This spec ok for video editing?
This spec ok for video editing?
Author
Discussion

MHT223

Original Poster:

198 posts

239 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all

Did quite a bit of video editing on my current pc a couple of years ago but could be a bit slow at times. Looking to upgrade to a new computer and have specced this Dell up...

AMD 64 X2 Dual Core 4400+
2048 RAM 533mhz
320GB 7200rpm Serial ATA 8mb Databurst
256MB ATi X1300 PCI Express Graphics Card
16 x DVD RW Drive
20" Screen
Vista
3yr on site warranty

Never had an AMD processor before, any reason I should stick to Intel? Oh and I'll be using MiniDV tapes.

That comes to £505 inc VAT and delivery

Any thoughts??


ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
More drive space, or rather more disks. Set them to RAID, drat, it's slipped my mind but it's either level 0 or level 1 will give you a slightly improved write speed, which is important when getting the tapes in without frame drops.

Athlon's are pretty perky but the Core 2 Duo has a slightly edge in terms of grunt, you should be fine with an X2, but if the budget will stretch move to the C2D.

Make sure you budget for your software and that the machine either already has the firewire port or you have the PCI card needed for capture.

SS HSV

9,646 posts

289 months

Monday 18th June 2007
quotequote all
MHT223 said:
Did quite a bit of video editing on my current pc a couple of years ago but could be a bit slow at times. Looking to upgrade to a new computer and have specced this Dell up...

AMD 64 X2 Dual Core 4400+
2048 RAM 533mhz
320GB 7200rpm Serial ATA 8mb Databurst
256MB ATi X1300 PCI Express Graphics Card
16 x DVD RW Drive
20" Screen
Vista
3yr on site warranty

Never had an AMD processor before, any reason I should stick to Intel? Oh and I'll be using MiniDV tapes.

That comes to £505 inc VAT and delivery

Any thoughts??
For the price its a lot of PC for the money. Personally I would look for am Intel Core Duo as they are taking the market by storm and you can always upgrade to a faster model or quad-core cpu later when the prices drop. The AMD still offers good price performance here and its a dual core too, so as far as your requirements are, it will do the job. If you decided to go down the Intel route, I would look at running 800Mhz DDR2 as again you will get a noticeable gain in performance through the faster RAM.

I'm not sure I would pick that hard disk - I would go for a 10,000rpm Western Digital Raptor as the performance is noticeable compared to 7200rpm drives. Do Dell give that option? For anything demanding ie games/cad/encoding I always specify these drives as they will save you time. The Intels are back ontop for the time being but AMD gave them a good run for their money recently and there is no reason why they can't do it again.

Also I am not yet convinced with Vista. Microsoft claim that it is faster at encoding video by I am yet to see those results. I have run serveral tests on Vista against XP and I always manage to get XP frames ahead. If you are just running this PC as an editing suite, then I would see if your editing software will run a 64bit OS. If this is the case you can take advantage of running 4gb of memory (or more) and this too will give you a marked improvement. Once your application start paging the hard drive any performance is immediately lost.

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
I'd third the Core 2 Duo thing, try for Conroe if you can, and not Allendale, the extra cache will do wonders for your edit suite!!

MHT223

Original Poster:

198 posts

239 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all

Thanks for all the replys, I'm just off out to work now but I'll look at the options and report back.

Mark

philthy

4,697 posts

271 months

Tuesday 19th June 2007
quotequote all
I'll fourth the intel chip. Paid a grand for the AMD dual core box (a year ago) I'm sat in front of now, and I'm not particularly impressed with the chip. For starters, it seems to have some sort of firewire bug (could just be drivers I know). It does do two thing at once very well, but crunching video is one big app, and it seems to drag it's feet a little.

Oh yeah, more RAM !

MHT223

Original Poster:

198 posts

239 months

Wednesday 20th June 2007
quotequote all
This is the best value Intel package on the Dell site including the Home and Small Business section, mainly because its got free delivery worth £60 till the 28th. Its £630 inc Vat & Del, is it worth the extra £125 over the AMD? This one has 2x250GB HD opposed to 320GB, but a 19" monitor not a 20". Dell don't offer a 10,0000rpm HD.



PROCESSOR Intel® Core™ 2 Duo E6420 Processor (2.13GHz,1066MHz,4MB cache)
OPERATING SYSTEM Genuine Windows Vista™ Home Basic - English
HARDWARE SUPPORT Basic Package, 3 Year On-Site Service
MONITOR Dell™ 19" Silver Wide Flat Panel (SE198WFP)
MEMORY 2048MB 533MHz Dual Channel DDR2 SDRAM [2x1024]
HARD DRIVE 500GB Dual Hard Drive Non RAID (2x250GB - 7200rpm)
GRAPHICS CARD 256MB ATI® Radeon® X1300 Pro PCI Express graphics card
OPTICAL DRIVE 16X DVD+/-RW Drive

UKBSDONL-D06E03A


Mark



Edited by MHT223 on Wednesday 20th June 23:52

Stuart G Gray

7,703 posts

259 months

Thursday 21st June 2007
quotequote all
MHT223 said:
Did quite a bit of video editing on my current pc a couple of years ago but could be a bit slow at times. Looking to upgrade to a new computer and have specced this Dell up...

AMD 64 X2 Dual Core 4400+
2048 RAM 533mhz
320GB 7200rpm Serial ATA 8mb Databurst
256MB ATi X1300 PCI Express Graphics Card
16 x DVD RW Drive
20" Screen
Vista
3yr on site warranty

Never had an AMD processor before, any reason I should stick to Intel? Oh and I'll be using MiniDV tapes.

That comes to £505 inc VAT and delivery

Any thoughts??
I just would not use Dell. Build your own. I was an Intelboy until I built my last one using AMD. I'm impressed so far. MSI K9N SLI (MS-7250 v2) motherboard, 1 gig of DDR2 800 memory, Nvidia 7900GS x2 in SLI, Samsung 250 Gig Sata drivers x2, cost me about £500.

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Thursday 21st June 2007
quotequote all
MHT223 said:
OPERATING SYSTEM Genuine Windows Vista™ Home Basic - English
An interesting coaster there hehe

In short, yes the Core 2 Duo is worth the extra money vs an AMD X2. In all the important areas you mentioned the C2D pulls ahead of the X2. The X2's are no slouch but with vid editing and high end gaming that extra cache memory on the C2D really comes in to its own.

Pigeon

18,535 posts

277 months

Thursday 21st June 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
More drive space, or rather more disks. Set them to RAID, drat, it's slipped my mind but it's either level 0 or level 1 will give you a slightly improved write speed, which is important when getting the tapes in without frame drops.
RAID 0 (striping) for speed. Ideally for sustained high speed write performance you'd want b/w drives where b is the rate at which the drive can transfer data over the bus and w is the speed at which it can actually write it to the magnetic platter, plus one for luck, and the size of each individual stripe no greater than the drive cache size.

RAID 1 is mirroring and it hammers the write speed smile

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Friday 22nd June 2007
quotequote all
Pigeon said:
ThePassenger said:
More drive space, or rather more disks. Set them to RAID, drat, it's slipped my mind but it's either level 0 or level 1 will give you a slightly improved write speed, which is important when getting the tapes in without frame drops.
RAID 0 (striping) for speed. Ideally for sustained high speed write performance you'd want b/w drives where b is the rate at which the drive can transfer data over the bus and w is the speed at which it can actually write it to the magnetic platter, plus one for luck, and the size of each individual stripe no greater than the drive cache size.

RAID 1 is mirroring and it hammers the write speed smile
That's the fella. Thanks Pigeon. For some insane reason I keep thinking RAID 0 is span... I'm either loosing my marbles or going end user. hehe

Using off the shelf cheapo parts, looks like RAID 0+1 would be what I'm working on building ATM; would love to do a RAID 5 / 6 NAS but can't afford the controllers hehe

svenhaas

1 posts

265 months

Friday 22nd June 2007
quotequote all
If your'e still looking at a Dell, www.dmxdimension.com are worth a look
They give you all the current valid discount codes.

SS HSV

9,646 posts

289 months

Friday 22nd June 2007
quotequote all
Pigeon said:
ThePassenger said:
More drive space, or rather more disks. Set them to RAID, drat, it's slipped my mind but it's either level 0 or level 1 will give you a slightly improved write speed, which is important when getting the tapes in without frame drops.
RAID 0 (striping) for speed. Ideally for sustained high speed write performance you'd want b/w drives where b is the rate at which the drive can transfer data over the bus and w is the speed at which it can actually write it to the magnetic platter, plus one for luck, and the size of each individual stripe no greater than the drive cache size.

RAID 1 is mirroring and it hammers the write speed smile
If you are serious about RAID then you should go RAID5 as you speed and redundancy for the price of one extra hard drive.

CommanderJameson

22,096 posts

257 months

Saturday 23rd June 2007
quotequote all
SS HSV said:
Pigeon said:
ThePassenger said:
More drive space, or rather more disks. Set them to RAID, drat, it's slipped my mind but it's either level 0 or level 1 will give you a slightly improved write speed, which is important when getting the tapes in without frame drops.
RAID 0 (striping) for speed. Ideally for sustained high speed write performance you'd want b/w drives where b is the rate at which the drive can transfer data over the bus and w is the speed at which it can actually write it to the magnetic platter, plus one for luck, and the size of each individual stripe no greater than the drive cache size.

RAID 1 is mirroring and it hammers the write speed smile
If you are serious about RAID then you should go RAID5 as you speed and redundancy for the price of one extra hard drive.
RAID 5 stuns the write speed due to the parity calculation. If you need fast RAID, you're better off with RAID 0+1, with the 1 bit done in hardware by the controller.