ADSL, VDSL, VDSL2 - whats the difference
ADSL, VDSL, VDSL2 - whats the difference
Author
Discussion

hab1966

Original Poster:

1,126 posts

243 months

Sunday 30th December 2018
quotequote all
I'm currently with Plusnet on their fibre unlimited package. I have FTTC and then copper wires to house.

Having had fun and games with my Vigor router (connected to white Openreach modem) over the last few days, ive switched to the Plusnet one box (direct connection to wall socket.)

I don't know how good the Plusnet One box is so have been looking at alternatives so i can get the 5GHz wifi, but i realise i don't understand whether i need VDSL or VDSL2.

Is ADSL the old style broadband that isnt termed fibre?

Is VDSL FTTC?

What is VDSL2? FTTP?

Thanks

Hanslow

838 posts

276 months

Sunday 30th December 2018
quotequote all
VDSL2 is what you want. VDSL is the older slower FTTC technology with approx 50Mb/s max throughput, VDSL2 allows the (up to) 80Mb/s that is offered. ADSL is the copper all the way technology that offered up to 8Mb/s.

I'm on plusnet and switched out to a Netgear D6400 very soon after everything was settled down and have been happy with it enough to not want to change make/model of router. I used to use a Draytek on ADSL, but went for a mid-range price option with the Netgear (at the time) and it's stood up well. That was probably about three years ago now when we took up the FTTC option.

The D6400 is an all in one, so you have many choices of sticking with the BT Openreach Modem along with a separate router, or go combined with an all in one unit.

Edited by Hanslow on Sunday 30th December 19:03

hab1966

Original Poster:

1,126 posts

243 months

Monday 31st December 2018
quotequote all
So the router handles whether VDSL or VDSL2 is used during negotiation?

colin79666

2,228 posts

144 months

Monday 31st December 2018
quotequote all
hab1966 said:
So the router handles whether VDSL or VDSL2 is used during negotiation?
The modem does, which might be built into the router.

The white BT modems are actually about the best you can get, especially if you have the type that matches the manufacturer of the street cabinet (huawei are the most common).

If you stick with the separate modem you get the biggest choice of router. I’ve run this setup with an Asus RT-AC68U for a couple of years with good results.

More on modems: https://kitz.co.uk/routers/openreach-modems.htm

snuffy

13,477 posts

315 months

Tuesday 1st January 2019
quotequote all
hab1966 said:
I don't know how good the Plusnet One box is so have been looking at alternatives so i can get the 5GHz wifi, but i realise i don't understand whether i need VDSL or VDSL2.
Don't fall into the trap, like I did, in thinking that 5GHz is better than 2.4GHz, because it's actually worse. I had the same as you (had a white BT openreach modem that was connected to my Plusnet router). I replaced both with a router/modem and expected the wireless to be faster on 5GHz. But oh no, it was slower. It was about to go back in the box but then I tried it on 2.4GHz and it was as before. It turns out that 5GHz is worse than 2.4GHz at going through walls etc but the reason for going to 5GHz is that it's better if you are somewhere where there are loads of 2.4Ghz networks. But as I don't (I can see about 6 or 8 wireless networks right now (and most people will not hide their SSID)) so it's not congested.

Trustmeimadoctor

14,373 posts

186 months

Tuesday 1st January 2019
quotequote all
If all of them are on the same channel it will be congested

snuffy

13,477 posts

315 months

Tuesday 1st January 2019
quotequote all
Trustmeimadoctor said:
If all of them are on the same channel it will be congested
Most routers (all of them now?) will select the least congested channel it can find.

I'vs just checked mine using the MS WiFi analyser and there is only 1 other network on the same channel as me and that keeps going out of range.

As I say, it depends where you are. Middle of a city or in a block of flats and it will be very congested of course.