Living the Mac dream... or not
Author
Discussion

pikey

Original Poster:

7,704 posts

315 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
We needed a replacement laptop "thing" and with her ladyship being persuaded by the recent ad campaign, went for a MacBook. It's not quite been a week of ownership, but I'm forming some pretty strong opinions already..

I am, in a nutshell, disappointed. It's just not as wonderful as they say - mostly from the bundled software point of view.

The ads imply that it comes with all the software one needs, but reality is that you need a .Mac account (at £90 a year) to make the most of it. If you have your own email / website / picture hosting site / etc... then you don't want a .Mac account.

For example, I want a messenger program that has a webcam feature... great, it has iChat - except you need a .Mac or AIM account so can't use it. But there's an MS version - except that doesn't support the camera. Oh, and there's a Yahoo version that does, but you need a Yahoo account. But wait - what about the aMSN freeware thing? Doesn't work. Right - she still can't have a webcam chat with her sister in Aus.

The ads say it comes with MS Office - great it does... except that's the trial version.

When I first turned it on out of the box - wouldn't connect to my router with the message "there is an error". Great! Seems they copied that informative message from MS!

It's got web authoring software as part of iLife... but you need a .Mac account to do anything with it.

Someone sends you a WMV video file. Guess what? It can't play it - you have to rely on MS to supply a plugin.

I have a printer - it won't "just connect". The manufacturer doesn't support it.

It should be able to "just bluetooth" to my phone, but it doesn't.

So, what does it do that we like?
- It looks great
- It's fast
- The keyboard is nice to use
- The screen is a decent definition
- The battery lasts for ages
- It's light
- It browses the internet absolutely fine
... but that's about it.

I find that to do the stuff I want to do with it I'm looking for software that's similar to that I'd be running on a PC. This isn't necessarily bad, it's just that the ads imply you can do everything you want straight out of the box and actually... for me it's about the same as if I'd gone the PC route, and going the PC route brings more compatibility.

So far, coming from a PC background I don't "get" a Mac. Still, she wanted it 'cos it looks cute' and she's happy! I'm just trying to restrain myself from installing XP on this very fine piece of hardware for a little while longer! biggrin


ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
pikey said:
The ads imply that it comes with all the software one needs, but reality is that you need a .Mac account (at £90 a year) to make the most of it. If you have your own email / website / picture hosting site / etc... then you don't want a .Mac account.
? Odd. I admit my mac is a much older vintage but none of iLife has ever pestered me about needing a .mac account. It does during OS X's 'configure yourself' bit. I suspect there is an option somewhere to get it to work with a more generic host.

pikey said:
For example, I want a messenger program that has a webcam feature... great, it has iChat - except you need a .Mac or AIM account so can't use it. But there's an MS version - except that doesn't support the camera. Oh, and there's a Yahoo version that does, but you need a Yahoo account. But wait - what about the aMSN freeware thing? Doesn't work. Right - she still can't have a webcam chat with her sister in Aus.
iChat isn't much good. Try pidgin, it's what became of gAIM and is rather good.

pikey said:
The ads say it comes with MS Office - great it does... except that's the trial version.
You really can't fault them for that. Dell, HP, Compaq and the rest do the same. Hell, I've a Microsoft book here and it says "Contains full version of Office 2003" on the front, it's a time limited demo.

pikey said:
When I first turned it on out of the box - wouldn't connect to my router with the message "there is an error". Great! Seems they copied that informative message from MS!
No. Windows would throw up an odd error that contained a hex code or other identifier and expect you to go look it up (which is a neat trick if it won't join your wifi network). I agree, OS X could do with an "I'm not an idiot" button to get it to show it's underbelly. But so could XP.

pikey said:
It's got web authoring software as part of iLife... but you need a .Mac account to do anything with it.
Tinker in it's preferences, I'm sure somewhere in it is an option to just save html/php/whatever to disk and let you upload it manually. It might, annoyingly I admit, call it "Export".

pikey said:
Someone sends you a WMV video file. Guess what? It can't play it - you have to rely on MS to supply a plugin.
Welcome to the world outside Microsoft. Now you know why Linux users bitch so much about "closed proprietary standards". Flip4Mac might work. Alternatively try installing VLC or mplayer + Win32Codecs.

pikey said:
I have a printer - it won't "just connect". The manufacturer doesn't support it.
Complain to the manu', they won't do anything until they know their is a market for OS X support. But google might help you do stuff with it.

pikey said:
It should be able to "just bluetooth" to my phone, but it doesn't.
You have paired them? That's a requirement of BT and Apple can't really work around it... once paired my imac and phone happily shuffle pictures between each other.


The whole "Just Works" thing is subjective. If you buy it, a .mac account, an OS X compatible printer and an ipod... it will 'just work', anything outside of Apple's domain or not 100% compatible... 'may work'.

kiwisr

9,335 posts

238 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
iWeb can publish to a folder.



with these differences

http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=303...

HiRich

3,337 posts

293 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
pikey said:
For example, I want a messenger program that has a webcam feature... great, it has iChat - except you need a .Mac or AIM account so can't use it. But there's an MS version - except that doesn't support the camera. Oh, and there's a Yahoo version that does, but you need a Yahoo account. But wait - what about the aMSN freeware thing? Doesn't work. Right - she still can't have a webcam chat with her sister in Aus.
Dragging this from deep in my memory, so I wonder if someone has done it or can find the reference, but...
I think that if you take the free .Mac trial, your iChat registration continues even after the trial ends/
hello

pikey said:
So far, coming from a PC background I don't "get" a Mac. Still, she wanted it 'cos it looks cute' and she's happy! I'm just trying to restrain myself from installing XP on this very fine piece of hardware for a little while longer! biggrin
If you're not happy, just do it. Then you'll both be happy. In time, as you resolve the problems you might find yourself in the Apple environment more and more.
Oh, and a copy of "Missing Manual For Tiger" might help you out an awful lot. I've recommended this so often I really should just buy a box load and sell them direct.

The Dude

6,546 posts

278 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
pikey said:
most of it. If you have your own email / website / picture hosting site / etc... then you don't want a .Mac account.
....okay

pikey said:
there's an MS version - except that doesn't support the camera. Oh, and there's a Yahoo version that does, but you need a Yahoo account.
Don't see how that's the Mac's fault?

pikey said:
The ads say it comes with MS Office - great it does... except that's the trial version
But MS Office is not free with Windows either? Get NeoOffice. It's free and does everything you want.

pikey said:
When I first turned it on out of the box - wouldn't connect to my router with the message "there is an error". Great! Seems they copied that informative message from MS!
So does it work now? If so, what's the problem?

pikey said:
It's got web authoring software as part of iLife... but you need a .Mac account to do anything with it.
Is there free web authoring on Windows?

pikey said:
Someone sends you a WMV video file. Guess what? It can't play it - you have to rely on MS to supply a plugin.
Well, considering it's a Windows format, what do you expect? At least there's a free plugin to play it. Not sure what your problem is...

pikey said:
I have a printer - it won't "just connect". The manufacturer doesn't support it.
I think I see the problem....

pikey said:
It should be able to "just bluetooth" to my phone, but it doesn't.
I'll give you that one. I waited a year or so before my phone was supported by iSync. However, before that I used a program called Phone Agent (Nokia and Ericsson phones) that more than catered for my needs.

pikey said:
installing XP on this very fine piece of hardware
No need but get Parallels and install it if you really need to.

I think overall you're just suffering teething trouble. Before Macs I used PCs for over 15 years. Now I'd never go back. There's just no need to as far as I'm concerned and I use my Macs to do a very wide range of tasks.

Stick with it and do a bit more research. Just 'cos the ads say you'll get everything on a plate, doesn't necessarily mean it's absolutely true. That's ads for you.

smile

Buffalo

5,488 posts

285 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
I downloaded a "flip4mac" plug in from the apple webpage downloads section to sort out the .wmv files thing. Never had a drama since.

As soon as you hook it to the internet, get the software updated and go searching on the apple downloads page for other useful bits. All software auto-updates or updates under "software updates" under the apple menu after that too.

Neo-office is supposed to be very good, but i ended up shelling out for the MS Office full version.

For the video-cam thing, i use skype. You can text and vid-phone using that and no money changes hands...

I don't think Macs are the be-all and end-all either, but i've had mine nearly a year now and i am slowly coming around to it's way of thinking. I do enjoy using it far more than my works' MS machine.

Most options are much easier to use than the windows system eventually. Why eventually? Well, the trouble i have found (and i have mentioned this before) is that it is not always very easy to find out how the mac does it, the first time you need to use it - it has its own way of doings things quite often different from MS/windows. This is evident from the sheer number of posts here from new users (myself included) asking "how do i...?" One re-assuring thing though, is that once i have worked something out on the Mac, i find it very much easier than windows to do the same task again and again. That is why i like my choice of an MBP, over any MS/Windows machine that i could have bought.

pikey

Original Poster:

7,704 posts

315 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
Guys - don't get me wrong. I'm not sticking up for the PC chap in the suit on the adverts, I'm just putting a point of view across that Macs are not as wonderful as some say.

Yes, if you buy a PC it does not come ready to go from opening the box, and you can expect any software on it to be trial versions but the situation on a Mac isn't really that much different.

pikey

Original Poster:

7,704 posts

315 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
kiwisr said:
iWeb can publish to a folder.

Thanks for that smile

"Publish to folder" - didn't spot that option!

pikey

Original Poster:

7,704 posts

315 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
HiRich said:
pikey said:
it has iChat - except you need a .Mac or AIM account
Dragging this from deep in my memory, so I wonder if someone has done it or can find the reference, but...
I think that if you take the free .Mac trial, your iChat registration continues even after the trial ends/
Ah, but what if I want to be 'ben@<mydomain>.com', like I have been for the last 9 years? I don't want to now be ben@mac.com - particularly not if I'm going to sign in on another machine.

pikey

Original Poster:

7,704 posts

315 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
Buffalo said:
I downloaded a "flip4mac" plug in from the apple webpage downloads section to sort out the .wmv files thing. Never had a drama since.
I got the plug in from Microsoft - worked fine. I was just surprised that it didn't play something as simple as WMV out of the box. I never expected a PC to play MOV out of the box!

Buffalo said:
For the video-cam thing, i use skype. You can text and vid-phone using that and no money changes hands...
but I want to use a basic app that's worked fine for years. Why should so much upheaval be needed?

Buffalo said:
One re-assuring thing though, is that once i have worked something out on the Mac, i find it very much easier than windows to do the same task again and again. That is why i like my choice of an MBP, over any MS/Windows machine that i could have bought.
Interesting.

cjs

11,722 posts

282 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
Pikey, I am with you on this. I have had my Mac for 6 months and am now only just happy I have my head around it. The Mac 'heads' won't hear a bad word said however there is quite a bit of stuff that Windows does better, most of these are small things that are more niggley than important.

All I can say is you will get used to it and learn to appreciate the benefits of a Mac, as you have found it doesn't 'just work' and if you have read the Rich36 'My first Mac Mini' thread on here you will see lots of things don't just work on a Mac either!

I also fell for the MS Office inclusive software 'con' and found out after it was only a trial, same with the i-works software! There again most PC come with the same


Give it a month or so and then come back and let us know what you think, and ask lots of questions on here as there are some real Mac experts lurking.......not me though!

Edited by cjs on Tuesday 19th June 09:11


Edited by cjs on Tuesday 19th June 09:12

Blanc

221 posts

270 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
Pikey

Stick with it. I changed over about 3 years ago after a lifetime of windows. Things are different, it took me about a year before I stopped getting frustrated but now I would never go back to windows.

Just remember once you get it working, it will stay working with none of the annual re-install windows sessions.

Good luck!

Blanc






Rico

7,917 posts

286 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
I made the change 4+ years ago. Never looked back. Hated my last job as I had to use Windows during the day! lol

Takes time to work out what to use instead of the MS products. But you soon realise that doing it the mac way is much more effecient smile

HiRich

3,337 posts

293 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
pikey said:
Guys - don't get me wrong. I'm not sticking up for the PC chap in the suit on the adverts, I'm just putting a point of view across that Macs are not as wonderful as some say.
I think most people understand where you're coming from. I believe Apple have a better track record than MS, but it's still far from perfect. You have been a bit unlucky in your transfer.

Missing Manual would help you out enormously - it has lots of tips and tweaks for both the system and apps. Otherwise, I don't see a problem adding BootCamp and XP - let them fight it out on one machine.

Sorry, I can't take you any further on the iChat problem as I don't use it. It's bad enough having to talk with you all on a forum, I sure don't want to see your ugly mugs as well!

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
pikey said:
Guys - don't get me wrong. I'm not sticking up for the PC chap in the suit on the adverts, I'm just putting a point of view across that Macs are not as wonderful as some say.
Fair enough. I have to admit I quite like Apple's OS to MS's, it does more out of the box than Windows. That's not saying it does 'everything' out of the box, but then again I don't know of a OEM who's machine does.


kiwisr

9,335 posts

238 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
I don't have any problems with aMSN and using the webcam.

The benefits of the Mac, to me, are not really the sorts of things you can put in flash ad campaigns. They are quite boring really.

I have 10,000's of documents, pictures, emails, MP3's etc, all instantly findable as well as being able to find anything in the contents immediately through Spotlight. Part of the OS and much faster and more comprehensive than Google desktop.

I never have to wait for it to start-up, from sleep it wakes virtually instantaneously. It never slows down over time, never has to suffer the performance hit of AV scans or spyware programs. It never crashes - ever.

When I had a PC I messed around with all sorts of programs, paid hosting fees and just generally didn't get stuff done. On my Mac (and I did get .Mac) I found that the task of plugging in my camera, having iPhoto download the images, iWeb publish them etc was so automated and easy that I actually got stuff done and was able to show family overseas a decent website. And the apps are incredibly well integrated (iPhoto/iTunes/iWeb/iDVD etc). For example producing a fully authored DVD with a slideshow of images and background music and flash transition can be done in minutes.

Additionally, Office 2004 was always much nicer than Office 2003, a similar thing will occur next year with Office 2008 on the Mac. (you can pick a copy of Office 2004 - Student Edition from the Apple Store for £99)

And the little things like the Widgets, which I use a lot - calculator/currency converter/dictionary etc, or Expose which shows all open windows just make it so fast and nice to use.

And the final thing is Parallels - it is just so fast to run other O/S's like Windows or Solaris - which I need for my job. In fact XP boots faster in Parallels than on any hardware I've ever seen.


pikey

Original Poster:

7,704 posts

315 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
One thing they are very good at (to be fair) is the whole user experience / looking after customers at the store. I got it from Regent Street branch where they were telling me of the amount of personalised help available, which I was impressed at. This is much better than a PC where they take your money and wave goodbye.. but the flip side (if you can call it that) is they try and tie you in for your computer owning life. For someone who's not got a PC, email, webspace, anything I would recommend it as they're more than happy to hold your hand the whole way.



Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
TBH all your "mac issues" to date sound identical to almost every person I've ever seen try and go from PC to mac.

They are different systems, work differently, and it's just not what you are used to.

Put my missus in front of a PC and she makes similar comments, only far, far more frequently - she's only ever used Mac's, they make perfect sense to her, PC's don't.

I started on Mac's, moved to PC's (not through choice I hasten to add) and still think the vast majority of what you do on a PC is easier on a Mac.

pikey

Original Poster:

7,704 posts

315 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
Davi said:
TBH all your "mac issues" to date sound identical to almost every person I've ever seen try and go from PC to mac.
You're missing my point - the "Mac issues" are to do with perception.

My point is the IMAGE that the Mac adverts and Mac community give out is false. At the end of the day, it's not completely seamless and wonderful - as the experience is conditional on too many things.

I have a technical background of support (although many moons ago!) and I can figure it out to make this do what I want to, just like I did when I was playing with a Linux build for fun last month, but the perception sold is that it works "right out of the box" whereas the truth is (if you're non-techie) you're likely to need help.

For example - look at this ad (Click)

As the previous poster said, I'll come back in a month (once I've sorted the bits) and maybe I'll be completely converted? And you know what? I hope that happens as that 24" iMac is a lovely looking piece of kit and I would like one!!


Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
pikey said:
Davi said:
TBH all your "mac issues" to date sound identical to almost every person I've ever seen try and go from PC to mac.
You're missing my point - the "Mac issues" are to do with perception.

My point is the IMAGE that the Mac adverts and Mac community give out is false. At the end of the day, it's not completely seamless and wonderful - as the experience is conditional on too many things.

I have a technical background of support (although many moons ago!) and I can figure it out to make this do what I want to, just like I did when I was playing with a Linux build for fun last month, but the perception sold is that it works "right out of the box" whereas the truth is (if you're non-techie) you're likely to need help.

For example - look at this ad (Click)

As the previous poster said, I'll come back in a month (once I've sorted the bits) and maybe I'll be completely converted? And you know what? I hope that happens as that 24" iMac is a lovely looking piece of kit and I would like one!!
In which case I'm surprised you bought with those perceptions - obviously if you have specific requirements that you wish to tailor to, you will have to have some input - as you say it can't be set up for every eventuality.

In the hands of most people though it will do what they want out the box - usually because what they want is rather more vague and will accept the pre-sets!