Soldering Iron!... Is it bust...
Discussion
I have an Antex 15w soldering iron.
I've had it for years, used it maybe twice, but that was a fairly long time back.
Trying to use it today, to solder two small wires from a LED indicator to a resistor... No go.
Seems to have enough heat, to melt solder, after about 20 seconds, but nowhere near the heat to melt solder on the wires.
I know my technique may not be great, but surely it should be hotter than that.
Do I need a new iron?...
Any recommendations?
No budget, but no need to shell out silly money
I've had it for years, used it maybe twice, but that was a fairly long time back.
Trying to use it today, to solder two small wires from a LED indicator to a resistor... No go.
Seems to have enough heat, to melt solder, after about 20 seconds, but nowhere near the heat to melt solder on the wires.
I know my technique may not be great, but surely it should be hotter than that.
Do I need a new iron?...
Any recommendations?
No budget, but no need to shell out silly money

This solder station looks pretty decent for around £20
Temperature controlled too.
I've no experience of it I must stress.

EDIT: I found what looks to be the same iron on Amazon but with Draper branding.
Reviews are mixed but mostly good - it'll probably be perfectly ok if you're just a casual hobbyist.
I've no experience of it I must stress.
EDIT: I found what looks to be the same iron on Amazon but with Draper branding.
Reviews are mixed but mostly good - it'll probably be perfectly ok if you're just a casual hobbyist.
Edited by TonyRPH on Friday 23 November 22:11
When you say wires from an led indicator, are we talking on the car?
Trying to solder out doors in November with a cheap soldering iron meant for indoor use is a very frustrating expirence. I once tried to solder a power resistor for a radiator fan, it just was not possible, the wire was too think and too long to get hot from a 35w soldering iron.
Trying to solder out doors in November with a cheap soldering iron meant for indoor use is a very frustrating expirence. I once tried to solder a power resistor for a radiator fan, it just was not possible, the wire was too think and too long to get hot from a 35w soldering iron.
Lead free solder requires more heat to flow, and 15w is at the lower end of soldering iron power.
As above, clean the tip (use a file, if necessary), get an amount of molten solder on the tip and heat the wire. If new solder doesn't melt when you touch it to the wire, then I suspect your iron is underpowered.
As above, clean the tip (use a file, if necessary), get an amount of molten solder on the tip and heat the wire. If new solder doesn't melt when you touch it to the wire, then I suspect your iron is underpowered.
dickymint said:
Mr Pointy said:
Honestly, file the tip? How do you know it's not a coated tip. If you file through the coating you'll start to lose the tip.
It’s a very old solder station 
TonyRPH said:
This solder station looks pretty decent for around £20
Temperature controlled too.
I've no experience of it I must stress.

EDIT: I found what looks to be the same iron on Amazon but with Draper branding.
Reviews are mixed but mostly good - it'll probably be perfectly ok if you're just a casual hobbyist.
?
I have one of those, use it on my repair bench, works well, no issues.I've no experience of it I must stress.
EDIT: I found what looks to be the same iron on Amazon but with Draper branding.
Reviews are mixed but mostly good - it'll probably be perfectly ok if you're just a casual hobbyist.
?
Edited by TonyRPH on Friday 23 November 22:11
ging84 said:
When you say wires from an led indicator, are we talking on the car?
Trying to solder out doors in November with a cheap soldering iron meant for indoor use is a very frustrating expirence..
What type of soldering iron would be suitable for use outdoors in winter? I have to sober some wires on my Land Rover and it blooming cold outside?Trying to solder out doors in November with a cheap soldering iron meant for indoor use is a very frustrating expirence..
LeadFarmer said:
What type of soldering iron would be suitable for use outdoors in winter? I have to sober some wires on my Land Rover and it blooming cold outside?
Gas powered are pretty good for using in cars because even if you can get power where you need it the wire normally gets in the way.You are usually having to get into a somewhat awkward place and you don't want to find yourself treading on the wire and yanking the hot pointy bit towards your face.
LeadFarmer said:
ging84 said:
When you say wires from an led indicator, are we talking on the car?
Trying to solder out doors in November with a cheap soldering iron meant for indoor use is a very frustrating expirence..
What type of soldering iron would be suitable for use outdoors in winter? I have to sober some wires on my Land Rover and it blooming cold outside?Trying to solder out doors in November with a cheap soldering iron meant for indoor use is a very frustrating expirence..
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Portasol-SP-1-Super-Sold-...
https://portasol.co.uk/catalog/index.php
It's butane powered so you don't need mains power to it & it's adjustable up to 125 watts which is good for thick cables. Amazon do spare tips as well if you search for them.
Alternatively you could look at something like this which is cheap but it mains powered:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Hi-Spec-Temperature-Elect...
Again high power but not adjustable so you'd have to learn to be quick.
I generally avoid soldering irons with conical pointy tips that look like they were designed some time in the industrial revolution, even for soldering Land Rovery bits.
If 25W is enough, I always find Antex irons pretty reliable and easy to find bits for.
https://cpc.farnell.com/antex/s582470/xs25-230v-so...
If you fancy something a bit more PH, the TS100 (and TS80) from somewhere vague in China is getting a lot of very good reviews. It looks small and weedy, but can deliver a lot of power, mostly because the heating element is closely coupled to the tip. It runs off 12-24V, being rated at 65W at the upper end of that, but only 18W or so at 12V. I had my doubts about a soldering iron with an OLED display that can take software updates, but as I say, lots of people seem to like it. It costs £40 ish from Ebay, Amazon marketplace, BangGood etc.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sDMhh3p2nuM (A good general video on soldering away from the bench)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RThpvcq9Tdg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ao39bPEyok4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HgrB5P-rDLw
They are popular for using in the field with a modified Makita / Ryobi / whatever drill battery pack.
Oh yeah, and don't even think about filing a soldering iron tip made this century.
If 25W is enough, I always find Antex irons pretty reliable and easy to find bits for.
https://cpc.farnell.com/antex/s582470/xs25-230v-so...
If you fancy something a bit more PH, the TS100 (and TS80) from somewhere vague in China is getting a lot of very good reviews. It looks small and weedy, but can deliver a lot of power, mostly because the heating element is closely coupled to the tip. It runs off 12-24V, being rated at 65W at the upper end of that, but only 18W or so at 12V. I had my doubts about a soldering iron with an OLED display that can take software updates, but as I say, lots of people seem to like it. It costs £40 ish from Ebay, Amazon marketplace, BangGood etc.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sDMhh3p2nuM (A good general video on soldering away from the bench)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RThpvcq9Tdg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ao39bPEyok4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HgrB5P-rDLw
They are popular for using in the field with a modified Makita / Ryobi / whatever drill battery pack.
Oh yeah, and don't even think about filing a soldering iron tip made this century.
Probably no bad thing, any DC powered iron may potentially be powered from a switched mode power supply like a laptop PSU which itself will float, the suppression capacitor across the transformer will have a 50/50 chance of being coupled to live, albeit offering a relatively high impedance, but there is a risk that the "earth" of the iron would be at mains potential. Similarly, working on switched mode equipment, not all gear is totally isolated when switched off, and they can get interesting if you touch a live chassis with an earthed iron.
Zad said:
Probably no bad thing, any DC powered iron may potentially be powered from a switched mode power supply like a laptop PSU which itself will float...
<snip>
I've yet to encounter a bench top soldering iron that uses a switch mode PSU (although I'm sure they're out there...) - I wouldn't buy one unless I really had to though...<snip>
The two solder stations I have (both 24v DC) provide an earth point at the rear, should you want to earth the tip to mains earth (or other earth).
TonyRPH said:
Zad said:
Probably no bad thing, any DC powered iron may potentially be powered from a switched mode power supply like a laptop PSU which itself will float...
<snip>
I've yet to encounter a bench top soldering iron that uses a switch mode PSU (although I'm sure they're out there...) - I wouldn't buy one unless I really had to though...<snip>
The two solder stations I have (both 24v DC) provide an earth point at the rear, should you want to earth the tip to mains earth (or other earth).
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


