"Government to tax Second Life money"
"Government to tax Second Life money"
Author
Discussion

chris watton

Original Poster:

22,552 posts

291 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
Is this a wind up?
Taken from the PCAdvisor site;

http://www.pcadvisor.co.uk/blogs/index.cfm?entryid...

"June 11, 2007

People who control avatars of themselves and float around in the popular virtual world of Second Life could find themselves on the wrong end of a tax demand that will leave them wanting to flee their first life.

Yes, even fictional profits in games are taxable, and the dark lords of the Inland Revenue are logging in to catch you.

If profits from online games such as Second Life enter the real world in the form of special deals or discounts you are advised to seek advice from the taxman pronto.

The same goes for people who sell goods on online auction sites such as eBay and re-sale affiliates such as Amazon. Read more here.

Second Life has a fully integrated economy built to "reward risk, innovation, and craftsmanship", according to creators Linden Research.

Second Life "residents" can create their own virtual goods and services. Because residents retain the IP rights of their creations, they are able to sell them at various in-world venues.

Players who have amassed lots of Linden Dollars are matched with residents who want to buy Linden Dollars at LindeX (the official Linden Dollar exchange), or at other unaffiliated third-party exchanges.

Second Life's real estate market provides opportunities for Residents to establish their own communities and business locations.

HM Revenue & Customs is running a kind of amnesty for people who haven't yet paid all taxes owing from self-employment, off-shore accounts, internet trading and buy-to-let rentals.

Declare your profits now and you should avoid paying up to 100% penalties on top of the monies owed. 10% penalties will still be payable for profits over £2,500.

The amnesty runs out on June 22. "

yikes


shadowninja

80,183 posts

313 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
In other news today, Labour government considers asking all new parents to hand over their first born.

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
No it's not a wind up.

a MMORPG appearing is a little odd, but Second Life is, apparently, quite different from the others. It's currency is transferable to GBP and back again, so it's quite possible with some work to make money building/designing things in the game.

The rest of the article is about people making money from ebay and the like in effect being self-employed and needing to pay tax like everyone else.

Fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
I do actually agree with this.

If a student buys in bulk a huge number of watches, sells them on ebay making a tenner per watch, why shouldn't he have to file a tax return, and if he makes more than his annual allowance, why shouldn't he have to pay tax on the income?

Its no different to someone running their own buisness as an individual online shop, or god forbid, and actual bricks and mortar shop..

shadowninja

80,183 posts

313 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
No, I didn't mean it was a wind up. Just that you can't do anything freely these days. Yes, it is a form of income. What about for MMORPGs where people buy equipment with real money and receive it in the game?

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
shadowninja said:
No, I didn't mean it was a wind up. Just that you can't do anything freely these days. Yes, it is a form of income. What about for MMORPGs where people buy equipment with real money and receive it in the game?
That's a one way transaction, you're not making money from it. Now if you were handling the other side of the transaction (i.e. flogging MMORPG stuff on fleabay) then you'd need to do your tax returns like everyone else.

HM C&E really do not give a rats arse about the legalities of something, they'll happily VAT register a brothel (and yes they will enter it as a brothel) they just want your tax return.

JonRB

80,226 posts

303 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
This is a bit of a non-story really.

If you make money from whatever source then you pay tax on it according to its class (capital gain, income, whatever).

The moment Linden Dollars are converted into Sterling then they become real money that's taxable income, surely?. Same goes for the profits of selling stuff on eBay.

Just what is the problem here? confused

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
JonRB said:
Just what is the problem here? confused
I think it's just a 'WTF? Tax on my ebay?" thing, people haven't considered the tax implications of using ebay/MMORPG's to make money (and in some cases a decent living) and it's caught a few people by surprise.

Combine that with the media's general stance to overplay things and bingo.

All of this only kicks in if you're making £2,500 or more per year from ebay and such, but it'd also kick in if you're making that much from anything else.

JonRB

80,226 posts

303 months

Thursday 14th June 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
All of this only kicks in if you're making £2,500 or more per year from ebay and such, but it'd also kick in if you're making that much from anything else.
Indeed. People just don't seem to make the connection that the IR don't care how you make your money - be it employment, self-employment, stocks & shares, gambling, selling stuff on eBay, or creating real money out of virtual money on a MMORPG. It's all money coming into your pocket and they want their slice of it.

Edited by JonRB on Thursday 14th June 18:42

Fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
JonRB said:
Just what is the problem here? confused
I think it's just a 'WTF? Tax on my ebay?" thing, people haven't considered the tax implications of using ebay/MMORPG's to make money (and in some cases a decent living) and it's caught a few people by surprise.

Combine that with the media's general stance to overplay things and bingo.

All of this only kicks in if you're making £2,500 or more per year from ebay and such, but it'd also kick in if you're making that much from anything else.
ah yes, perhaps they think because its the internet it doesnt count! hehe

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
Fidgits said:
ah yes, perhaps they think because its the internet it doesnt count! hehe
Sums it up nicely Fidgits. smile

chris watton

Original Poster:

22,552 posts

291 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
Ahh, I see, it's 'real money' that we're dealing with here, not 'Monopoly' money. I see the sense of the IR getting involved now....

Fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
chris watton said:
Ahh, I see, it's 'real money' that we're dealing with here, not 'Monopoly' money. I see the sense of the IR getting involved now....
Yeah, typical media hype... losing the real story in sensationalism...

The heading should be "People making money through online auctions and transactions will be targetted for not filing tax returns and declaring income"

JonRB

80,226 posts

303 months

Friday 15th June 2007
quotequote all
Fidgits said:
The heading should be "People making money through online auctions and transactions will be targetted for not filing tax returns and declaring income"
yes Indeed. But that would be a non-story, wouldn't it? wink