Windows AV or something better (free).
Windows AV or something better (free).
Author
Discussion

Skyedriver

Original Poster:

23,707 posts

313 months

Sunday 30th December 2018
quotequote all
Son's new PC has the usual Windows Firewall and AV on it. I usually add Avast or AVG to any new computer but should the Microsoft kit be sufficient?
I usually find adding another wall of AV just slows things down..

The_Jackal

4,854 posts

228 months

Sunday 30th December 2018
quotequote all
Avast and AVG are rarely recommended these days.
Add Malwarebytes if you want an extra level of protection.

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Sunday 30th December 2018
quotequote all
Don't run two. Windows Defender is as good as anything free.

Narcisus

9,108 posts

311 months

Sunday 30th December 2018
quotequote all
Have look around for a cheap Norton deal. It's excellent these days. I've used it for years.

( Waits for the usual it's a resource hog etc from the IT experts )

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 30th December 2018
quotequote all
Windows 10 AV and Defender are almost adequate. I recommend you also install either Superantispyware, or Malwarebytes antimalware - the free versions that do NOT do real time protection. Once a month or so, let them do a software/database update.

Then, if you do get a nasty piece of malware, you have a head start, as installing either once infected is very very difficult indeed.

I had a couple of nasty infection with Win 7, but nothing so far with Win 10.

I gave up with AVG and Avast. An unescessary overhead and lots of pop ups etc.

With Win 10 AV and defender, and firewall, there really is little need for another layer of AVG, particularly if you are not the type to download cracked programs etc.

Edited by anonymous-user on Sunday 30th December 20:48

Brainpox

4,331 posts

182 months

Sunday 30th December 2018
quotequote all
You can get multi-device licenses for most security suites for under £25 on Amazon. Can you invest a little bit and not worry about whether the free stuff is good enough or not?

hyphen

26,262 posts

121 months

Sunday 30th December 2018
quotequote all
If you want two, Raspberry Pi with a firewall etc and route your internet through that.

egor110

17,693 posts

234 months

Monday 31st December 2018
quotequote all
What about comodo ?

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 31st December 2018
quotequote all
ash73 said:
There's a reason Defender is unobtrusive; it detects almost nothing.
That is my experience. I’ve run literally hundreds of machines with different AV and I don’t recall defender ever detecting anything at all!!!

I find Norton will prevent most infections and malware bytes is good for malware, there may be better out there but these work well for me. Personally imho a machine with just defender on it is essentially unprotected BUT I’ve heard better IT types than me say it’s all you need albeit I’ve seen their machines get malware attacks etc so I’m confused by their view. I just stick to what works for me.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 1st January 2019
quotequote all
grumbledoak said:
Don't run two. Windows Defender is as good as anything free.
Do you know of any reviews that show how good Defender is compared to other free AV to support your point? Genuine question, as I am deeply sceptical about Defender myself. But am happy to be educated. TY.

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Tuesday 1st January 2019
quotequote all
MikeStroud said:
Do you know of any reviews that show how good Defender is compared to other free AV to support your point? Genuine question, as I am deeply sceptical about Defender myself. But am happy to be educated. TY.
Nothing right up to date, if I'm honest.

Chris Hinds

497 posts

196 months

Tuesday 1st January 2019
quotequote all
Sophos Home - https://home.sophos.com which is Enterprise class but zero cost... albeit with less configuration available.

TonyRPH

13,550 posts

199 months

Tuesday 1st January 2019
quotequote all
MikeStroud said:
Do you know of any reviews that show how good Defender is compared to other free AV to support your point? Genuine question, as I am deeply sceptical about Defender myself. But am happy to be educated. TY.
Here's a fairly recent review(June 2018)

For those who say they've never seen Defender detect anything, I have seen it in action.


TonyRPH

13,550 posts

199 months

Tuesday 1st January 2019
quotequote all
hyphen said:
If you want two, Raspberry Pi with a firewall etc and route your internet through that.
A firewall need two interfaces, a Rasperry Pi only has one.

Additionally, for any kind of reasonably fast connection, a Pi just cannot handle the throughput required.

Even when configured as a PiHole server, I've seen the Pi struggle to serve DNS requests fast enough when faced with more than 3 - 4 simultaneous connections.

Australiam

277 posts

160 months

Wednesday 2nd January 2019
quotequote all
Chris Hinds said:
Sophos Home - https://home.sophos.com which is Enterprise class but zero cost... albeit with less configuration available.
+1 - well worth considering.

HM-2

12,467 posts

200 months

Wednesday 2nd January 2019
quotequote all
The_Jackal said:
Add Malwarebytes if you want an extra level of protection.
MalwareBytes is categorically awful- it's premium product is the worst performing AV on the market in comparison tests.

Windows Defender is perfectly good, but if you're averse to using it then I'd suggest Avira. It's much less intrusive than either AVG or Avast, plus better detection rates and lower false positive rates too. The notion that Defender detects less than Avast and AVG has been demonstrated wrong in the most recent AV-LAB testing, where they all had similar detection rates (somewhat behind the other 11 providers that received "best picks", which include the likes of Avira and Sophos).

Unlike Avast, it also doesn't have a history of bricking systems when it doesn't agree with a Windows update.



-Edited for speeling

Edited by HM-2 on Wednesday 2nd January 13:20

geeks

11,892 posts

170 months

Wednesday 2nd January 2019
quotequote all
I use Avast paid for AV, have done for some time and never had an issue with it nor a pop up (although probably as I pay for the basic one) gives me use on 5 machines and is pretty cheap.

I did used to use Avira until it let a load of nasties through.

Come renewal time on Avast I will probably swap to Sophos home though as I am a big fan of it in "the enterprise".

Malwarebytes has always been a bit st in my experience...

clonmult

10,529 posts

240 months

Wednesday 2nd January 2019
quotequote all
Australiam said:
Chris Hinds said:
Sophos Home - https://home.sophos.com which is Enterprise class but zero cost... albeit with less configuration available.
+1 - well worth considering.
-1. "enterprise class" can often be meaningless, but often tends to mean that it is a resource hog, a sod to operate and generally not advisable. I've had way too many years working with enterprise systems and software.

geeks

11,892 posts

170 months

Wednesday 2nd January 2019
quotequote all
clonmult said:
Australiam said:
Chris Hinds said:
Sophos Home - https://home.sophos.com which is Enterprise class but zero cost... albeit with less configuration available.
+1 - well worth considering.
-1. "enterprise class" can often be meaningless, but often tends to mean that it is a resource hog, a sod to operate and generally not advisable. I've had way too many years working with enterprise systems and software.
I would disagree, Sophos is pretty well known and liked by all who run it/use it/administer it. "Enterprise Class" can be a misnomer but its pretty solid in this regard!

Funk

27,811 posts

240 months

Wednesday 2nd January 2019
quotequote all
Australiam said:
Chris Hinds said:
Sophos Home - https://home.sophos.com which is Enterprise class but zero cost... albeit with less configuration available.
+1 - well worth considering.
I tried it and hated it - it was a complete pain in the backside as it only offered a web-based GUI.

Ultimately I purchased Bitdefender for up to 5 machines on a 2-year discount a while back and it's been great (although that doesn't solve the OP's requirement for something free...).