Facebook Groups - Anonymous Post Reply not possible
Facebook Groups - Anonymous Post Reply not possible
Author
Discussion

P1Fanatic

Original Poster:

1,953 posts

44 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
I think of myself as tech savvy but I am scratching my head on this one and its annoying due to restricting my participation in a particular FB group.

Scenario: I belong to a particular Private FB group doing some research for my father regarding a timeshare contract. Due to the nature of the group the majority of members post anonymously. I can also post anonymously no issues. However I can't reply anonymously to other people's posts even though many other members can and do.

It's the same issue no matter if I use Facebook via Chrome Browser on a Win11 PC or an iPhone / iPad using the app (or using Safari). So would appear to be account related. FB is not much help as suggests that Posting and Commenting are based on the same privelege, therefore if one works (Posting) then the other (commenting) should also work. However it does not seem to distinguish between commenting on your own post (which does work) vs commenting on another group members post (which does not work):

https://www.facebook.com/help/832270967369626



Anyone else come across this and ever found a way to get it working?

droopsnoot

14,801 posts

273 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
I also don't seem to be able to reply anonymously. Posting anonymously in groups tends to be governed by the group settings, and I can't say I've ever tried that, but I have sometimes wanted to reply to an anonymous or pseudonym post without my identity being obvious and can't see how.

vaud

60,047 posts

186 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
For groups I think it depends on the group settings by the admin.. not all allow anonymous posts.

P1Fanatic

Original Poster:

1,953 posts

44 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
vaud said:
For groups I think it depends on the group settings by the admin.. not all allow anonymous posts.
It does but its definetly enabled at group level as A) I can post anon B) many others can reply anon to other peoples posts.

P1Fanatic

Original Poster:

1,953 posts

44 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
droopsnoot said:
I also don't seem to be able to reply anonymously. Posting anonymously in groups tends to be governed by the group settings, and I can't say I've ever tried that, but I have sometimes wanted to reply to an anonymous or pseudonym post without my identity being obvious and can't see how.
Yes it has to be enabled but Group Admins confirmed it is and clearly they have. The more I read up it seems to be random if Meta enable it for a particular user - but then half of it works for me (posting my own new thread and replying to that). But I seem to be in the minority as the majority of users in my group use it no issues. I even posted about this issue and no one else has this issue.