Which Wireless Router is best? (Easy set up a must!)
Which Wireless Router is best? (Easy set up a must!)
Author
Discussion

kippax

Original Poster:

2,792 posts

279 months

Monday 31st October 2005
quotequote all
As per title I am about to buy a wireless router & want to know which one is best to go for.
On my previous post asking if I could do wireless with NTL Broadband there were a couple of suggestions 1 of which was called Buffalo which sets up secure connection automatically do any others do this? Finally how much should I expect to pay for one of these & best place to buy.
My new Dell laptop is due to arrive today so I want to set up wireless network for this while keeping wired up desktop.

Thanks Again
Howard.

shadytree

8,291 posts

279 months

Monday 31st October 2005
quotequote all
I set myself up a wireless network last week.

Lynksys WRT54G

Set-up is quite straight forward.

or if you want to transfer larger files between machines go for the 108mbs WRT54GS. (no faster for internet though)

A friend has a NETGEAR router and he said the setup was a nightmare.





>> Edited by shadytree on Monday 31st October 15:40

Plotloss

67,280 posts

300 months

Monday 31st October 2005
quotequote all
Netgear DG834GT

puggit

49,820 posts

278 months

Monday 31st October 2005
quotequote all
shadytree said:
I set myself up a wireless network last week.

Lynksys WRT54G

Set-up is quite straight forward.

or if you want to transfer larger files between machines go for the 108mbs WRT54GS. (no faster for internet though)

A friend has a NETGEAR router and he said the setup was a nightmare.





>> Edited by shadytree on Monday 31st October 15:40
Ditto

bga

8,134 posts

281 months

Monday 31st October 2005
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
Netgear DG834GT


piece of cake to set up!

pmanson

13,388 posts

283 months

Monday 31st October 2005
quotequote all
puggit said:

shadytree said:
I set myself up a wireless network last week.

Lynksys WRT54G

Set-up is quite straight forward.

or if you want to transfer larger files between machines go for the 108mbs WRT54GS. (no faster for internet though)

A friend has a NETGEAR router and he said the setup was a nightmare.





>> Edited by shadytree on Monday 31st October 15:40

Ditto



thirded.

FunkyGibbon

3,863 posts

294 months

Monday 31st October 2005
quotequote all
pmanson said:

puggit said:


shadytree said:
I set myself up a wireless network last week.

Lynksys WRT54G

Set-up is quite straight forward.

or if you want to transfer larger files between machines go for the 108mbs WRT54GS. (no faster for internet though)

A friend has a NETGEAR router and he said the setup was a nightmare.





>> Edited by shadytree on Monday 31st October 15:40


Ditto




thirded.


quartered

BliarOut

72,863 posts

269 months

Monday 31st October 2005
quotequote all
bga said:

Plotloss said:
Netgear DG834GT



piece of cake to set up!

Thirded

Podie

46,649 posts

305 months

Monday 31st October 2005
quotequote all
BliarOut said:

bga said:


Plotloss said:
Netgear DG834GT




piece of cake to set up!


Thirded


Fourthed..!

(although the BT ones are pretty easy too)

shadytree

8,291 posts

279 months

Monday 31st October 2005
quotequote all
Everyone seems to be going wireless mad at the moment. Must have seen at least 10 people in PCW buying routers!

puggit

49,820 posts

278 months

Monday 31st October 2005
quotequote all
shadytree said:
Everyone seems to be going wireless mad at the moment. Must have seen at least 10 people in PCW buying routers!
More fool them!

richb

56,377 posts

314 months

Monday 31st October 2005
quotequote all
puggit said:

shadytree said:
Everyone seems to be going wireless mad at the moment. Must have seen at least 10 people in PCW buying routers!

More fool them!

malman

2,258 posts

289 months

Monday 31st October 2005
quotequote all


Is your NTL connection ADSL or ethernet cable modem (I know telewest will supply ADSL as well as cable, not sure about NTL)? If its ethernet then the DG834GT won't work as it an ADSL router. The linksys wrt54g is an ethernet to ethernet router. A guy at work here has the linksys on his telewest connection without problems. Netgear do an ethernet to ethernet router but I can't remember the model code off hand

Both are easy to setup

>> Edited by malman on Monday 31st October 18:06

rico

7,917 posts

285 months

Monday 31st October 2005
quotequote all
Don't go for 3COM. Fecking nightmare!

Netgear are awesome... why oh why didn't I go for one?

edit - btw. i never read manuals so it might be simple, but the normal 'try until it works' ethos didn't work for me this time!

>> Edited by rico on Monday 31st October 19:08

_dan_

2,392 posts

309 months

Monday 31st October 2005
quotequote all
Podie said:

BliarOut said:


bga said:



Plotloss said:
Netgear DG834GT





piece of cake to set up!



Thirded



Fourthed..!

(although the BT ones are pretty easy too)


Fifthed!!

Had mine 6 months with no problems what-so-ever. Easy to set up and yet has many more advanded features should you need them. Wireless is good too.

munky

5,328 posts

278 months

Tuesday 1st November 2005
quotequote all
Belkin - I've been wireless with a Belkin ADSL modem/router for 2 years now and it has always worked perfectly. In recent times I only use the wireless router part, not the ADSL part. It's connected now, at 54Mbps.

Netgear - my brother has one, says it's great

3com - my dad has one, however it has an annoying "feature". Every time you switch it on, you must go into the setup screen in order to switch on the internet (ADSL) connection. The Belkin and Netgear ones connect automatically.

No experience of Linksys

Edited to add - if moving large files between PCs is an issue, you could always wait for 802.11n which has better range, and speeds of up to 540Mbps, 10 times faster than 802.11g

Or there's 802.11a which doesn't suffer from interference from microwave ovens, cordless phones or bluetooth.

Question - how does one monitor actual throughput? i.e. the adaptor may say that the speed is 54.0 Mbps, but where can one see what actual rate is being achieved?

>> Edited by munky on Tuesday 1st November 07:18

aldi

9,288 posts

267 months

Tuesday 1st November 2005
quotequote all
In XP you can right click on the taskbar, choose Task Manager, then Networking. That gives you a graph of throughput as a %age of max.

spivvy

1,535 posts

284 months

Tuesday 1st November 2005
quotequote all
this product seems reasonable and a very good price from misco's £32.89 incl VAT

DYNAMODE 11G/54MBPS DSL/CABLE RTR/SWITCH/FIREWALL


The BR6004W-G is an IEEE 802.11g compliant wireless router with a built in four-port fast Ethernet switch. The BR6004W-G is designed for SOHO users to cost-effectively share a DSL or cable modem, providing Internet access to all your LAN/WLAN users. The integrated 802.11g Wireless Access Point allows wireless users simple and flexible access to all LAN or Internet resources by your wireless users. The BR6004W-G provides not only the ease of Internet access, but also the privacy of data transmission. Network Address Translation (NAT) provides your network with protection from intruders, while 64 and 128-bit WEP (Wired Equivalent Privacy) encryption guard your wireless network for maximum privacy. Additional security features include pass-through of multiple concurrent IPSec and PPTP VPN sessions for telecommuters or for anyone who needs to transmit sensitive information more securely.

or this one even cheaper


Dynamode Cable Router+4Port Switch+Firewall (NTL/Telewest)

Item not in stock

Manufacturer Code BR6004

£17.69 Ex VAT
£20.79 Inc VAT

from www.scan.co.uk



>> Edited by spivvy on Tuesday 1st November 09:22

kippax

Original Poster:

2,792 posts

279 months

Tuesday 1st November 2005
quotequote all
[quote=shadytree]I set myself up a wireless network last week.

Lynksys WRT54G

Set-up is quite straight forward.

or if you want to transfer larger files between machines go for the 108mbs WRT54GS. (no faster for internet though)

A friend has a NETGEAR router and he said the setup was a nightmare.

Thanks for advise I have ordered one of these from Amazon £42 incl delivery although my new laptop arrived today & I have been on wireless broadband ever since so maybe wasted my money (wonder which neighbour it belongs to??)

Howard.





likesbikes

1,439 posts

266 months

Tuesday 1st November 2005
quotequote all