Apple magic mouse replacement
Author
Discussion

Gad-Westy

Original Poster:

16,663 posts

244 months

Wednesday 12th December 2018
quotequote all
Our apple magic mouse is driving me mad. Constantly disconnecting and reconnecting when it receives even the mildest of bumps. Tried all the fixes, different batteries from all sorts of manufacturers, paper wedges etc. Some work a bit, some work not at all.

It's time to replace it. This one hails from 2011. Would a new one have the same issues? I like the functionality and feel of it, just not the disconnecting. Or a third party mouse that offers the same kind of interface?

Or maybe the apple touchpad but I need to check whether my daughter could still play roblox with a touchpad or I'll have a mutiny on my hands!

jesusbuiltmycar

5,143 posts

285 months

Wednesday 12th December 2018
quotequote all
Funny you should mention this. I bought a new IMac last month and I have had nothing but issues with magic mouse/keyboard disconnects and all Apple's so called 'Geniuses' can do is siggest I reboot the system.

Last week they replaced the iMac with a new one and if anything it is worse. It would appear from the number of people complaining about Bluetooth issues with Macs on the internet that Apple's implementation of Bluetooth is fundamentally broken; it does not even support restart (via the shift+option+bluetooth icon -> debug -> restart) and any attempt to do so results in "Blueooth Unavailable" which is only solvable via a reboot.

I now run with the keybard plugged in (via a lightning cable) and currently use an old corded mouse. I was coming on here to ask for recommendations for a decent quality corded mouse should I decide to keep the IMac.

I have a call scheduled this evening to see what my options are - out of the box this machine is clearly not fit for purpose.

Gad-Westy

Original Poster:

16,663 posts

244 months

Wednesday 12th December 2018
quotequote all
jesusbuiltmycar said:
Funny you should mention this. I bought a new IMac last month and I have had nothing but issues with magic mouse/keyboard disconnects and all Apple's so called 'Geniuses' can do is siggest I reboot the system.

Last week they replaced the iMac with a new one and if anything it is worse. It would appear from the number of people complaining about Bluetooth issues with Macs on the internet that Apple's implementation of Bluetooth is fundamentally broken; it does not even support restart (via the shift+option+bluetooth icon -> debug -> restart) and any attempt to do so results in "Blueooth Unavailable" which is only solvable via a reboot.

I now run with the keybard plugged in (via a lightning cable) and currently use an old corded mouse. I was coming on here to ask for recommendations for a decent quality corded mouse should I decide to keep the IMac.

I have a call scheduled this evening to see what my options are - out of the box this machine is clearly not fit for purpose.
Well glad it's not just me. Though I think the issues we are having a slightly different. The gen 1 magic mouse like ours uses 2xAA batteries but the terminals are prone to losing connection and are extremely picky with regard to exact battery size. Basically if the mouse gets any kind of knock, including something as little as having the audactiy to pick it up and place it on a mouse mat, the batteries temporarily lose connection and the computer loses sight of the mouse. It's not happening constantly!

goldieandblackie

273 posts

125 months

Wednesday 12th December 2018
quotequote all
I brought a Logitech MX Master 2 wireless mouse for my iMac and have never looked back after using it for over 6 months.
https://www.techradar.com/uk/reviews/logitech-mx-m...

WinstonWolf

72,863 posts

270 months

Wednesday 12th December 2018
quotequote all
Gad-Westy said:
Our apple magic mouse is driving me mad. Constantly disconnecting and reconnecting when it receives even the mildest of bumps. Tried all the fixes, different batteries from all sorts of manufacturers, paper wedges etc. Some work a bit, some work not at all.

It's time to replace it. This one hails from 2011. Would a new one have the same issues? I like the functionality and feel of it, just not the disconnecting. Or a third party mouse that offers the same kind of interface?

Or maybe the apple touchpad but I need to check whether my daughter could still play roblox with a touchpad or I'll have a mutiny on my hands!
The Apple Trackpad is awesome IMO, I much prefer it to the mouse.

jesusbuiltmycar

5,143 posts

285 months

Wednesday 12th December 2018
quotequote all
goldieandblackie said:
I brought a Logitech MX Master 2 wireless mouse for my iMac and have never looked back after using it for over 6 months.
https://www.techradar.com/uk/reviews/logitech-mx-m...
I take it there is no corded/vired version of that...

boxst

3,806 posts

176 months

Wednesday 12th December 2018
quotequote all
Gad-Westy said:
jesusbuiltmycar said:
Funny you should mention this. I bought a new IMac last month and I have had nothing but issues with magic mouse/keyboard disconnects and all Apple's so called 'Geniuses' can do is siggest I reboot the system.

Last week they replaced the iMac with a new one and if anything it is worse. It would appear from the number of people complaining about Bluetooth issues with Macs on the internet that Apple's implementation of Bluetooth is fundamentally broken; it does not even support restart (via the shift+option+bluetooth icon -> debug -> restart) and any attempt to do so results in "Blueooth Unavailable" which is only solvable via a reboot.

I now run with the keybard plugged in (via a lightning cable) and currently use an old corded mouse. I was coming on here to ask for recommendations for a decent quality corded mouse should I decide to keep the IMac.

I have a call scheduled this evening to see what my options are - out of the box this machine is clearly not fit for purpose.
Well glad it's not just me. Though I think the issues we are having a slightly different. The gen 1 magic mouse like ours uses 2xAA batteries but the terminals are prone to losing connection and are extremely picky with regard to exact battery size. Basically if the mouse gets any kind of knock, including something as little as having the audactiy to pick it up and place it on a mouse mat, the batteries temporarily lose connection and the computer loses sight of the mouse. It's not happening constantly!
And me. Both the keyboard and trackpad will disconnect and sometimes reconnect for no apparent reason: Apple have had the iMac for a couple of weeks, replaced the motherboard and both the keyboard and trackpad and then a few months later it starts all again. Very weird.

To fix it, I just have a couple of lightning cables dangling from the back and just plug them in for a "bit" (not sure how long, depends) and then it'll work again for a while.

nikaiyo2

5,980 posts

226 months

Wednesday 12th December 2018
quotequote all
Get the Magic Mouse 2. The current version for sale, it is a big improvement over the original. Mainly as It’s rechargeable so no issues with the stupid batteries.

gregs656

12,436 posts

212 months

Wednesday 12th December 2018
quotequote all
I have an MX Master also. Rubbish name but decent bit of kit.

Gad-Westy

Original Poster:

16,663 posts

244 months

Wednesday 12th December 2018
quotequote all
nikaiyo2 said:
Get the Magic Mouse 2. The current version for sale, it is a big improvement over the original. Mainly as It’s rechargeable so no issues with the stupid batteries.
Have gone with this option. Picked one up tonight. Hope that is the end of the issues, but my word, they aren't cheap are they!?

jesusbuiltmycar

5,143 posts

285 months

Thursday 13th December 2018
quotequote all
Gad-Westy said:
nikaiyo2 said:
Get the Magic Mouse 2. The current version for sale, it is a big improvement over the original. Mainly as It’s rechargeable so no issues with the stupid batteries.
Have gone with this option. Picked one up tonight. Hope that is the end of the issues, but my word, they aren't cheap are they!?
I find it is a bh to use with a lightning cable plugged in...

Craikeybaby

12,179 posts

256 months

Thursday 13th December 2018
quotequote all
I have had mine for 8 years, always using it with Sanyo Eneloop batteries, and have never had a problem.

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Thursday 13th December 2018
quotequote all
WinstonWolf said:
Gad-Westy said:
Our apple magic mouse is driving me mad. Constantly disconnecting and reconnecting when it receives even the mildest of bumps. Tried all the fixes, different batteries from all sorts of manufacturers, paper wedges etc. Some work a bit, some work not at all.

It's time to replace it. This one hails from 2011. Would a new one have the same issues? I like the functionality and feel of it, just not the disconnecting. Or a third party mouse that offers the same kind of interface?

Or maybe the apple touchpad but I need to check whether my daughter could still play roblox with a touchpad or I'll have a mutiny on my hands!
The Apple Trackpad is awesome IMO, I much prefer it to the mouse.
Me too. No good for games though.

AJB88

16,004 posts

202 months

Thursday 13th December 2018
quotequote all
I have a A1296 and it constantly disconnects etc. Tried all the fixes myself.

nikaiyo2

5,980 posts

226 months

Friday 14th December 2018
quotequote all
jesusbuiltmycar said:
I find it is a bh to use with a lightning cable plugged in...
LOL it is a daft design from that point of view, but it literally takes about 10 minutes to charge.

I do still have the old Magic mouse that I use the odd time i cant wait for charging.

B17NNS

18,506 posts

278 months

Friday 14th December 2018
quotequote all
AJB88 said:
I have a A1296 and it constantly disconnects etc. Tried all the fixes myself.
Same. Mine can drop out a couple of times a day. That and the constant need to charge/replace the batteries. Frustrating for an £80 mouse.

AJB88

16,004 posts

202 months

Friday 14th December 2018
quotequote all
B17NNS said:
Same. Mine can drop out a couple of times a day. That and the constant need to charge/replace the batteries. Frustrating for an £80 mouse.
Got mine 2nd hand off eBay, originally presumed it was just broke but then realised it seems to be the norm, I use mine with ChromeOS Chromebase but also tried it with my old 2010 MBP and it was the same.

Not tried it with my Dell Ubuntu setup.