I need a mouse for CAD
Author
Discussion

Gad-Westy

Original Poster:

16,665 posts

244 months

Saturday 24th November 2018
quotequote all
Hi all. I need a new mouse for my laptop to use with 3D CAD. Have a logitech laser thing at the moment and it's terrible on most surfaces. Used to use weighted Logitech mice in the past and they were ideal but no longer made. frown

Basic requirements are:

Simpler design the better, don't need loads of buttons
Reasonably weighty, needs a bit of resistance to be accurate if you know what I mean.
High quality
Centre button and scroll wheel essential
Wireless would be nice but I don't want to faff with batteries so battery needs to last for months or be very easily USB charged or something along those lines. Wired is okay too although getting a bit bored of untangling it every time I take it out the bag.
Crucially, it needs to work on more or less any surface, don't want a mouse mat.

Dave.

7,903 posts

284 months

Saturday 24th November 2018
quotequote all
I use a Gigabyte M9600, it's wired but they do a wireless one.

There was a thread not so long ago, loads of suggestions, I'll see if I can find it.


Eta - https://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&...

There's another link in there to another thread too.

Edited by Dave. on Saturday 24th November 07:44

Gad-Westy

Original Poster:

16,665 posts

244 months

Saturday 24th November 2018
quotequote all
Dave. said:
I use a Gigabyte M9600, it's wired but they do a wireless one.

There was a thread not so long ago, loads of suggestions, I'll see if I can find it.


Eta - https://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&...

There's another link in there to another thread too.

Edited by Dave. on Saturday 24th November 07:44
Brilliant thanks. What do you think of the gigabyte? Assume you mean M6900?

Dave.

7,903 posts

284 months

Saturday 24th November 2018
quotequote all
Ah, yes, I do!

I've had it for ages, used it daily for 5 or 6 years.

My hand cramps up with smaller mice, this one fits my hand perfect.

Got another one at home, and got one as a freebie when I bought my last laptop, convinced the other half to try it, and even with her tiny hands finds it comfortable.

It's not mega heavy, but if you go for wireless it'll be a bit heavier with the batteries. (Never used one though, so don't know how long they last etc).

Gad-Westy

Original Poster:

16,665 posts

244 months

Saturday 24th November 2018
quotequote all
Dave. said:
Ah, yes, I do!

I've had it for ages, used it daily for 5 or 6 years.

My hand cramps up with smaller mice, this one fits my hand perfect.

Got another one at home, and got one as a freebie when I bought my last laptop, convinced the other half to try it, and even with her tiny hands finds it comfortable.

It's not mega heavy, but if you go for wireless it'll be a bit heavier with the batteries. (Never used one though, so don't know how long they last etc).
Sounds promising. Can I ask whether you use it on multiple surfaces. Biggest problem I have with the current one is that it basically needs a mouse mat to work. It won't work on an oak table. It will work on some glossy hardback books but not all. It sometimes works on mat surfaces but not all. Drives me mad as I cannot predict if it will work or not and I refuse to carry a mouse mat around.

motco

17,669 posts

277 months

Saturday 24th November 2018
quotequote all
I did a lot of CAD work in the late 90s and early 2000s and found that a roller ball mouse was far bette than any optical one I tried.

Ambleton

7,291 posts

223 months

Saturday 24th November 2018
quotequote all
on my workstation in the office I'm presently using a Cyborg RAT7, I really like the weight and customisability on size and weight, but I don't use even 20% of what it can do.

I was looking at the 3dConnexion one last night. I need a new spacemouse too and they do a package for spacemouse/CADmouse which is cheaper than buying them separately... don't get me wrong though, it still ain't cheap!

Dave.

7,903 posts

284 months

Saturday 24th November 2018
quotequote all
Gad-Westy said:
Sounds promising. Can I ask whether you use it on multiple surfaces. Biggest problem I have with the current one is that it basically needs a mouse mat to work. It won't work on an oak table. It will work on some glossy hardback books but not all. It sometimes works on mat surfaces but not all. Drives me mad as I cannot predict if it will work or not and I refuse to carry a mouse mat around.
I don't tend to use a mouse mat, I've had it on 3 or 4 different desks, from old "oak" one, matt white, and the sofa arm.

I got a huge gaming mouse mat with the laptop, I tried for a few hours and it was garbage, the movement wasn't linear.

GnuBee

1,339 posts

246 months

Saturday 24th November 2018
quotequote all
I use one of these -> https://www.3dconnexion.com/spacemouse_compact/en/ in conjunction with a normal mouse. Looks odd, feels odd at first then becomes second nature and is a huge QOL upgrade

warch

2,941 posts

185 months

Saturday 24th November 2018
quotequote all
I've tried various meece down the years (CAD/Adobe Illustrator) and I prefer a good quality bog standard mouse. They're the right size (not too small) and perfectly fit for purpose. I usually alter my grip every so often and use different fingers to reduce hand/wrist strain.

cadmunkey

800 posts

120 months

Saturday 24th November 2018
quotequote all
I've used a Zowie FK1 now for a long time and its perfect. Works on shiny surfaces too without a mat.

warch

2,941 posts

185 months

Saturday 24th November 2018
quotequote all
cadmunkey said:
I've used a Zowie FK1 now for a long time and its perfect. Works on shiny surfaces too without a mat.
Might give one of these a try.

Gad-Westy

Original Poster:

16,665 posts

244 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
Thanks all.

A few good options to look into.

Should have mentioned, I already use a space mouse. This is to replace the 'normal' mouse. I jump between systems a lot at the moment and I'm having to get used to using mouse only from time to time.

Trackballs - I like them but don't find them that easy for 3D CAD.

Normal, robust, simple mouse is more or less what I need. Looks like some good suggestions here.

Derek Smith

50,031 posts

279 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
I get a bit of RSI, this despite using a mouse with my right hand and a trackball with my left. I'm partially ambidextrous, which leads to a few problems but lots of benefits. The biggest downside was being hit over the knuckles by ruler-wielding teachers in primary school whenever I picked a pen or brush up with my left hand. In the end I used to sit on it.

I bought an A5 Wacom tablet (advertised as 'half letter size' ?) mainly for a bit of CAD. I did not find it much better than a mouse. However it was great for RSI. If I use the mouse for a time I then use the pad. I'm told for CAD one needs A4. I've had my pad for more than 5 years, probably 7 or 8, but when it finally goes, I'm going up a size.

I would not risk bluetooth. Lots of complaints about lag.


designforlife

3,742 posts

194 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
i've used razer gaming mice for solidworks for the last 15 or so years...braided USB cables, no tangling, and no worries about batteries draining. The one on my desk currently is a 2013 death adder, it's still going strong.

Not a huge fan at all of the space pilot 3d connexion things...tried one for a couple months and just couldn't get on with it, the background software is a real resource hog too. I would say deffo try one before you buy as they aren't for everyone.

caelite

4,282 posts

143 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
I know it's a 'gamer' mouse. But I use a Razer Orochi for this exact purpose. Small, with possibly the most reliable Bluetooth connection I've used. Uses AA batteries which last weeks and are easily swapped out. Simple with just enough buttons.


48Valves

2,814 posts

240 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
If you can find a Logitech MX1100. Get one. I have had mine for years and its still going. I used to use it all day, mostly with Revit. So lots of clicks. Never had any aches or pains when using it.

I think the Master is its replacement.

Bungleaio

6,595 posts

233 months

Tuesday 27th November 2018
quotequote all
I use a Logitech G700s for both CAD and excel. I've had it for years now and must have pushed it miles, sadly the wireless part doesn't work anymore so I just use it via a cable.

It has multiple buttons on them which I have customised to have F8, Enter, Escape, back, forward, Copy, Paste and mute. Depending on what I'm doing sometimes I can be quite a while before I need to actually use the keyboard.