Replacement Smartphone needed not too big
Replacement Smartphone needed not too big
Author
Discussion

cliffords

Original Poster:

3,414 posts

44 months

Friday 12th September 2025
quotequote all
I am not a phone expert and I don't want to spend more than £150 . I use calls and WhatsApp. Take very few pictures , google things in the pub to settle arguments and will look in my Bank from time to time on the mobile . I am not a heavy user .

My current phone is a Pixel 4a used from Backmarket about 4 years ago . Its absolutely fine but is now not holding a charge . Battery depletes over just a few hours or so . It was fab when I got it .

My biggest issue is I want it in my pocket comfortably . All phones now seem like tablets to me .
The 4a is 144mm tall and that big enough.

May I ask for suggestions please what to buy and where from . No contract needed I just us my Tesco sim card.

Thanks

guyvert1

2,145 posts

263 months

Friday 12th September 2025
quotequote all
Depends if you want new or refurb, here's an idea https://www.giffgaff.com/mobile-phones/refurbished...

cliffords

Original Poster:

3,414 posts

44 months

Friday 12th September 2025
quotequote all
guyvert1 said:
Depends if you want new or refurb, here's an idea https://www.giffgaff.com/mobile-phones/refurbished...
Thank you ,I did look here but you cant actually buy outright , even though it says you can . You have to buy a minimum £10 package .

Thanks for the suggestion though.

QuartzDad

2,738 posts

143 months

Friday 12th September 2025
quotequote all
Pixel 5 is 145mm tall, not much else is that small.

There is one on Amazon for £138.

OutInTheShed

12,761 posts

47 months

Friday 12th September 2025
quotequote all
You could get a new battery fitted?

Or you could buy something like a refurbed iPhone SE with a new battery fitted for that kind of money.

Personally, I'd like a phone that size with a decent battery life when running GPS apps.

C69

1,035 posts

33 months

Friday 12th September 2025
quotequote all
Google was running a free battery replacement scheme for the Pixel 4a earlier this year because of charging / capacity issues.

Maybe your phone wasn't eligible, and the scheme could've already closed, but it might be worth checking: https://support.google.com/pixelphone/workflow/156...

the-norseman

14,964 posts

192 months

Saturday 13th September 2025
quotequote all
As above see if yours is eligible for the battery replacement.

As you have a Pixel, if you want to replace it just get a newer Pixel. I'd personally spend a little more to get a Pixel that is going to get a few years of OS and security updates, especially as you mention you do use banking apps.

nvubu

896 posts

150 months

Saturday 13th September 2025
quotequote all
For a new phone - I bought at Motorola Edge Neo 50 for £199 direct from Motorola - 5 years of upgrades. 6.4" - which was bigger than my Asus Zenfone 8 (5.9"), but it is fine size wise. Would prefer smaller, but for the price I thought it was a bargin.

Griffith4ever

6,199 posts

56 months

Sunday 14th September 2025
quotequote all
nvubu said:
For a new phone - I bought at Motorola Edge Neo 50 for £199 direct from Motorola - 5 years of upgrades. 6.4" - which was bigger than my Asus Zenfone 8 (5.9"), but it is fine size wise. Would prefer smaller, but for the price I thought it was a bargin.
Likewise. It's a great phone, great value, and small - compared to most other phones! I don't even case mine,

Doggleg

599 posts

187 months

Sunday 14th September 2025
quotequote all
Unihertz Atom.

Jamescrs

5,754 posts

86 months

Sunday 14th September 2025
quotequote all
cliffords said:
Thank you ,I did look here but you cant actually buy outright , even though it says you can . You have to buy a minimum £10 package .

Thanks for the suggestion though.
With GiffGaff it's almost a Pay as you go type deal so you can cancel at any time, even if you took the £10 package you can just cancel it straight away, effectively it just adds £10 to the cost to purchase if you look at it that way, just don't choose the 18 month contract

bigmowley

2,452 posts

197 months

Sunday 14th September 2025
quotequote all
I use a Samsung Galaxy XCover 5. It’s small, an old design but still new enough to be updated, and got a battery that will start my car. I have it because I also hate massive phones, and working in construction I need a rugged water resistant phone. They started off in price well above your budget but as they become more ancient, in phone terms, they are getting steadily cheaper. I paid about £200 for my current one last year. I bet you can get them for under that now.

Alorotom

12,655 posts

208 months

Sunday 14th September 2025
quotequote all
bigmowley said:
I use a Samsung Galaxy XCover 5. It s small, an old design but still new enough to be updated, and got a battery that will start my car. I have it because I also hate massive phones, and working in construction I need a rugged water resistant phone. They started off in price well above your budget but as they become more ancient, in phone terms, they are getting steadily cheaper. I paid about £200 for my current one last year. I bet you can get them for under that now.
They are well under £100 now - some can be found for under £50. Its end of life though really (hence the cheap price)

the-photographer

4,170 posts

197 months

Sunday 14th September 2025
quotequote all
Slightly over your budget would be the S22 at 146 mm

sgrimshaw

7,566 posts

271 months

Sunday 14th September 2025
quotequote all
If 153mm would be acceptable, then the Sony Xperia 10 IV is worth a look.

Amazing battery life, OLED screen, decent camera, 5G, dual SIM

cliffords

Original Poster:

3,414 posts

44 months

Friday 19th September 2025
quotequote all
Just to complete the thread , and thank you to those who contributed .
I bought a Motorola Edge Neo 50 direct from Motorola.

I thought it was a bit big when it arrived but a few days in and it seems normal size again. Its a great phone does everything I want with my modest needs and a few years of updates and a big battery .

Wife wants to order one now smile

Edited to add I paid £225 last week , Ordered today for wife again direct with Motorola and it was £149 ! colour dependant .
Fantastic value .

Edited by cliffords on Friday 19th September 10:53

nvubu

896 posts

150 months

Friday 19th September 2025
quotequote all
cliffords said:
Just to complete the thread , and thank you to those who contributed .
I bought a Motorola Edge Neo 50 direct from Motorola.

I thought it was a bit big when it arrived but a few days in and it seems normal size again. Its a great phone does everything I want with my modest needs and a few years of updates and a big battery .

Wife wants to order one now smile

Edited to add I paid £225 last week , Ordered today for wife again direct with Motorola and it was £149 ! colour dependant .
Fantastic value .
Yes, couldn't agree more.

I'm tempted to get another one at £149 for my daughter in the USA who keeps trashing her Pixel frown

ambuletz

11,495 posts

202 months

Friday 19th September 2025
quotequote all
If you fancy tinkering you might aswell keep the pixel. There is bound to be a teardown video somewhere on how to replace the battery.

Get yourself a phone repair kit and look up how to do it. At the very least you could use the phone as a backup.

nvubu

896 posts

150 months

Saturday 20th September 2025
quotequote all
Just noticed the Edge 60 Neo is coming this month GSM reckons 400 EUR. Looks to be a very similar spec, but a 5200 mAh battery - which is a large increase on the 50 - and and 12Gb RAM.

There's only the Latte left at £149 on the Motorola site.

Edited by nvubu on Saturday 20th September 17:31

SydneyBridge

10,793 posts

179 months

Saturday 20th September 2025
quotequote all
I just got a Motorola G24 from Argos for £90. 16cm tall and really pleaed with it, sim free so I just put my old sim in and transferred everything from my old phone