Unexplained deleted folders/images on HDD
Unexplained deleted folders/images on HDD
Author
Discussion

Jukebag

Original Poster:

1,463 posts

170 months

Saturday 8th December 2018
quotequote all
Just today I decided to browse through some family digital photos stored on my 1TB external HDD, and to my bewilderment I noticed that some of the folders containing photos I transferred onto the HDD from my camera had disappeared. These were photos taken this year, and as far I can recall, neither myself nor anyone else has deleted them, and I am sure they were copied onto the HDD not long after the photos were taken. I think there are 2 or maybe 3 folders that have gone, some containing a dozen photos in each folder (all named and dated) that have vanished. I have encountered this problem several times and it keeps occurring from time to time.

I routinely check the HDD for viruses. It's as if someone's been deleting them (remotely that is), whether this is possible I don't know. The HDD powers up and works fine.

Anyone had the same problem?.

Edited by Jukebag on Saturday 8th December 11:05


Edited by Jukebag on Saturday 8th December 11:28

Penelope Stopit

11,209 posts

140 months

Saturday 8th December 2018
quotequote all
You need to be looking at the OS for a virus or problem rather than the external HDD

Easternlight

3,971 posts

175 months

Saturday 8th December 2018
quotequote all
Try some file recovery software that may find them if they have been deleted.
Are you sure you saved them on there? I find it's very easy to miss saving stuff or saving it in the wrong place.
I try to backup my photos in two different drives for redundancy, but often get in a pickle with itspin

Jukebag

Original Poster:

1,463 posts

170 months

Sunday 9th December 2018
quotequote all
Im sure they were saved on the harddrive and didn't forget to add them. It's likely a virus or something that's causing this, but why certain folders disappear and not the rest that are all contained in the same folder, is abit strange. All the folders are listed by year, with individual folders in each year labelled for each month the photos were taken in. If it were a virus, wouldn't it infect/damage the entire folder?.

essayer

10,410 posts

225 months

Sunday 9th December 2018
quotequote all
I hope it’s all backed up, if not get that done now; could well be on the way out

Sheepshanks

41,377 posts

150 months

Sunday 9th December 2018
quotequote all
External USB HDDs always seem bit flakey especially if you’re not super careful disconnecting them.

I use a NAS now although I had issues with the first one from Western Digital - now use Synology.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 9th December 2018
quotequote all
Doubt a virus would delete specific folders.

As others said external drives can be very fussy about being disconnected properly before pulling the cable out. Usually have to right click the drive and ej3ct it before pulling the cable out. I’d suspect you didn’t do this.

Alternatively if you’re using back up software or phone photo syncing software or some cloud syncing service then depending on how you’ve set it up adding a file somewhere will add it evereywhere, but likewise deleting a file somewhere can delete it everywhere.

Skyedriver

23,721 posts

313 months

Sunday 9th December 2018
quotequote all
Understand your concern as I too have had photo folders vanish.
Sometimes they have just moved into another folder (folder in a folder) but there is one folder I have yet to find and it is a series of photos that are unrepeatable (6 A4 Pacifics at Locomotion). Can't find them on my external back up either so must have vanished before I did a back up.

TonyRPH

13,550 posts

199 months

Sunday 9th December 2018
quotequote all
Highly unlikely to be a virus.

If you didn't click the little icon to safely remove the disk*, it can appear that the data has been copied, however it is only cached in memory (depending on how much data) and then it's committed to disk at the point you click the "safely remove disk" icon (this is also time dependant, the data is only cached for a fixed time period).

  • this assumes you performed the copy and then almost immediately unplugged the disk.
This is the same action that causes data / disk corruption in the event of a power failure. The system could be midway through committing cached data to disk, and then the power fails - leaving the data unwritten and lost.

This is why servers have battery backed RAID controllers, as any uncommitted data is held in (RAID controller) memory using the battery power until mains power is restored.

Jukebag

Original Poster:

1,463 posts

170 months

Sunday 9th December 2018
quotequote all
Thanks for the advice.

It's interesting you mention making sure to safely disconect the HDD properly from the computer. This is something I always do, but in the case of this particular external HDD (when upon trying to safely remove it by right mouse clicking on "safely remove"), which should normally be listed in the drop down bar, I find that this option isn't there, only for other actions like reformat, etc. Why the safely remove option isn't there I've no idea. Even within the main taskbar on the bottom right of the screen, there is no safely remove icon to click, which is why I often have to simple pull the USB out, or just shut down or restart Windows. On the other external I have, which incidentally stopped working a few months ago, the safely remove option was there, but not on the external HDD I'm using now. I also have a few usb pen drives that I use, and the safely remove option is displayed also.

Why one HDD would display the safely remove optiin yet another won't I've no idea.

Thankfully though, I think all of the photos that have vanished are still on my camera.

Edited by Jukebag on Sunday 9th December 18:07

buggalugs

9,296 posts

268 months

Monday 10th December 2018
quotequote all
  1. 1 cause of this is accidentally dragging the folder into another folder, it’s very easily done. Do some searches or click through them all manually.

Jukebag

Original Poster:

1,463 posts

170 months

Wednesday 12th December 2018
quotequote all
I'm almost certain the folders/photos haven't been accidentally dragged to a different folder as I rarely ever drag folders over from the camera into another folder on an external or internal HDD, but instead I just highlight the photos I want and click copy, open up the destination folder and paste them into that folder, so there would be no chance of them dropping into a different folder. As I said previously, it maybe because I can't safely remove the HDD from my laptop which causes some of the folders to disappear, but again why some and not others I don't know. Why this particular external HDD drives doesn't display the safelty remove function I've no idea (btw the model is a Seagate 1TB).

It could be that the folder within the SD is corrupted. And also, some of the photos are grouped together with other photos taken from a different camera and resolution, but whether that makes any difference I don't know.

TonyRPH

13,550 posts

199 months

Wednesday 12th December 2018
quotequote all
When the disk is plugged in, open up Windows explorer and "Right click" on the disk and go to "Properties".

You should see a list of the various disk drives in your system.

Highlight the USB drive in question, and click the "Properties" button, which will open the "<disk drive name> USB properties" - then click on the "Policies" tab.

Under "Removal Policy" check the "Quick Removal (default)" radio button (if not already checked) and click ok.

This will disable write caching on the device (should be disabled already by default anyway).


buggalugs

9,296 posts

268 months

Wednesday 12th December 2018
quotequote all
Jukebag said:
I'm almost certain the folders/photos haven't been accidentally dragged to a different folder as I rarely ever drag folders over from the camera into another folder on an external or internal HDD, but instead I just highlight the photos I want and click copy, open up the destination folder and paste them into that folder,
That's not how it works - move your mouse pointer down a big list of folders while you accidentally hit the mouse button, voila disappearing folders. If you're lucky it will just be under one of the folders next to it. If you're not it'll land on the desktop or somewhere completely frikking random.

TonyRPH

13,550 posts

199 months

Wednesday 12th December 2018
quotequote all
buggalugs said:
That's not how it works - move your mouse pointer down a big list of folders while you accidentally hit the mouse button, voila disappearing folders. If you're lucky it will just be under one of the folders next to it. If you're not it'll land on the desktop or somewhere completely frikking random.
I used to work with someone who did this all the time.

She'd sit at her desk with the left mouse button depressed to select a file / folder, and someone would talk to her and she'd turn around to look at them, dragging her mouse as she did so, but then let go of the button in the process.... <boom> a whole load of files moved to some random area.

I eventually revoked her rights to do anything other than read files as she did it so often (I'm a sysadmin).