Which of these NAS?
Author
Discussion

Dan_1981

Original Poster:

18,129 posts

230 months

Sunday 25th November 2018
quotequote all
So i'm looking for a NAS.......

I'll use it more for a back up than I will accessing network stored info.... if that makes much of a difference?

Thinking of 4tb split over x 2 2tb dics in parallel for redundancy.

Two options that seem to be well regarded....

synology DS218J

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Synology-DS218j-Bay-Deskt...

adding a couple of drives gives a price of about £290


or the WD 4 TB My Cloud EX2 Ultra

https://www.amazon.co.uk/WD-TB-Cloud-EX2-Ultra/dp/...

So about £60 quid less but doesn't seem as well recommended as the synology.

So any suggestions?

RoadRailer

599 posts

259 months

Sunday 25th November 2018
quotequote all
If you want 4TB storage and redundancy you’ll need 2x 4TB drives, I’d buy the same model of drive from two suppliers so they don’t fail at the same time too.
I’ve several Synology devices and can’t fault them really.

bitchstewie

68,506 posts

241 months

Sunday 25th November 2018
quotequote all
As above, buy the Synology and a pair of 4TB drives.

Murph7355

42,079 posts

287 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
RoadRailer said:
...I’d buy the same model of drive from two suppliers so they don’t fail at the same time too....
That is no guarantee of anything smile

OP - I'd be more inclined to get a unit with more bays so you can use smaller drives for the same capacity. Also gives you more configuration options.

Bikerjon

2,211 posts

192 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
I own both and each has their own benefits. The Synology runs full featured software and can do many things but can take a little while to setup and options can be quite buried in the software. The WD is rapid to setup/manage and has a much simpler interface, which makes it good when it's just for file storage/backup stuff.

I actually prefer the MyCloud for simple NAS duties but the Synology is the safer option to recommend I suppose.

Dan_1981

Original Poster:

18,129 posts

230 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
Back up to portable USB drive also, but would like a remote options for phones etc.

(which i'm assuming both of these can do? and automatically. each day?)


Tiggsy

10,261 posts

283 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
I need something like the WD option for my video storage after I'm done editing it on the Mac - 4TB is enough for a while but I dont want only one version - Can I just plug in a second (simpler) 4TB ext HD to the WD NAS and have it copy everything - I could do that once a week and keep that version off site??

Somebody

1,766 posts

114 months

Monday 26th November 2018
quotequote all
I have an older 2-bay Synology from 2011 which is still being supported (just). I do have them in RAID configuration which was good as one of the identical harddrives failed which I had to replace. As the drives were obsolete models I had to chance a replacement off eBay which thankfully worked.

Synology is good for features (to name but a few):
- it has a built in VPN server so you can watch iplayer etc from abroad routing through your own set up;
- a free DDNS service which you can use for the said built in VPN and other DDNS uses like remote accessing your IP cameras
- surveillance station to record one of your IP camera (only comes with a free license for one camera)
- stick a spare usb wifi dongle on it and you can turn your box into a wifi access point
- connect a printer to it so you have network printer
- you can download Synology packages for it to enable to set up your own mail server, DNS server, iTune server etc

Edited by Somebody on Monday 26th November 14:43

Dan_1981

Original Poster:

18,129 posts

230 months

Wednesday 5th December 2018
quotequote all
I think I prefer to synology after a little reading.

2TB should be enough so x 2 2tb drives.

It seems cheaper to buy the enclosure and then add the drives separately?

Just a couple of 2TB Nas drives - either ironwolf or WD?

dhutch

17,959 posts

228 months

Wednesday 5th December 2018
quotequote all
Synology here, bought for the extra features, which I have then never used, in part because they are a bit faffy to set up.

Parents have had a pair of Linkstations, first one did about 6 years before the fan failed and dad decided to replace the lot for a larger spec'er model.

No complaints at all. Fan might have worked less hard if it wasnt located in the attic!


Daniel

Bullitt Five-Oh

876 posts

98 months

Wednesday 5th December 2018
quotequote all
Raid redundancy is great but not really meant to be a used as backup strategy. I've had my Synology DS213+ since 2012 and apart from fan failing and being replaced under warranty (a known issue on these) I had two drives die at different times (both freaking Seagate) and although the data was resynced everytime some files were corrupted. Without external backup those files would have been lost.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 5th December 2018
quotequote all
+1 for synology, my experiences with WD stuff weren't good but that was a while ago.

LeadFarmer

7,411 posts

162 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
Make sure you buy the correct model of Synology, each model name can be broken down as follows...

Chassis Type – Number of Hard drives you can connect – Which Year/Series it is part of – Intended Use

The first letters indicate the Chassis type
DS - Disc station
RS - Rack station
NVR - Network video recorder
DX - Disc station extender
RX - Rack station extender
VS - Visual station

The number that follows the chassis type indicates how many hard drive bays the unit has
e.g. 2 = 2 x HDD bays

The next two numbers indicate the year of the unit
e.g. 18= 2018

Then theres the letters at the end
SE - basic model
J - Upgrade from the SE model
Slim - Uses smaller hard drives
Standard - a standard model
Play - Multimedia capability
+ - PLUS models have longer warranty
XS - Top of the range



So, the Synology DS918+ means its a..
DS = Disk station
9 = 9 x HDD bays
18 = 2018 model
+ = Plus model




Chris Hinds

497 posts

196 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
Another pro Synology vote here... but you need to remember that if you populate a 2 bay NAS with 2tb drives and run with the storage redundant to protect from disk failure, your USABLE capacity is 2tb only. Disk failures do happen, right now I’ve got a friend downloading 2tb of data from his cloud backup because three of the four disks in his Synology crashed. All the usual safeguards were applied. We bought the disks over 3 weeks from 2 suppliers and the same model of disk in each case. First time in 7 NAS devices I’ve set up that a crash has happened, but it does happen.

dhutch

17,959 posts

228 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
Colleague recently lost a load of data plugging his main disks and backup disk into the same pc, what happened is not clear but powering on appears to have knackered all three disks circuite boards. Data recovery is excluded from his house insurance even though replacing or repairing the disks is.

Obviously he is gutted. But a pair of disks in the same box in the same location only gives so much cover.
You then need a pair of usb hard disks, stored unplugged, one off site in work or at an freind/families house.

Daniel

alock

4,575 posts

242 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
dhutch said:
Obviously he is gutted. But a pair of disks in the same box in the same location only gives so much cover.
You then need a pair of usb hard disks, stored unplugged, one off site in work or at an freind/families house.
I've said this on many threads, but normally seem to be in a minority of one. For most home users, protecting against disk failure, but not motherboard, CPU, RAM, etc... failure is an odd choice.

What is the recovery strategy if the RAM in the NAS fails? You have two copies of the data on the two internal disks. Now what do you do? If you know what to do then you probably wouldn't start a thread like this.

A one disk 2TB NAS with an external 2TB disk is a far more robust backup solution. On day one, after the first backup, check you can mount and read the external disk on other computers.

dhutch

17,959 posts

228 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
Obviously depends how the box fails as to if it takes the disks with it. If not you can put them in another box.

I would have a pair of disks, mirrored (barely any cost over one disk, bar the disk itself) and then a pair of external disks which are backed up from it at intervals of your choice, one of which lives off site (this costs not just the disks, but the time and faff) else you obviously have cloud based options these days.


Daniel

neilus

908 posts

313 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
LeadFarmer said:
The number that follows the chassis type indicates how many hard drive bays the unit has
e.g. 2 = 2 x HDD bays

....

So, the Synology DS918+ means its a..
DS = Disk station
9 = 9 x HDD bays
18 = 2018 model
+ = Plus model
Slight clarification to the above, the second number is the total number of HDD the unit will support including expansion units.

In the case of the DS918+, the unit only has 4 x HDD bays but you can plug in a 5 x HDD expansion unit to provide 9 HDD bays in total.

twister

1,594 posts

267 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
Chris Hinds said:
All the usual safeguards were applied. We bought the disks over 3 weeks from 2 suppliers and the same model of disk in each case.
Whilst I've often seen it suggested that RAID arrays ought to use the same model of disk to avoid any possible issues caused by the slight (or not so slight) differences in drive performance, doing so does then place you at risk of experiencing a multi-disk failure due to a fault common to all drives of that particular model type/range of models within the wider drive family. There was a quite well known issue in the past when certain models of Seagate drive bricked themselves after a specific number of power cycles due to a firmware bug - imagine having an entire RAID array populated with those, all experiencing the same number of power cycles...

So IMO, I'd prefer to populate an array with a mixture of drives not just from different batches, but from different families or even manufacturers. The less each drive has in common with the next one in the array, the less risk you have of a common failure mode taking out enough drives at once to prevent the R part of RAID being able to do its job.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
ash73 said:
Don't waste storage space on RAID, you need a second backup on a USB drive or similar anyhow.
Its a little odd to call RAID a waste when RAID is designed specifically designed to gain advantage by using multiple "Inexpensive Discs" (well, apart from striping - which is a performance tool).

I run a raid array over 2 discs on a RAID NAS, 2Tb drives x2 = 2TB with parity. I then hang a 2TB USB drive off it which performs an auto backup weekly.

If a RAID drive fails, it is as simple as buying another and plugging it in.
When I go away on holiday, I take the USB drive with me, or leave with a friend.

I'm covered for protection, I have quick easy data recovery, and I don't have to take my raid away when I go on holiday.

I could of course run a striped RAID with no redundancy (parity) but then if one drive fails, all data is gone until I restore a backup. Not a massive ball ache but for the sake of a £50 HDD I just though, "why not?"