Sony 1000XM3 v Bose Quietcontrol30
Discussion
So I lost my Bose set after only 4 months of use but Wifey, bless her, bought me a new set for Crimbo which took me by surprise as we'd agreed to not spend out too much this year.
I really liked the Bose but was not that impressed with the ANC which was my main reason for getting them. I used them a lot in what can be a very noisy machine and fabrication workshop but found them not as good as passive ear defenders.
So i've decided to give ANC another try and will be sending the Bose back (or letting Wifey have them) and will be opting for "proper" full over ear headphones. I've watched hours of videos, reviews and tests which all seem to go for the XM3 Sonys for best ANC. I've always regarded Bose as the benchmark but things seem to have changed.
So does anybody have the Sonys? Were you blown away by them? and what have you compared them with?
I'll be hitting the purchase button on whatever tomorrow! Many thanks for any input.
I really liked the Bose but was not that impressed with the ANC which was my main reason for getting them. I used them a lot in what can be a very noisy machine and fabrication workshop but found them not as good as passive ear defenders.
So i've decided to give ANC another try and will be sending the Bose back (or letting Wifey have them) and will be opting for "proper" full over ear headphones. I've watched hours of videos, reviews and tests which all seem to go for the XM3 Sonys for best ANC. I've always regarded Bose as the benchmark but things seem to have changed.
So does anybody have the Sonys? Were you blown away by them? and what have you compared them with?
I'll be hitting the purchase button on whatever tomorrow! Many thanks for any input.
Noise cancellation is only truly effective for countering ongoing drones. Any sharp sounds such as talking or clanging and they'll take a small amount of edge off but little else.
If an industrial environment is their prime purpose then I wouldn't waste the money on any noise cancellation. There won't be much in it in terms of effectiveness between Sony or Bose.
If an industrial environment is their prime purpose then I wouldn't waste the money on any noise cancellation. There won't be much in it in terms of effectiveness between Sony or Bose.
dickymint said:
I really liked the Bose but was not that impressed with the ANC which was my main reason for getting them. I used them a lot in what can be a very noisy machine and fabrication workshop but found them not as good as passive ear defenders.
I think you might find everything a bit disappointing compared to passive NC in that kind of environment.That being said I am happy with my original 1000Xs.
gregs656 said:
dickymint said:
I really liked the Bose but was not that impressed with the ANC which was my main reason for getting them. I used them a lot in what can be a very noisy machine and fabrication workshop but found them not as good as passive ear defenders.
I think you might find everything a bit disappointing compared to passive NC in that kind of environment.That being said I am happy with my original 1000Xs.
I tried Bose, Sony, B&W etc. when I was after a pair of ANC headphones and went with the Sony WH-1000XM2. The sound was better than Bose and I didn't like the fit of the B&W at all, in fact, they were downright uncomfortable. The Sonys aren't the nicest design but I have been more than happy with the noise cancelling and overall sound quality when I use them when on the train/plane.
dickymint said:
I was sort of trying to get a comparison between my old (lost) in ear Bose Quietcontrol 30's as opposed to the over/on ear Sony's hoping their passive and ANC were the better option.
I don’t think the 30s were thought to have had as good noise cancelling as the 25s or 35s anyway. I think over ears would be better, but I’m not sure they will be amazing.
They are also heavier and if you’re a warm person can get hot to wear.
I’d have a mooch about at what cheaper in ears are available these days. I had the Leophile Zeros and they were great.
dickymint said:
I was sort of trying to get a comparison between my old (lost) in ear Bose Quietcontrol 30's as opposed to the over/on ear Sony's hoping their passive and ANC were the better option.
The best noise cancelling with Bose products I've experienced is the QC20 as it combines ANC with a reasonable amount of noise isolation from the ear buds. I've had QC15s and 35s and neither were as good at keeping noise out.
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


