Vista
Author
Discussion

c c

Original Poster:

8,058 posts

270 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
Please note this is not a question for geeks or mac enthusiasts.

I've jut spent a large chunk of the morning setting up a new laptop that has Vista preinstalled. Somthing that would have taken a half-hour or so with XP.

I'm just wondering if there is anyone who thinks Vista is an improvement over XP and if so why.



Edited by c c on Saturday 16th June 12:33

kiwisr

9,335 posts

238 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
No, not yet.

c c

Original Poster:

8,058 posts

270 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
Wow that got moved quick. So much for not asking geeks.

nick heppinstall

9,108 posts

311 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
Yes but only in the home environment.

sadako

7,080 posts

269 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
There is no reason to go over to it for a business at the moment because Vista doesn't run MS office any better while at the same time having much higher system requirements. Most offices I've done IT work in only recently started using XP for the same reasons.

For a home user most people will just use the OS that comes with their computer whatever it is. The only reason to go over to it at the moment is so you can play a 2 year old X-box game or if you have bleeding edge specs use a 3d desktop eyecandy if you pay extra for the OS. The built in encryption in Ultimate may be of some use to people working on stuff that might be useful to their competition although I doubt the tinfoil hat types would trust it.

kiwisr

9,335 posts

238 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
The vast majority of corporates use the core set of MS Office, Project, Visio etc. Most internal apps these days are web based/portals etc. There is absolutely no reason why they would need to upgrade. It'll happen as part of tech-refreshes when XP support starts expiring, but in general the desktop OS is loosing it's relevance.

sadako

7,080 posts

269 months

Saturday 16th June 2007
quotequote all
Business wise there will probably be a push to go for things like thin clients, yes, but even if that does happen I highly doubt that the executives would want to give up their laptops. Its a status symbol thing.

wolves_wanderer

12,959 posts

268 months

Sunday 17th June 2007
quotequote all
For me it has been a huge improvement over XP. I do a shedload of image editing and Vista copies the contents of a 2gb memory card in around 5 minutes compared to half an hour or so on XP. The way that it handles images is also faster and clearer than XP.

I have had no software problems with it apart from not being able to get a proper driver for my wireless lan card, which is Belkin's fault.

I give it two thumbs up.

nick_bbb

5,520 posts

266 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
I just got a Vista machine at the weekend and after about an hour of swearing while I got used to it, I really like it now. I did splash out on a really good laptop though which I think helps. I will be doing alot of photoshop work with large images so bought machine with two hard drives so I can have the scratch disk seperate.

The interface of Vista seems alot more "grown up" than XP. I like biggrin

Doobs

736 posts

281 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
wolves_wanderer said:
For me it has been a huge improvement over XP. I do a shedload of image editing and Vista copies the contents of a 2gb memory card in around 5 minutes compared to half an hour or so on XP. The way that it handles images is also faster and clearer than XP.

I have had no software problems with it apart from not being able to get a proper driver for my wireless lan card, which is Belkin's fault.

I give it two thumbs up.
I am having the exact same problem with my Belkin wireless card. It's a pain in the ass cos the machine is used on our TV so needs wireless to connect to the office upstairs.

I would stick with XP for my work usage because it currently works so no need to risk changing anything, but for home Vista seems fine (so far).

mcflurry

9,192 posts

284 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
I don't like the way it tries to hide the drive structure.
When you are saving a document it automatically goes to "My documents", and won't as easily go to another directory like c:\somewhere else frown

c c

Original Poster:

8,058 posts

270 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
nick_bbb said:
The interface of Vista seems a lot more "grown up" than XP. I like biggrin
I feel it to be the opposite of grown up. I feel using Vista is like being a kid at school again and given round nosed plastic scissors so that I wont hurt myself.

jamieboy

5,932 posts

260 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
mcflurry said:
I don't like the way it tries to hide the drive structure.
When you are saving a document it automatically goes to "My documents", and won't as easily go to another directory like c:\somewhere else frown
confused Not with you.

It shows the current directory and the immediate parent(s) in the top line of the 'Save As' box, so you can either click on one of them to backtrack or you can click on 'Computer' in the left-hand pane and navigate from there. If there is no left-hand pane, click on 'Browse Folders' to show it.

In this respect it's not wildly different from XP - I'm not sure how much easier they could make it?


Mattt

16,664 posts

249 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
jamieboy said:
mcflurry said:
I don't like the way it tries to hide the drive structure.
When you are saving a document it automatically goes to "My documents", and won't as easily go to another directory like c:\somewhere else frown
confused Not with you.

It shows the current directory and the immediate parent(s) in the top line of the 'Save As' box, so you can either click on one of them to backtrack or you can click on 'Computer' in the left-hand pane and navigate from there. If there is no left-hand pane, click on 'Browse Folders' to show it.

In this respect it's not wildly different from XP - I'm not sure how much easier they could make it?
I think I know what he means - I can't easily find say I: root or C: root, the other day I wanted to find program files and had to type it in manually!

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
c c said:
nick_bbb said:
The interface of Vista seems a lot more "grown up" than XP. I like biggrin
I feel it to be the opposite of grown up. I feel using Vista is like being a kid at school again and given round nosed plastic scissors so that I wont hurt myself.
Must admit, had a play with Vista when doing a parts run to Novatech; it looks good on the glossy 'ultrabrite' screens but. Hmmm. A bit 'happy clappy' in looks, different but the same as XP in that respect.

On inspection I can see a lot of companies either forcing it back to XP or 2K display modes, partly the "You're here to work and this looks like a toy" and partly "Support procedures all have 'Click Start' can't be arsed rewriting all of them".

Is it more tonka toy than XP? No. It's a similar sized tonka smile

jamieboy

5,932 posts

260 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
Mattt said:
jamieboy said:
It shows the current directory and the immediate parent(s) in the top line of the 'Save As' box, so you can either click on one of them to backtrack or you can click on 'Computer' in the left-hand pane and navigate from there. If there is no left-hand pane, click on 'Browse Folders' to show it.

In this respect it's not wildly different from XP - I'm not sure how much easier they could make it?
I think I know what he means - I can't easily find say I: root or C: root, the other day I wanted to find program files and had to type it in manually!
In the 'Save As' dialog, click 'Computer' then double-click C: (or N: or I: or whatever) and there you are in the root of that drive.

Simpo Two

93,096 posts

296 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
wolves_wanderer said:
For me it has been a huge improvement over XP. I do a shedload of image editing and Vista copies the contents of a 2gb memory card in around 5 minutes compared to half an hour or so on XP.
Are you sure that's not a USB1 vs USB2 issue? I run XP with USB2 and it shifts (IIRC) 4Gb in 7 minutes!


Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
We think Vista is completely ace.

It will create a host of incompatibilities and software problems that we can earn money fixing for corporates. Thanks, Bill, your good health, sir.

At work I will shortly have a Vista development environment for our application. At home? It might be a while, yet. wink

neil_bolton

17,113 posts

295 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
I'll echo the Home vs Corporate comments - I've been using for quite some time and I very much like it.

It has lots of things going for it - driver handling is much better and in a home environment its properly thought out when it comes to security.

However I will concede that it takes some adjusting to, and I do still grumble at having to navigate around certain weirdnesses in the system.

At home, I have Ultimate, which really is quite special, and has some great benefits, most notably Shadow Copy Volume services on the local disks - something that is really handy. Add to that, proper Media Centre capabilities, and you have a fantastic device for at home.

Certainly in a corporate environment however, these things (bar the Shadow Copy Volume services) don't equate to a worthy enough reason to spend in licensing to upgrade.

If you have Software Assurance, sure you could upgrade, but then the support and hardware costs will outweigh the return on investment.

However, there is no reason why not either - some of the group policy stuff in Vista is very cool, and the new Management Console that comes as standard is pretty nifty - but not something that you couldn't do with some poking about in XP.

So - Home, at the moment, Yes. At work, not really.

ETA: Ooh, I'd forgotten about the compatibilty problems with software - I've stumbled across it a lot, especially with legacy software. However, most corporates (inc. me) are now moving to Virtualisation, which can be run easily on most Vista machines, and if the software is mission critical you would budget in a spend for the approriat resource to move it across to a VM environment (like our EDI software) - it works very well.

However with regard to stuff like printers, etc etc, well thats just the price you pay for moving to a newer OS - poke the third party software vendor in the eye if it doesn't work - its their fault if they don't appease their customers by testing their software on Vista.

Edited by neil_bolton on Tuesday 19th June 09:46

Mattt

16,664 posts

249 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
jamieboy said:
Mattt said:
jamieboy said:
It shows the current directory and the immediate parent(s) in the top line of the 'Save As' box, so you can either click on one of them to backtrack or you can click on 'Computer' in the left-hand pane and navigate from there. If there is no left-hand pane, click on 'Browse Folders' to show it.

In this respect it's not wildly different from XP - I'm not sure how much easier they could make it?
I think I know what he means - I can't easily find say I: root or C: root, the other day I wanted to find program files and had to type it in manually!
In the 'Save As' dialog, click 'Computer' then double-click C: (or N: or I: or whatever) and there you are in the root of that drive.
#

When I click computer there is no C: or I: or whatever shown there!