mouse choice - optical or laser mx518/610 ?
mouse choice - optical or laser mx518/610 ?
Author
Discussion

rameshuk

Original Poster:

595 posts

292 months

Saturday 17th December 2005
quotequote all
Hi all,


I need a new mouse for general use+photoshop editing & the occasional quake session.

Should I go for an optical or laser one ?

Currently looking at the Logitech MX518 or MX610

thanks for any advice.

medusa

301 posts

257 months

Saturday 17th December 2005
quotequote all
What is a laser mouse? I have used the ball type, currently using optical, have been thinking of getting a graphics pad & using the pen that comes with it for most mouse operations.

rameshuk

Original Poster:

595 posts

292 months

Saturday 17th December 2005
quotequote all
the ball type would wear down and needs a good mouse mat to work.

Optical mice are much better as they work on a good flat service and have provide more tracking info.

Lasers are the newest type which capture more data.

**An analogy**
Imagine dipping your hand in a tray of paint and then doing a hand print onto a sheet of paper. The optical print would show the general outline of the hand.
The laser print would show much more detail including your finger prints !
Also the new generation of laser mice have no 'lag'. When you pick up the mouse and re center it, the pointer moves immediately. older mice had an annoying lag which could spell the end of your character in a game.

[k]ar|

963 posts

276 months

Saturday 17th December 2005
quotequote all
The latest and greatest laser mice are the Logitech G5/G7, the MS Intellimouse laser mouse 6000, and the Razer Copperhead.

I have a selection of computer rodents - a MS Intellimouse Explorer (optical), Logitech MX510 (optical), Logitech MX1000 (laser cordless) and Logitech G5 (laser).

TBH, any of them will be fine for your purposes, save that the MX1000 has been reported to have some issues with lag when gaming, although I personally have not noticed this using this on my laptop.

My main consideration is gaming, and I can heartily recommend the G5 over all the others. The only issues are that it will not work with all mouse mats unless you install a firmware upgrade (like the Icemat glass mouse pad), and there is only one thumb button for "back" (the earlier versions also had a "forward" thumb button). However, it is incredibly accurate, has on-the-fly resolution switching, adjustable weight system and tilt wheel.

[k]

aldi

9,288 posts

267 months

Sunday 18th December 2005
quotequote all
Have used the logitech laser mice, they're very good! Havent tried gaming with them though. It depends how hardcore you are but I know people who have an old ball mouse on standby for serious gaming (more predictable response apparently)

rameshuk

Original Poster:

595 posts

292 months

Monday 19th December 2005
quotequote all
[quote=[k]ar|]The latest and greatest laser mice are the Logitech G5/G7, the MS Intellimouse laser mouse 6000, and the Razer Copperhead.

I have a selection of computer rodents - a MS Intellimouse Explorer (optical), Logitech MX510 (optical), Logitech MX1000 (laser cordless) and Logitech G5 (laser).

TBH, any of them will be fine for your purposes, save that the MX1000 has been reported to have some issues with lag when gaming, although I personally have not noticed this using this on my laptop.

My main consideration is gaming, and I can heartily recommend the G5 over all the others. The only issues are that it will not work with all mouse mats unless you install a firmware upgrade (like the Icemat glass mouse pad), and there is only one thumb button for "back" (the earlier versions also had a "forward" thumb button). However, it is incredibly accurate, has on-the-fly resolution switching, adjustable weight system and tilt wheel.

[k]

Thats quite a collection !

Thanks for the info. Will try them out in a store before purchasing.

[/quote]

polus

4,343 posts

255 months

Monday 19th December 2005
quotequote all
I have a couple of MX1000's at home and an Intelli Explorer Bluetooth at work.

I much prefer the MX1000 but when I siwtched to wireless I realised the extra weight but its not so much of an issue. I have noticed no lag using games. Becareful with the surefaces as on the wooden desk my laser mouse is somewhat irratic.

The bluetooth intelli mouse has sooooo much lag its not worth considering. TBH for the price of the MX1000 id be tempted to go back to wired mice (the MX510).

>> Edited by polus on Monday 19th December 23:09

Yrv 130 turbo

279 posts

266 months

Wednesday 21st December 2005
quotequote all
I have mx518 with evergide gaming pad and it is very good ,for all games it is smooth and fast it really gives you an edge in BF2,call if duty 2,and FEAR