TV or Monitor ? for pc/ XBOX 360 / PS22
TV or Monitor ? for pc/ XBOX 360 / PS22
Author
Discussion

dtmpower

Original Poster:

3,972 posts

276 months

Saturday 23rd June 2007
quotequote all
I currently play PS2 on the tv and have 2 monitors hooked up to my pc (17inch crt and 17 inch tft)

I am thinking of getting an XBOX 360 and will want to play it in HD.

So do I spend out about £500 and get an HD ready LCD tv ? (with vga/dvi input for pc)

or

Spend the money replacing my monitors with only one larger monitor to use with pc/XBOX 360 etc..

My only concern is the difference in resolutions.

A 26 inch LCD tv seems to have a native resolution of say 1366 x 768, where as a 22 inch monitor can have 1680 x 1050 native... obviously better for the pc part of it. Is the tv resolution OK for working on the pc , emails/web etc. ? Or should I get the monitor and live with a smaller screen for the PS2/ XBOX 360 ?

Anyone ?

Edited by dtmpower on Sunday 24th June 17:05

dtmpower

Original Poster:

3,972 posts

276 months

Sunday 24th June 2007
quotequote all
? >

Altrezia

8,742 posts

242 months

Sunday 24th June 2007
quotequote all
Games for xbox are made for HD tellies, so 1080 pixels high. Get a decent full HD tv or a decent monitor imho. full 1080p is the one to go for, altho £.

dave_s13

14,031 posts

300 months

Sunday 24th June 2007
quotequote all
Can't beleive there's a vast difference, if any, between 1080i/p for Xbox gaming so I wouldn't worry about a non 1080p set.

You can get a Samsung LE26R74BDX for under £400 if you look around (I got one for £380 delivered from Amazon) and then maybe a seperate TFT for the PC?

Buying HD tellies is a bloody nightmare, too much choice. Can highly recommend the above though, Xbox looks stunning, freeview picture is excellent and it has all the inputs you need.

PJ S

10,842 posts

258 months

Sunday 24th June 2007
quotequote all
Forget 1080p - you need to be practically sat on top of the thing to appreciate the extra resolution, plus the SD TV transmissions will look worse as the internal processing has more to do to the signal.
So, under 65" and any more than 5-6 ft from the screen, you'll be wise to spend the money on HD Ready (1366x768) sets.
For decent money - not silly, and not steptoe & son either, look at the Panasonic 26" or 32" LXD70.
Mind you, for not much more, and if you have the room for it, you could do worse than the 37" Plasma PX70 - possibly a better compromise if TV is being watched on it as well. If not, then LXD70.

Edited by PJ S on Sunday 24th June 20:49

robbieduncan

1,993 posts

267 months

Sunday 24th June 2007
quotequote all
I'm going to jump in with the other opinion. I've just got a 40" 1080p Samsung LCD TV. It's attached to a Mac Mini with EyeTV for TV and an XBox 360. The additional resolution & refresh are very noticeable when connected to the Mini Perhaps the XBox would be fine without it, but as I've jumped from and SD TV and the difference is mind blowing. It would be possible to use the TV as a 1920x1080 monitor from a decent distance (say 2-3m).

Having said all that it's blowing the budget: I paid £950.

Altrezia

8,742 posts

242 months

Monday 25th June 2007
quotequote all
robbieduncan said:
I'm going to jump in with the other opinion. I've just got a 40" 1080p Samsung LCD TV. It's attached to a Mac Mini with EyeTV for TV and an XBox 360. The additional resolution & refresh are very noticeable when connected to the Mini Perhaps the XBox would be fine without it, but as I've jumped from and SD TV and the difference is mind blowing. It would be possible to use the TV as a 1920x1080 monitor from a decent distance (say 2-3m).

Having said all that it's blowing the budget: I paid £950.
Snap. Mine is a tosh 1080 screen, and you can really tell the difference between 768 and 1080.

dtmpower

Original Poster:

3,972 posts

276 months

Tuesday 26th June 2007
quotequote all
Think most of you have missed my point - I want a pc sized monitor that I can use a 360 on.... and finding that tv's of 26 inch are same price as some 22 inch monitors. I want to know if a 26 inch tv with its limited resolution would still do the job as a monitor for close written work etc.

dave_s13

14,031 posts

300 months

Tuesday 26th June 2007
quotequote all
dtmpower said:
Think most of you have missed my point - I want a pc sized monitor that I can use a 360 on.... and finding that tv's of 26 inch are same price as some 22 inch monitors. I want to know if a 26 inch tv with its limited resolution would still do the job as a monitor for close written work etc.
I would suggest they would be useable but not great and up close word processing or graphics stuff would be a bit rubbish.

dtmpower

Original Poster:

3,972 posts

276 months

Wednesday 27th June 2007
quotequote all
dave_s13 said:
dtmpower said:
Think most of you have missed my point - I want a pc sized monitor that I can use a 360 on.... and finding that tv's of 26 inch are same price as some 22 inch monitors. I want to know if a 26 inch tv with its limited resolution would still do the job as a monitor for close written work etc.
I would suggest they would be useable but not great and up close word processing or graphics stuff would be a bit rubbish.
As I thought... best to go for the 22inch monitor then use a tv tuner if I want tv on it...

qube_TA

8,405 posts

276 months

Wednesday 27th June 2007
quotequote all
hi res monitor will look lovely just make sure they have enough connectors on to plug everything in at once, swapping cables over is rubbish.

But if the PC is using DVI and the Xbox SVGA it should be nice.

Some nice widescreen Dell/Sony monitors on Ebay that would suit.


dtmpower

Original Poster:

3,972 posts

276 months

Monday 9th July 2007
quotequote all
Deciding now to buy this week:

either

http://www.ebuyer.com/customer/products/index.html...

or

http://www.play.com/PC/PCs/4-/3362511/-/Product.ht...


About the same spec but the LG has analogue tv , both have component and svideo and the LG has scart, what would PH say is the better choice ?

Thanks