iphone XR or XS ?
Author
Discussion

housen

Original Poster:

2,366 posts

223 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
hi i broke my samsung s9

and ive been useing my iphone 5 instead

i really like being back on apple


but i dont really wanna spend 1k+ on xs so was looking at xr


but will i feel short changed if i dont get the xs over the xr ?

hope you can help


thx

robsa

2,472 posts

215 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
Probably not, but depends on how much you care for bleeding-edge screen tech and camera basically. The XR screen is absolutely fine, and for most people, they wouldn't even notice a difference until sat side-to-side with the XS. The camera doesn't has the zoom lens, again, depends on how much you care about that. On the plus side, it has excellent battery life.

Go into a shop and pick one up - they are really nice.

housen

Original Poster:

2,366 posts

223 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
robsa said:
Probably not, but depends on how much you care for bleeding-edge screen tech and camera basically. The XR screen is absolutely fine, and for most people, they wouldn't even notice a difference until sat side-to-side with the XS. The camera doesn't has the zoom lens, again, depends on how much you care about that. On the plus side, it has excellent battery life.

Go into a shop and pick one up - they are really nice.
yeah hearing u .....the onllyy thing im thinking of is the 3d touch ....which ive never experienced but looks really cool


on the flip side ....X vs XR ? closer to price has all features of xs ....but no a12 processor ....im think a12 to future proof going fwd

robsa

2,472 posts

215 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
3D touch is going on all iPhones apparently. It still has an alternative to it on the lock screen and action centre or whatever its called. It's really no big deal whatsoever,

If you prefer the X, and it's the same price, get one. Believe me, the processor in it will be good to go for a long time. Battery not as good, but it's still a brilliant phone (I got one when it first came out). Battery is a big deal for me, so I would choose the XR personally, but it's all about what you care about.

housen

Original Poster:

2,366 posts

223 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
robsa said:
3D touch is going on all iPhones apparently. It still has an alternative to it on the lock screen and action centre or whatever its called. It's really no big deal whatsoever,

If you prefer the X, and it's the same price, get one. Believe me, the processor in it will be good to go for a long time. Battery not as good, but it's still a brilliant phone (I got one when it first came out). Battery is a big deal for me, so I would choose the XR personally, but it's all about what you care about.
yeah think ill go xr


i cant be paying 1500 chf over 880 chf here in switzerland ...i want the 128gb storage too

robsa

2,472 posts

215 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
More colour choice too!

Philplop

378 posts

205 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
I was debating the same. Main thing I wanted was a better camera over my current iPhone 6.

XS and XR have exactly the same primary camera, the XR just lacks the telephoto zoom lens.
XR has a bigger screen.
XR has 25% better battery life.

Oh. And it’s a million pounds cheaper.

A white 64GB XR should be getting delivered to me today. 😊

alorotom

12,792 posts

218 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
I have an XS Max (and from an X), my wife has the XR and honeslty, I wish I went the XR route, its everybit as good a phone in all day to day uses and the camera/battery differences are negliglbe IMO

housen

Original Poster:

2,366 posts

223 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
alorotom said:
I have an XS Max (and from an X), my wife has the XR and honeslty, I wish I went the XR route, its everybit as good a phone in all day to day uses and the camera/battery differences are negliglbe IMO
real world review thank you


yeah i cant be paying 1500 of world currency on a phone

imagine the mother of all tvs you could buy with that

housen

Original Poster:

2,366 posts

223 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
on another note


the samsung s9 i had really didn't click with me


the whole experience just felt un finished and there were a few things that just annoyed me and didnt make sense .....hence my return to apple

coldel

11,403 posts

177 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
I am having the same debate at the moment, negotiated some deals with the main operators - the XR is a couple of hundred quid cheaper over the term of the contract. Another thing on the camera is that the XS takes better portrait photos - I have to say I love this feature on my iPhone 7 Plus and having a 7 year old capturing photos in portrait mode of him growing up is fantastic.

EdR

98 posts

238 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
For what is worth, I just went through this dilemma - having had a series of the Plus phones, I personally wanted a larger (more precisely, wider) screen than the X, so was interested when XS Max came out. In the meantime, my wife got a XS and my son got a XR, so gave me plenty of time to compare the technology in them, including display quality (albeit not the same size as a XS Max) and photos.

My conclusion was that side by side, I would just give the edge to the XS screen, but it really is only being very critical that I would observe any difference, however when factoring price, I just could not justify paying the extra for a XS Max over the XR. This was particularly the case for me, since given the price of the XS Max, I would have bought Apple Care, but for the XR was willing to accept having to write it off if I do something stupid. I wanted more than 64GB, so the 128GB XR was £800, and I would have paid £1450 for the 256GB XS Max (appreciate this is not completely an apples-to-apples comparison, but was the relevant scenario for me) - figured for nearly twice the price, the XS Max did not offer enough extra.

I bought the XR nearly 2 months ago and am very happy with it - battery life is great, photo quality really nice (and I am fussy on this kind of thing!), screen size and format works very well for me, and I have never thought that the display looked below par in any way whilst owning it.

gregs656

12,433 posts

212 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
Another option is the X - which seems to me to be slightly better than the XR and a lot less money than the XS.

The XR is a really nice phone though, and the battery life is excellent - woman in my office who uses her phone decent amount gets 2 days out of it.

I'm going to hunt for an X next month.

pokethepope

2,667 posts

219 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
With the Halide app the XR gets very close to the XS for portrait photos (both people and objects), that was the only real consideration for me between the two, ended up getting the XR once i'd tried Halide on a friends XR.

coldel

11,403 posts

177 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
Just on the online chat as we speak battering VF down on price for an XS wink Loyal customer and all that ...!

nikaiyo2

5,980 posts

226 months

Tuesday 26th February 2019
quotequote all
I could not really tell the difference between the screen on the XR vs the XS. I played with them in the Apple store, so maybe not ideal conditions but the differences were so small. It was not a case of one was crap the other great.

The thing that sold me on the XR was battery life, it’s brilliant if I am in the office, so not surfing on the train etc it will last 3 or 4 days between charges!!!

Blown2CV

31,662 posts

234 months

Wednesday 27th February 2019
quotequote all
XS Max has better battery life than the XS, doesn't it?

coldel

11,403 posts

177 months

Wednesday 27th February 2019
quotequote all
Would imagine bigger phones carry bigger batteries?

Got my XS yesterday, took two visits to the website and three different agents including being passed to the retentions team and saved a fair few hundred quid so happy days. Phone arrives today.

Over over under steer

810 posts

154 months

Wednesday 27th February 2019
quotequote all
I had the same dilemma you are having - I chose the XR

- Better battery
- Bigger screen than XS
- Cheaper
- Fun colours

Screen is brilliant, thought sure not as good as my partner's XS if side by side, Camera is amazing, and I can't tell any difference between ours.

For me it's a no brainer

housen

Original Poster:

2,366 posts

223 months

Wednesday 27th February 2019
quotequote all
Over over under steer said:
I had the same dilemma you are having - I chose the XR

- Better battery
- Bigger screen than XS
- Cheaper
- Fun colours

Screen is brilliant, thought sure not as good as my partner's XS if side by side, Camera is amazing, and I can't tell any difference between ours.

For me it's a no brainer
cool thank u


gonna buy xr today