Anyone use Nest or Ring ip cameras?
Anyone use Nest or Ring ip cameras?
Author
Discussion

Cpl nobby nobbs

Original Poster:

390 posts

168 months

Monday 31st December 2018
quotequote all
The wife would like some cameras around the house, possibly 2 external and 2 internal.

We have a Nest thermostat and smoke detectors already so this would seem like the obvious choice but the subscription seem like it could get expensive with a few cameras and the outdoor cameras are only held on to the base plates by magnets.

Ring seems to have cheaper subscriptions, they replace cameras if they get stolen but they don't do a small indoor camera, just the stick up cam that is quite large. They do offer a couple of options for outside that come with lights though.

Anyone use these systems and can offer an opinion based on your experience.

HOGEPH

5,249 posts

217 months

Monday 31st December 2018
quotequote all
I have a Ring camera/searchlight, which replaced my standard PIR on the back of the house.

Alerts me to any movement, (including my cats), but you can adjust sensitivity etc.

You can remotely turn on lights or set off the siren, or speak to the uninvited guests.

I paid for a year's subscription which holds your recordings for a set length of time.

Worth it for the piece of mind I think.

NDA

25,830 posts

256 months

Monday 31st December 2018
quotequote all
I've just had lunch with someone whose 'Ring' CCTV doorbell pinged to life whilst we were at lunch. The quality of the image was amazing - very impressed.

33q

1,629 posts

154 months

Monday 31st December 2018
quotequote all
HOGEPH said:
I have a Ring camera/searchlight, which replaced my standard PIR on the back of the house.

Alerts me to any movement, (including my cats), but you can adjust sensitivity etc.

You can remotely turn on lights or set off the siren, or speak to the uninvited guests.

I paid for a year's subscription which holds your recordings for a set length of time.

Worth it for the piece of mind I think.
Ring Spotlights back and front
Ring doorbells back and front

I like them...good quality....but you need good wifi to get the best performance

sooty61

750 posts

202 months

Tuesday 1st January 2019
quotequote all
I have had a Ring Spotlight cam (battery) for a few months and I am very impressed with the quality of the product, the reliability and how simple it is to use.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 1st January 2019
quotequote all
I have both.

Nest wired outdoor cam has really good picture quality and intelligent zoning, but it does lack a light, siren and is hard wired. If you want to to run it from an internal plug socket a considerable hole would need to be drilled through the house (inch) to get the wiring and junction box through. Good integration with Google products though and the app alerts are good.

Ring outdoor battery: picture quality possibly isn't as good as Nest, and there is no pre-alert buffer (i.e. it doesn't record the seconds leasing up to an event) but it is fairly responsive. The light and siren are great and it didn't need a hole through the house. You can also buy a wired version if needed which enables more intelligent zoning and buffering. Sometimes the app hangs.

If I only had to pick one, I would say the Ring stuff is easier and has more features. Although, as it's Amazon, integration may be an issue if the rest of your house is primarily Google Home. I am a big Nest fan due to the smoke alarm etc.

ETA. Yes, the Nest cams are only held on magnetically but realistically they need to be about 7ft high to provide a good aspect. And the length of attached wire would make them a pain to nick. The ring cam is actually held on to a bracket using a ball socket, which I have to periodically check after strong winds etc.

Edited by JIMMYJ4ZZ on Tuesday 1st January 11:01

TheRainMaker

7,889 posts

273 months

Tuesday 1st January 2019
quotequote all
Cpl nobby nobbs said:
The wife would like some cameras around the house, possibly 2 external and 2 internal.

We have a Nest thermostat and smoke detectors already so this would seem like the obvious choice but the subscription seem like it could get expensive with a few cameras and the outdoor cameras are only held on to the base plates by magnets.
We have the nest iq cameras outside, a base plate is screwed to the wall then the camera clips to that, you need a tools to remove it.

We also have indoor cameras and a load of smoke detectors the whole app works really well and seems to respond quicker than the ring app which we have for the doorbell.

Cpl nobby nobbs

Original Poster:

390 posts

168 months

Tuesday 1st January 2019
quotequote all
Thanks all for the great info.

At the moment and for what it will be used for the nest IQ cams would go beyond what I want to spend.

For my very basic home automation I use Amazon echo plus and a couple of dots, they seem to play OK with the nest thermostat. The other stuff is just Tuya plugs for lights ans such.

Looked at the ring Pro doorbell for the front and expected it to notify you via the echo this would be a really good feature, but that's only available in the US for some reason.

I do like the Nest app it works well, the Nest doorbell also looks great but not very big in the UK, and I have no current wiring for one at this house.

So much stuff out there and it's not just a few quid,.

Basically I want it all, I just need someone else to pay for it.

TheRainMaker

7,889 posts

273 months

Tuesday 1st January 2019
quotequote all
Oh, one other thing, if you have a google home hub, the nest cameras stream directly to them.

“Google show me the drive” etc etc smile

tenohfive

6,276 posts

213 months

Tuesday 1st January 2019
quotequote all
For indoor use both Arlo and Blink are worth considering, and I think Netatmo do one too. Blink are also owned by Amazon so it can only be a matter of time before they become one with Ring. Arlo also do external cameras although no doorbell to the best of my knowledge, and get good reviews. Neither require a subscription for full functionality IIRC.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 1st January 2019
quotequote all
Cpl nobby nobbs said:

Looked at the ring Pro doorbell for the front and expected it to notify you via the echo this would be a really good feature, but that's only available in the US for some reason.
You would be able to use Stringify or IFTTT to enable the Ring doorbell to blink the light of the room you are in or suchlike as a notification - might solve this point for you.