HMV digital downloads, DRM?
Author
Discussion

chris watton

Original Poster:

22,552 posts

291 months

Wednesday 27th June 2007
quotequote all
OK, I just want to download a couple of songs from a couple of albums, one being 1979 by the Smashing Pumpkins. I very nearly clicked the 'buy' button, but am afraid that, like the wife's MSM downloads, it'll be DRM enabled, which, I know from experience is more trouble than it's worth.

Has anyone downloaded songs from the HMV website, and more importantly, are they DRM enabled (can't find anything written on their website that confirms or denies!)

If I wanted the whole album, downloading a digitla copy is, on average, £2 more that buying the actual CD hard copy! confused

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Wednesday 27th June 2007
quotequote all
chris watton said:
If I wanted the whole album, downloading a digitla copy is, on average, £2 more that buying the actual CD hard copy! confused
And they wonder why it's not a hugly popular thing.

Anyway, snide attacks on idiots aside, it'll be MS DRM, PlayForSure I think it's called. You can remove it, the tools are available smile Google is your friend and so is Doom9.


chris watton

Original Poster:

22,552 posts

291 months

Wednesday 27th June 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
chris watton said:
If I wanted the whole album, downloading a digitla copy is, on average, £2 more that buying the actual CD hard copy! confused
And they wonder why it's not a hugly popular thing.

Anyway, snide attacks on idiots aside, it'll be MS DRM, PlayForSure I think it's called. You can remove it, the tools are available smile Google is your friend and so is Doom9.
Cheers smile, looks like a little Google searching is in order.
What I fail to understand is, why on earth are the single (79p) tracks more expensive than the equivilent hard copy, and much more restrictive?

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Wednesday 27th June 2007
quotequote all
chris watton said:
What I fail to understand is, why on earth are the single (79p) tracks more expensive than the equivalent hard copy, and much more restrictive?
Politics usually, look at it this way. If you want to kill off a TV program you reschedule it for say... Saturday @ 1am, the ratings drop off, you can turn around saying nobody is watching this and cancel it. Same with music downloads, a lot of people, really don't want it. You've also got the whole price fixing and monopoly thing going on, hence the various incarnations of allofmp3 are wildly popular.

DRM is just there to control you. Again, big companies would love to figure out a method of making you buy (for example) a CD for every player in your house, you buy it once, use it and it somehow locks to that player for the rest of eternity. It also plays a part in vendor lock-in, basically you buy product X, it'll only work with devices Y and Z which are from the same company, so you buy them as well... and you have to keep buying from the same company to keep everything working. A good (if old) example is the .doc format, the only thing that is 100% guaranteed to generate and open it properly is Microsoft Word, so if you've a lot of .doc's in your business you're hypothetically locked in to Microsoft's products (and with the .doc format being so widely used, you're better off with Word than anything else). DRM schemes are the same, you'll notice that none of the various schemes talk to each other.

chris watton

Original Poster:

22,552 posts

291 months

Wednesday 27th June 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
chris watton said:
What I fail to understand is, why on earth are the single (79p) tracks more expensive than the equivalent hard copy, and much more restrictive?
Politics usually, look at it this way. If you want to kill off a TV program you reschedule it for say... Saturday @ 1am, the ratings drop off, you can turn around saying nobody is watching this and cancel it. Same with music downloads, a lot of people, really don't want it. You've also got the whole price fixing and monopoly thing going on, hence the various incarnations of allofmp3 are wildly popular.

DRM is just there to control you. Again, big companies would love to figure out a method of making you buy (for example) a CD for every player in your house, you buy it once, use it and it somehow locks to that player for the rest of eternity. It also plays a part in vendor lock-in, basically you buy product X, it'll only work with devices Y and Z which are from the same company, so you buy them as well... and you have to keep buying from the same company to keep everything working. A good (if old) example is the .doc format, the only thing that is 100% guaranteed to generate and open it properly is Microsoft Word, so if you've a lot of .doc's in your business you're hypothetically locked in to Microsoft's products (and with the .doc format being so widely used, you're better off with Word than anything else). DRM schemes are the same, you'll notice that none of the various schemes talk to each other.
Cheers for that smilesmile

Just ordered the CD off Amazon instead, I am morally opposed to paying for a product that is broken, and paying extra for the 'privilege' of owning (well, part owning) a broken product.

Edited by chris watton on Wednesday 27th June 14:59