for the last 6 years or so every single day I've been working, I'm fairly competent with it, but not one piece of software will do everything you want.
For "proper" surfacing work you will need a NURBS (Non-Uniform Rational B Splines) based software like Alias or ICEMSurf. I say proper because you can do surfacing in most software to an extent, but to get into the real nitty gritty A-surfacing, reflection combs and curvature continuity then you're better off with one of the above.
For mechanical design including the tub, suspension, kinematics etc then NX or Catia would be the go to high end software. There are various licences to go for ranging massively in price. I'm biased towards NX as that's what I'm used to, but essentially they're pretty similar.
Solidworks is a cheapo version of NX/Catia, with enough practice you could probably do 80% of what you can do in one of the other bits of software but it'll take you longer to get there, however the licenses are also about 10% of the price...
You'll need either an add on or a standalone software for both structural analysis and aero... if you're doing aero work then you'll likely be using data spat out by Alias or ICEM as you have more control over the exterior surfaces and can run through many iterations reasonably quickly by tweaking the surfaces slightly and exporting many models to run in the sim.
I imagine this raises more questions than answers...
I've been using siemens NX for the last 6 years or so every single day I've been working, I'm fairly competent with it, but not one piece of software will do everything you want.
For "proper" surfacing work you will need a NURBS (Non-Uniform Rational B Splines) based software like Alias or ICEMSurf. I say proper because you can do surfacing in most software to an extent, but to get into the real nitty gritty A-surfacing, reflection combs and curvature continuity then you're better off with one of the above.
For mechanical design including the tub, suspension, kinematics etc then NX or Catia would be the go to high end software. There are various licences to go for ranging massively in price. I'm biased towards NX as that's what I'm used to, but essentially they're pretty similar.
Solidworks is a cheapo version of NX/Catia, with enough practice you could probably do 80% of what you can do in one of the other bits of software but it'll take you longer to get there, however the licenses are also about 10% of the price...
You'll need either an add on or a standalone software for both structural analysis and aero... if you're doing aero work then you'll likely be using data spat out by Alias or ICEM as you have more control over the exterior surfaces and can run through many iterations reasonably quickly by tweaking the surfaces slightly and exporting many models to run in the sim.
I imagine this raises more questions than answers...
Edited by Ambleton on Thursday 22 November 23:35
We use Solidworks at work. It doesn't have all the bells and whistles, but it does the job.
It has some FEA abilities, but it's a bit fiddly.
I'm not a CAD person, but provided the loading data : the FEA gives a nice visual representation of any stress concentrations.
We're using homogeneous materials (steel) - I don't know how Solidworks copes with mixed materials or composites.
It has some FEA abilities, but it's a bit fiddly.
I'm not a CAD person, but provided the loading data : the FEA gives a nice visual representation of any stress concentrations.
We're using homogeneous materials (steel) - I don't know how Solidworks copes with mixed materials or composites.
I use Solidworks and Inventor. Both can do this type of thing to a level but for the simulation packages you could be spending a huge amount of money. A relatively 'normal' license will cost around £4k + around £1-1.5k per annum support. Inventor can be done via subscription. Both would need extra moeny spending on add-ons but Inventor is more comprehensive out of the box. Must admit, I hate Inventor but it does seem better VFM than SW and I believe you can buy it on subscription rather than buying outright. Expensive project whichever way you cut it!
Autodesk Fusion 360 is free for personal use, this is likely your best bet, and has a huge community on youtube, etc. I can't comment on its simulations capabilities, I use it to create small parts on my 3D printer.
https://www.autodesk.co.uk/products/fusion-360/ove...
https://www.autodesk.co.uk/products/fusion-360/ove...
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


