AMD, Celeron, iX, etc...
Author
Discussion

james_tigerwoods

Original Poster:

16,347 posts

228 months

Wednesday 5th December 2018
quotequote all
I'm in IT, have been for over 20 years but as time has gone on, my knowledge of processor architecture has dwindled (dumbed down even) - I used to do desktop support so I knew quite a bit about what was then P3, P2, Celeron processors and a little bit about AMD processors. (I'm a Solution Architect now so I go as far as "It's Windows 10 and, erm, that's it"....)

So I guess my question is this - What's the difference, these days, between the AMD and Intel processors? I generally steer clear of the Celerons (when giving advice) or is this a snobbish attitude? Have the AMD architectures stepped up to the iX processors? Is there an AMD Celeron equivalent?

Sorry for such an open question, but it's one of those that I have wondered...

Thanks

JTW

RobDickinson

31,343 posts

285 months

Wednesday 5th December 2018
quotequote all
AMD CPUs are less efficient (in terms of performance per watt, and ipc) but make up for it generally with more cores, but offer better value and keep intel (more) honest.

Top of the consumer tree you have the AMD Ryzen 32 core (64thread) vs intels i9-9900 8 core/16 thread CPU

Its been nice to see AMD come back recently because intel have taken the piss with some of their recent CPUs, feature minefields and poor heat spreaders etc (along with high prices).

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 5th December 2018
quotequote all
Celerons were/are best avoided at all costs. Every single time I've helped someone witha computer with "Celeron inside" on it, I've run out of patience. Nothing snobby about avoiding them. I'm sure they are Z80's robbed from old Speccys.

FukeLreeman

1,502 posts

206 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
I'll be bold enough to say that since the AMD 64's ,Intel's IX range has taken over.

AMD did step their game up massively with the latest Ryzen stuff though.


I recently swapped from a 2500k to a 8700k. To be fair, even though the 2500k was 8 year old, it still held it's own today.

Jinx

12,023 posts

291 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
If you only play games and have the money - intel is still king. If on the other hand you have a diverse work load, don't need to squeeze that extra 5-10fps from your top end GPU and run many applications at once then AMD is the goto (they also support the same socket for multiple generations - so upgrades are just dropping a new cpu in - well after a bios update) .
On the consumer side you can't go wrong with either a Ryzen 2700 or intel i9 9900k as they are both good chips - the intel will hurt your pocket more. On the HEDT side - it is hard to recommend anything but AMD Threadripper (this is coming from an i7 7820X owner) - the amount of cores, support for ECC memory up to 1TiB, 64 PCIE lanes and is much cheaper than the intel HEDT chips. Intel do win in AVX 512 workloads though....

dcb

6,070 posts

296 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
RobDickinson said:
AMD CPUs are less efficient (in terms of performance per watt, and ipc) but make up for it generally with more cores, but offer better value and keep intel (more) honest.

Top of the consumer tree you have the AMD Ryzen 32 core (64thread) vs intels i9-9900 8 core/16 thread CPU

Its been nice to see AMD come back recently because intel have taken the piss with some of their recent CPUs, feature minefields and poor heat spreaders etc (along with high prices).
Good point. Intel have 85% - 90% of the marketplace, so to avoid a monopoly,
I'd always buy and recommend AMD. You can't beat their performance per dollar.

Now that the AMD 32 cores are out, this should reduce the price of the AMD 16 cores.




budgie smuggler

6,088 posts

190 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
RogerDodger said:
Celerons were/are best avoided at all costs. Every single time I've helped someone witha computer with "Celeron inside" on it, I've run out of patience. Nothing snobby about avoiding them. I'm sure they are Z80's robbed from old Speccys.
True for the most part, but some are okay. For example the G4920 and G3920 are good enough for most stuff.

MintyScot

848 posts

223 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
Expect the latest Zen2 cpu's from AMD next year. Early reports suggest they might have caught up and dare I say surpassed Intel in IPC. Probably not ghz wise though as Intel are on 14nm+++++++ now whereas this will be the first iteration of 7nm for AMD.

I currently use an r1600 as my cpu. Very happy with it but has a lover of strategy games Ill be looking to get the next gen AMD cpu to squeeze out a few more fps. I prefer the underdog and certainly dont like Intels pricing.

Edited by MintyScot on Thursday 6th December 18:50

RobDickinson

31,343 posts

285 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
I'm keen on the zen2 3700x the leaks make it look very good

MintyScot

848 posts

223 months

Thursday 6th December 2018
quotequote all
RobDickinson said:
I'm keen on the zen2 3700x the leaks make it look very good
Indeed I'm looking for the top tier so 8 (or maybe more?) cores and definitely X variant. AMD's XFR is so good its almost pointless overclocking these days.