Is a Chromebook a poor man’s laptop?
Is a Chromebook a poor man’s laptop?
Author
Discussion

highway

Original Poster:

2,743 posts

291 months

Wednesday 26th December 2018
quotequote all
We have a Mac which is rarely used other than as a repository for music. My daughter needs to donher school homework and the Mac apparently isn’t compatible with the school systems.

The Mrs says get a Chromebook. They are around £180. We stalled getting her one for Xmas in the hope they’d be on sale soon. I was disturbed to hear that the expected lifespan for a chrome book is only around two years.

It seems a chrome book doesn’t have any form of disk drive nonetheless am I better off paying the extra to get a laptop. It will largely be used for doing school homework

Brainpox

4,331 posts

182 months

Wednesday 26th December 2018
quotequote all
It will be fine for schoolwork unless she needs perfect compatibility with MS Office.

acd80

751 posts

176 months

Wednesday 26th December 2018
quotequote all
I have several Apple devices - a Macbook, Macbook Pro and an iMac as I run my own business and have differing requirements for different situations. I bought my wife a Chromebook earlier in the year (this one https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B073Q44S56/ref... for £99 when it was on offer. They are bloody brilliant for what they do and you can install Office on Chromebooks if required as well as use Googledocs. They are perfectly adequate for school coursework.

I'm going to look at buying one in the new year as I've got a few trips lined up to less salubrious parts of the world and I don't fancy getting a £4k laptop nicked.

I suggest you keep an eye out on Hotukdeals to see when the special offers on Chromebooks appear - they are quite frequent in fairness.

FunkyNige

9,866 posts

306 months

Wednesday 26th December 2018
quotequote all
I've got one similar to thIs https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B073R9CXM2/ref=cm_sw_r...
With a touch screen that hinges all the way round so you can use it as a tablet.
The only negatives I can think of for using it for coursework is that it's set up for the online editors (Google docs, Microsoft stuff) which are never as good as installed ones, and the screen/keyboard on them are generally quite small.

ATG

23,870 posts

303 months

Wednesday 26th December 2018
quotequote all
Why not ask the school what they recommend?

mattley

3,039 posts

253 months

Wednesday 26th December 2018
quotequote all
highway said:
My daughter needs to donher school homework and the Mac apparently isn’t compatible with the school systems.
Well surly it's up to school to tell you what is compatible. FWIW I'm going to say that if a mac isn't then a ChromeBook won't be.

:/




ExVantagemech..

5,733 posts

246 months

Wednesday 26th December 2018
quotequote all
We have had chromebooks for about 3 or 4 years.
Positives, that they now pretty much run like an android phone - when I bought my first one they only had crappy chrome add ons.
Now you can download from the android store, only the spec of the Chromebook depends on how or if it runs.
My Dell packed up earlier this year, foolishly I bought the lower spec Acer (looks nice - all alloy frame/ build) but only 2GB RAM.
IMO they need a minimum of 4GB, that or the chipset in the Acer is worse than a 3 yr old Dell.
Hook it to a wireless printer, connect it to your Gmail, Drive etc easily.
Theres a few things as said already that make it struggle or fails at.
I guess touch screens may enable signing docs etc, Ive done that on my phone instead (save to cloud and its instantly accessible)

Wife was a bit offish at first - big apple fan, but insisted on another Chromebook, rather than a cheap laptop.

caelite

4,282 posts

143 months

Wednesday 26th December 2018
quotequote all
They are great for basically doing everything a tablet can do, but for less money & in the form of an 'old style' laptop.

I picked my mum up one to replace her ageing laptop for emailing, browsing & watching iPlayer. With her old windows laptop it felt like every 2nd week I had to be over fixing 'something' on it. But the chromebook has given her 2 years of trouble/virus free use barring some wierd chrome popups that I had to block after she clicked some ads.

ging84

9,548 posts

177 months

Wednesday 26th December 2018
quotequote all
Not sure how they are the poor mans laptop, you pay a slight premium for a device running google's free OS
sure they're are some really cheap ones, but there are some really cheap windows PC, and in theory some of that money goes towards paying for windows.

i guess perception is everything and this is why they're still aren't any other premium models

hyphen

26,262 posts

121 months

Wednesday 26th December 2018
quotequote all
highway said:
We have a Mac which is rarely used other than as a repository for music. My daughter needs to donher school homework and the Mac apparently isn’t compatible with the school systems.
If OSX isn't compatible, then guessing windows.

OP - remember that Google business model is to spy, track and collect every piece of data they can about their users and then sell this data to the highest bidders. Do you want that for your daughter? Cheap for a reason.

egor110

17,693 posts

234 months

Wednesday 26th December 2018
quotequote all
If it's just for her homework why not just spend £100 on a used hp elite book with i5 ?