Time to upgrade, time for a change?
Time to upgrade, time for a change?
Author
Discussion

Kewy

Original Poster:

1,464 posts

125 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
My phone contract is up. Currently have an iPhone 7 Plus – works fine to be honest except the taptic engine is broken so it makes a horrible sound when it vibrates (quoted £60 to fix by Apple).

Its worth noting at this stage that I currently get a 30% off family and friends discount with EE. My Current contract was costing me about £40,

I have a few choices:

• Pay for the 7 Plus to be repaired, then get a sim only contract for about £15 a month – I would lose my family and friends discount and the family member no longer works for EE so I wouldn' get it back.

• Get another iPhone, the XS range is quite frankly ridiclous in price, even with F&F I'd be looking at about £55 a month and I'm not really willing to up my contract by £15 a month. So the only other option is an XR which would be a couple of quid more than my current one. Is the XR actually any better than the 7 Plus?? It doesn't have dual cameras for a start, and I'm not even sure the screen resolution is as good from what I can see? Would it be a pointless upgrade? (this would keep my F&F 30% discount)

• Get a Samsung Note 9 – I really apprehensive about this one, but part of me is tempted to give Android another go. I tried in the past and wasn't a huge fan but I'm guessing its come a long way in the last 6 or 7 years. Can't really be arsed to learn a new bit of tech as I have only just bought a new camera and I'm focusing on that, but it's not out the question. The Note would be about the same as my current contract (this would keep my F&F 30% discount).

My thoughts are that if I go sim only now, then maybe there is another couple of years in my 7 Plus – but then after two years I'd be back to paying full price for phone contract and christ knows what they'll be charging by then.

Any suggestions?

viggyp

1,919 posts

166 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
Kewy said:
My phone contract is up. Currently have an iPhone 7 Plus – works fine to be honest except the taptic engine is broken so it makes a horrible sound when it vibrates (quoted £60 to fix by Apple).

Its worth noting at this stage that I currently get a 30% off family and friends discount with EE. My Current contract was costing me about £40,

I have a few choices:

• Pay for the 7 Plus to be repaired, then get a sim only contract for about £15 a month – I would lose my family and friends discount and the family member no longer works for EE so I wouldn' get it back.

• Get another iPhone, the XS range is quite frankly ridiclous in price, even with F&F I'd be looking at about £55 a month and I'm not really willing to up my contract by £15 a month. So the only other option is an XR which would be a couple of quid more than my current one. Is the XR actually any better than the 7 Plus?? It doesn't have dual cameras for a start, and I'm not even sure the screen resolution is as good from what I can see? Would it be a pointless upgrade? (this would keep my F&F 30% discount)

• Get a Samsung Note 9 – I really apprehensive about this one, but part of me is tempted to give Android another go. I tried in the past and wasn't a huge fan but I'm guessing its come a long way in the last 6 or 7 years. Can't really be arsed to learn a new bit of tech as I have only just bought a new camera and I'm focusing on that, but it's not out the question. The Note would be about the same as my current contract (this would keep my F&F 30% discount).

My thoughts are that if I go sim only now, then maybe there is another couple of years in my 7 Plus – but then after two years I'd be back to paying full price for phone contract and christ knows what they'll be charging by then.

Any suggestions?
Apologies but I can't comment on the Samsung as only ever had iPhones but the Note 9 has 6gb RAM compared to the 3gb available on the iPhone XR. I watched this video last night funny enough so this may be able to help you decide? https://youtu.be/l4Dofj8r5jo

I upgraded from a 6S to a XR which was a huge difference although other than the processor and camera (and haptic touch) I was told by an Apple employee that there wasn't much difference from a 6S and 7. I love the XR and the battery is currently lasting just over three days (I always let it run out completely before charging) and regarding the lack of full HD screen and a single camera, I am still impressed with pictures I have taken and how they look on the screen.

I purchased it via the Apple finance deal which cost me £69 upfront with a monthly cost of £43.95 for the 128gb version over 20 months and includes 2 years AppleCare. This also includes the early upgrade option. I'm with Three and I pay £11 a month for 8gb data as I average 4gb so that was a no brainer.

Kewy

Original Poster:

1,464 posts

125 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
viggyp said:
Apologies but I can't comment on the Samsung as only ever had iPhones but the Note 9 has 6gb RAM compared to the 3gb available on the iPhone XR. I watched this video last night funny enough so this may be able to help you decide? https://youtu.be/l4Dofj8r5jo

I upgraded from a 6S to a XR which was a huge difference although other than the processor and camera (and haptic touch) I was told by an Apple employee that there wasn't much difference from a 6S and 7. I love the XR and the battery is currently lasting just over three days (I always let it run out completely before charging) and regarding the lack of full HD screen and a single camera, I am still impressed with pictures I have taken and how they look on the screen.

I purchased it via the Apple finance deal which cost me £69 upfront with a monthly cost of £43.95 for the 128gb version over 20 months and includes 2 years AppleCare. This also includes the early upgrade option. I'm with Three and I pay £11 a month for 8gb data as I average 4gb so that was a no brainer.
Thanks! I'll take a look at that video in my lunch break. Sound like you got a decent deal. I think I can get it cheaper via my discount but if it wasn't for the reduction then the approach you took would be a no brainer.

I'm not overly fussed about a camera, as my aim this year is to take less photos with my phone and more with my SLR. So long as it can take some half decent point and shoot stuff of friends and family then I'm not too bothered.

viggyp

1,919 posts

166 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
My pleasure Kewy. I was on SIM only anyway after my 6S contract expired and as the XR was the only one with 128gb I thought that was the one. Usually on a contract you pay a bit of interest. I forgot to mention that the monthly payment I pay is interest free.

Kewy

Original Poster:

1,464 posts

125 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
I've just found a site that compares the specs, and it would appear that everything on the XR is slightly better than the 7 plus except for the screen resolution which is worse... this doesn't help my decision! haha

viggyp

1,919 posts

166 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
smile

The specs don't show the full picture so best bet is to pop into an Apple Store or phone store to have a proper look. That's what I did but regardless I would've gotten the XR as the 8 wasn't on my radar and I didn't want to pay the prices for the X/XS.

Hammy98

942 posts

123 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
I was recently in a similar position, same phone, end of 2 year contract and wasn't sure what to do.

Your situation may be different however the battery in my 7 Plus is still pretty decent. The screen was cracked so I had that repaired - £70 - charging port failed - £20. I'm confident the phone will now go on for another couple of years provided the battery doesn't go and I don't drop it.

It's more than up to the task of playing the latest games and I personally am yet to see any slow down when using it. I'm planning to keep it until it dies or becomes obsolete.

I'm on EE 12 month SIM only:

30GB + 5GB bonus as my wifi is through them also.
Unlimited calls and texts.
£20 a month.

You can probably get a better deal with another provider but if you have any other products with EE you'll lose your discount on them.

alorotom

12,793 posts

218 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
Have a look at what other networks are offering. EE contract handset prices are comical compared to others

AJB88

16,001 posts

202 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
If you want to try Android go for the Pixel 3/ Pixel XL 3.

You will then get a taste of true Android, not Android that has had bloatware installed on it by Samsung.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
Android has come a LONG way on the last 6 years. You'd be surpised how slick it is now. There are plenty of phones without bloatware, and I have to say, I don't find the Samsung UI offensive.

The_Jackal

4,854 posts

228 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
And this bloatware you speak of doesnt impact you using the phone.
Cant you get an S9 for about £30pm?
Or buy one and get a SMARTY SIM?

pip t

1,366 posts

198 months

Wednesday 9th January 2019
quotequote all
viggyp said:
(I always let it run out completely before charging)
Slightly o/t but I’d strongly advise you not to do this - it’s possibly the worst thing you can do to a modern Li-ion battery. Back in the days of nickel based batteries this was the advice as it avoided the ‘memory effect’ associated with that type of battery. Modern batteries really don’t like deep discharge cycles. You can’t avoid it happening sometimes, but I really wouldn’t do it as a matter of course.

Back on topic, I went from a 7 Plus to an XR and I’m pretty happy with it. Decent sized screen, the camera is excellent despite not having the second lense, and the battery life is by far the best I’ve experienced on an iPhone. That said modern Android is indeed far better than it was a few years ago - and as long as you’re not too invested in the Apple ecosystem it’s pretty easy to get used to using.

viggyp

1,919 posts

166 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
pip t said:
viggyp said:
(I always let it run out completely before charging)
Slightly o/t but I’d strongly advise you not to do this - it’s possibly the worst thing you can do to a modern Li-ion battery. Back in the days of nickel based batteries this was the advice as it avoided the ‘memory effect’ associated with that type of battery. Modern batteries really don’t like deep discharge cycles. You can’t avoid it happening sometimes, but I really wouldn’t do it as a matter of course.
An Apple employee stated that you didn't have to let the battery die completely for the best results regarding battery life but I guess I'm doing it out of habit. It makes sense though as the battery on my iPhone 6S was awful and that was even after I took advantage of the battery replacement Apple did recently.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
LiPo batteries 100% do NOT like being flattened. It shortens their life very very quickly. Most gear with them in should shut you off before you get the battery too low - but then we keep turning phones back on to get that lkast bit out of them.

They also don't like being stored 100% full. More like 80% full. Long storage of 100% full leads to battery puffing and drastically reduced life. This bit is a bit more difficult to manage! :-) Just don't leave your phone on charge all day when you could be doign it overnight.

Kewy

Original Poster:

1,464 posts

125 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
Hammy98 said:
I was recently in a similar position, same phone, end of 2 year contract and wasn't sure what to do.

Your situation may be different however the battery in my 7 Plus is still pretty decent. The screen was cracked so I had that repaired - £70 - charging port failed - £20. I'm confident the phone will now go on for another couple of years provided the battery doesn't go and I don't drop it.

It's more than up to the task of playing the latest games and I personally am yet to see any slow down when using it. I'm planning to keep it until it dies or becomes obsolete.

I'm on EE 12 month SIM only:

30GB + 5GB bonus as my wifi is through them also.
Unlimited calls and texts.
£20 a month.

You can probably get a better deal with another provider but if you have any other products with EE you'll lose your discount on them.
Yeh other than my taptic engine (£60 fix), it's fine, there's nothing I need it for that it doesn't do. However if I move over to SIM only then I'll lose my 30% discount, and next time I want a new contract I'll be back to full prices – hence me being tempted to get a new handset and keep the discount, but obviously this is more expensive than a SIM only so I don't know whats the best option confused



alorotom said:
Have a look at what other networks are offering. EE contract handset prices are comical compared to others
I'll have a look, but I can't see EE being 30% more than other providers? In which case I won't get anything cheaper elsewhere.



AJB88 said:
If you want to try Android go for the Pixel 3/ Pixel XL 3.

You will then get a taste of true Android, not Android that has had bloatware installed on it by Samsung.
These weren't even on my radar, but I'll have a look. When you say Samsung bloatware, do you mean their native apps etc? Surely they can be stuck in a folder and forgotten about?



pip t said:
Back on topic, I went from a 7 Plus to an XR and I’m pretty happy with it. Decent sized screen, the camera is excellent despite not having the second lense, and the battery life is by far the best I’ve experienced on an iPhone. That said modern Android is indeed far better than it was a few years ago - and as long as you’re not too invested in the Apple ecosystem it’s pretty easy to get used to using.
Thats good to hear. What about the screen? As the XR has considerably less pixels than the 7 plus, did you notice it when you did the move?
I'm big on my photography and design so screen resolution is pretty important to me.

I've been using Apple products for years, but never really bought in to their ecosystem and have often used 3rd party apps for different services (evernote for notes, gmail for mail, contacts and calendar, manually manage my photos etc), so I'm hoping to move wouldn't be too painful if I did decide to do it. I'm more concerned about knowing how to do everything as I know iOS like the back of my hand now!


mygoldfishbowl

4,304 posts

174 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
Kewy said:
When you say Samsung bloatware, do you mean their native apps etc? Surely they can be stuck in a folder and forgotten about?
After nearly five years on a windows phone I've recently had the misfortune of using an android phone over the last couple of months. It drove me nuts with constant updating, almost every day it wanted to update this or update that. Not only what some people would describe as bloatware either, google, play store, play music, play something else, but the one that annoyed me the most was youtube. I didn't want it, I never used it but couldn't remove it, yet it updates regularly. If you don't allow the updates they just keep coming back and haunting you for ever, "there are 11 updates for your phone" or 12 or 20, and again, some things that I never used and didn't want.

In the end I turned the data and wifi off and am currently trying to go back to a five years old windows phone.

AJB88

16,001 posts

202 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
mygoldfishbowl said:
After nearly five years on a windows phone I've recently had the misfortune of using an android phone over the last couple of months. It drove me nuts with constant updating, almost every day it wanted to update this or update that. Not only what some people would describe as bloatware either, google, play store, play music, play something else, but the one that annoyed me the most was youtube. I didn't want it, I never used it but couldn't remove it, yet it updates regularly. If you don't allow the updates they just keep coming back and haunting you for ever, "there are 11 updates for your phone" or 12 or 20, and again, some things that I never used and didn't want.

In the end I turned the data and wifi off and am currently trying to go back to a five years old windows phone.
Your not used to updates because Windows has fck all support haha.

Some apps can be disabled.

TameRacingDriver

20,652 posts

303 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
The XR screen is still well over 300 ppi so I doubt you're really going to have any complaints. Too many people get hung up on screen resolution on what is a tiny screen. My iPad Pro is 264 ppi and it looks plenty sharp.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
AJB88 said:
Your not used to updates because Windows has fck all support haha.

This ^

And I think Grandad might be better off reading this - https://www.ageco.co.uk/viewpoint/the-best-mobile-...


TameRacingDriver

20,652 posts

303 months

Thursday 10th January 2019
quotequote all
AJB88 said:
mygoldfishbowl said:
After nearly five years on a windows phone I've recently had the misfortune of using an android phone over the last couple of months. It drove me nuts with constant updating, almost every day it wanted to update this or update that. Not only what some people would describe as bloatware either, google, play store, play music, play something else, but the one that annoyed me the most was youtube. I didn't want it, I never used it but couldn't remove it, yet it updates regularly. If you don't allow the updates they just keep coming back and haunting you for ever, "there are 11 updates for your phone" or 12 or 20, and again, some things that I never used and didn't want.

In the end I turned the data and wifi off and am currently trying to go back to a five years old windows phone.
Your not used to updates because Windows has fck all support haha.

Some apps can be disabled.
hehe indeed. Ironically, completely the opposite of full fat Windows 10 which likes to do updates when you’re in the middle of doing some work!

As for Android app updates, may be an unpopular opinion and each to their own but I’m sure mine is set to do everything automatically anyway; I am rarely bothered by it, in any event.