Garmin FItness/Sports Watches & Black Friday!
Garmin FItness/Sports Watches & Black Friday!
Author
Discussion

NiceCupOfTea

Original Poster:

25,608 posts

282 months

Friday 23rd November 2018
quotequote all
Hi all,

Currently have a budget Android Wear fitness/smart watch (Ticwatch E) which is OK but a bit clunky, thinking about an upgrade today while the deals are on. I like the Garmin ones and there seem to be some decent deals.

Wants:
Good for running/stats etc.
Smart watch stuff (phone notifications, different faces, etc.)
Round face, nothing too chunky
Decent battery life (more than a day basically!)

I was looking at the Forerunner 235 which Amazon have on today for £150. I know it is quite long in the tooth but it seems to get a good writeup and that is a good price. It says it's water resistant to 50m and although there is no swimming tracking it is possible to use something from the Garmin App store apparently. I don't need anything fancy though, just a timer and an estimate of distance would do.

One thing it is missing and my brother's older Garmin watch has is mapping capabilities. He seems to be able to follow a route on his watch when he is running which, although not a dealbreaker, would be nice. Only seems to be on the Fenix 5 though unless I'm mistaken... Any way of doing it?

It's quite difficult working out what is an older model. Is Fenix 3 older or just further down the range? Where does Vivoactive come in the range? What about Forerunner 645? 735XT? silly

Looking to keep it under £200 really. Tempted by the 235 as a more reliable and less clunky version of what I have now...

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 23rd November 2018
quotequote all
GPS rumours site

Vivoactive 3 on Amazon looks to be the better deal.

You may be able to install breadcrumb trail navigation through a third party app.


telford_mike

1,221 posts

216 months

Friday 23rd November 2018
quotequote all
I have a 235. It’s great for running, and the smart watch style notifications work well. Loads of different watch faces available in the Garmin store. No mapping, but I think a watch face would be too small to be useful anyway. Battery last about a week.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 23rd November 2018
quotequote all
Just picked up a 735XT from Amazon, £40 more than the 235 at 'black friday' prices but does pool swimming metrics as well.

Its replacing my 3 year old TomTom active which is good for the money, but I got fed up with it after breaking a second strap and the battery life having declined to being borderline on an hour and a half run.

NiceCupOfTea

Original Poster:

25,608 posts

282 months

Friday 23rd November 2018
quotequote all
Thanks guys - I have had a little budget creep since this morning and I have been looking at the Fenix 5 - it doesn't do mapping but does breadcrumbs. I use Google Maps on my Ticwatch from time and time and it's OK but not brilliant, hope I won't miss it,

I'm not nuts about the chunky diver's watch looks of the Fenix 5, but it is currently £350 which seems an absolute bargain fow what it does...

Thoughts?

R1gtr

3,443 posts

185 months

Friday 23rd November 2018
quotequote all
Sport pursuit have the fenix3 for about £240 today in the Black Friday sale

smn159

16,145 posts

248 months

Friday 23rd November 2018
quotequote all
NiceCupOfTea said:
Thanks guys - I have had a little budget creep since this morning and I have been looking at the Fenix 5 - it doesn't do mapping but does breadcrumbs. I use Google Maps on my Ticwatch from time and time and it's OK but not brilliant, hope I won't miss it,

I'm not nuts about the chunky diver's watch looks of the Fenix 5, but it is currently £350 which seems an absolute bargain fow what it does...

Thoughts?
Look at the 935 instead. Does pretty much the same stuff as the Fenix but is lighter and (IMO) looks better.

NiceCupOfTea

Original Poster:

25,608 posts

282 months

Sunday 25th November 2018
quotequote all
Thanks all.

As always I am probably overthinking it, but narrowing it down a bit.

Fenix 3 - would rather not, it's even chunkier than the 5 and I understand the software is older.

Fenix 5 standard - best priced at £350 in quite a few places (£310 on Amazon for the silver bezel). However, I am not massively keen on the chunky looks and it doesn't have WiFi. I don't know if this is a dealbreaker - I will be pairing it with my watch so BT transfer of data etc. will probably be fine. Not sure if I can USB sync it via my Chromebook or if I'll need a Windows PC.

Fenix 5 Sapphire - solves a few of the above problems - sapphire screen so more rugged, black bezel which I think looks better than the grey bezel, and WiFi included, however a massive price hike (doesn't seem to have benefitted from the Black Friday hype) at £520 from Wiggle.

Forerunner 935 - basically a Fenix 5 in a sleeker case, I like the looks and it comes with WiFi, £400 at Wiggle for the Tri Bundle with an extra straps and a couple of sensors that I will never use so might be able to ebay for some money back. However... I wonder if I will regret not going for the more rugged one...

Truth be told I would probably go for a Fenix 5 Sapphire if I could get one at £400, but it's a long way above that at the mo...

NiceCupOfTea

Original Poster:

25,608 posts

282 months

Sunday 25th November 2018
quotequote all
Just discovered the Fenix 5X can be had for £475 - WiFi, Sapphire glass and mapping too, all cheaper than the 5 Sapphire even though it's a better watch! However, it is truly massive and a 52mm watch is going to look ridiculous on my girly little wrists. Very annoying, as price point wise the 5 Sapphire should be coming in at around £425-450, but it is £100 more...

Is the FR935 that much of a lightweight?

Pedro Raynard

109 posts

139 months

Sunday 25th November 2018
quotequote all
NiceCupOfTea said:
Is the FR935 that much of a lightweight?
From Google

735XT 40g
FR935 49g
Fenix 5 86g
Fenix 3 84g

I've had a 735XT and currently on the 935. The lightness attracted me to the 735XT, now I have FR935 with more functionality and longer battery life I would not go back. I find the 935 light on the wrist, even if the watch is little deeper than the 735XT.

Pedro

smn159

16,145 posts

248 months

Sunday 25th November 2018
quotequote all
I upgraded from a 235 to a 935 about 9 months ago while I was marathon training. I like it a lot.

NiceCupOfTea

Original Poster:

25,608 posts

282 months

Sunday 25th November 2018
quotequote all
Oooh. Interesting chaps. It doesn't feel cheap does it? Worried it might end up getting scratched and scuffed. I take reasonable care of my watches but these things happen... Might get a screen protector. Does the screen stand proud? It did on my old Pebble and that got badly scratched. The bezel on my Ticwatch E stands 1mm proud of the screen and no marks on the screen so far (in 11 months).

£400 for the Tri - package does seem pretty good.

smn159

16,145 posts

248 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
NiceCupOfTea said:
Oooh. Interesting chaps. It doesn't feel cheap does it? Worried it might end up getting scratched and scuffed. I take reasonable care of my watches but these things happen... Might get a screen protector. Does the screen stand proud? It did on my old Pebble and that got badly scratched. The bezel on my Ticwatch E stands 1mm proud of the screen and no marks on the screen so far (in 11 months).

£400 for the Tri - package does seem pretty good.
The screen sits within a slightly raised bevel. No scuffs on mine that I can see after 9 months of everyday wear. I doesn't feel cheap to me anyway, which was one of the problems that I had with the 235 (plus the erratic heart rate monitor!).

For me it's the sweet spot in terms of functionality, price and weight.

daddy cool

4,108 posts

260 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
I (don't need but) quite want a Fenix 5 or 5X. Must be the sapphire version though (the "plus" features with music etc are a bonus). This site has them at full retail price but has a black Friday 15% discount code:
https://www.firstclasswatches.co.uk/
5X Plus ends up as £636
5 Plus ends up as £594

Tempting... if anyone sees any better deals let me know!

Tiggsy

10,261 posts

283 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
I use a 5x - awesome bit of kit for running. Or anything that needs tracking - mtb, etc

daddy cool

4,108 posts

260 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
Tiggsy said:
I use a 5x - awesome bit of kit for running. Or anything that needs tracking - mtb, etc
The thing is, I have an Edge 800 for MTB... a selection of G-Shocks (with compass etc) for hiking... an old Forerunner for running... and usually a smartphone with me for maps and music etc. Hence why I don't *need* a 5/5X, but they are sexy bits of kit that do everything!

Also, I have the wrists of a 12 year old girl. Ive got used to my G-Shock (which is 51mm wide) but for some reason the 5X just appears bigger, despite being the same width.

tenohfive

6,276 posts

213 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
NiceCupOfTea said:
Oooh. Interesting chaps. It doesn't feel cheap does it? Worried it might end up getting scratched and scuffed. I take reasonable care of my watches but these things happen... Might get a screen protector. Does the screen stand proud? It did on my old Pebble and that got badly scratched. The bezel on my Ticwatch E stands 1mm proud of the screen and no marks on the screen so far (in 11 months).

£400 for the Tri - package does seem pretty good.
The 935 doesn't feel cheap. A screen protector is (for me) a must - I've been through a couple of them already. But it looks and feels like a high end smartwatch.

Frankly it's the best bit of kit I've bought in the last few years. Of any description. And unlike the 735/Fenix 3 and some of the others it's got the more modern version of Connect IQ running - which means it has a degree of futureproofing.

That said, another member of my household has a Vivoactive 3 and with the touch screen it's very slick. And it'll run third party mapping app's like dW Maps. As a lifestyle and general running watch, it's probably a better bet. But 13 hours battery life is a bit short for some of the races I do, and I prefer the baked in ability to follow a .gpx file on the 935.

Personally I'd be dismissing the 5X either way - I've run dW on the 935 and a watch screen is just too small and fiddly to mess around zooming in or out to try and pick out the trails at a fork. Better to use a phone or the route following nav on-board the watch.

NiceCupOfTea

Original Poster:

25,608 posts

282 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
Thanks chaps. Actually managed to get in a shop today and try both the Fenix 5 Sapphire and 935 on my wrist. 935 was a good size, actually lighter than my Ticwatch, but the black "standard" one was a bit dull if truth be told. I think the Tri-Package with yellow strap looks much nicer, and I think the face has a yellow highlight on it which looks nice.

Fenix 5 Sapphire was a really nice solid piece of kit. Felt pretty heavy, but not too big on my wrist. Hope I would get used to the weight. I did prefer the look to the standard 935 if I'm honest, but £520 is a lot of wedge when it's been superceded by the 5 Plus, and when the 5X (top of the range of the non-Plus series) can be had cheaper.

If the Fenix 5 Sapphire was £400 or so I would have it. Just don't think I can justify the extra money though...

tenohfive

6,276 posts

213 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
Quickfit straps can be had for a fiver from Amazon/eBay/AliExpress. Some are good, some are bad but you learn pretty quickly which ones give way - just by putting it on tightly. I've run 100km+ with a £4 strap (chosen because it matched my t-shirt that day...I know, judge away) so I really wouldn't be swayed into a deal on the back of the overpriced Garmin watch straps - for standard silicon straps anyway. If it's a deal in other regards though then it's worth considering.

NiceCupOfTea

Original Poster:

25,608 posts

282 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
tenohfive said:
Quickfit straps can be had for a fiver from Amazon/eBay/AliExpress. Some are good, some are bad but you learn pretty quickly which ones give way - just by putting it on tightly. I've run 100km+ with a £4 strap (chosen because it matched my t-shirt that day...I know, judge away) so I really wouldn't be swayed into a deal on the back of the overpriced Garmin watch straps - for standard silicon straps anyway. If it's a deal in other regards though then it's worth considering.
Cheers - it's more that you can't get it any cheaper without the strap, maybe £20? But then pay that £20 more and get the strap & 2 extra sensors that you could sell on!