Networks for thickos
Author
Discussion

mr_tony

Original Poster:

6,351 posts

300 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
Need some help.
I've recently rejigged my network and I am now in the interesting position whereby all my pc's connect to the web fine through a shared router.

Happily, if I do network neighbourhood, all the PC's recognise each other and display nice blue icons.

Unhappily - none of them can actually access each other, even via something as simple as a ping.

I've tried mapping drives from one to the other, to no avail. The network is adamant that the PC's are there on the network. All of them have shared drives that should be visible, but I'm getting sweet FA.

I've tried disabling the router firewall to no avail already, and uninstalling all firewall software (equally without success).

Anyone know what the issue might be - I've pretty much given up hope of my PC's actually being able ot transfer material to each other!!!

If they couldn't see each other on the network, and I couldn't ping the router I'd know it was dodgy cables etc - but it's not.

Network is 4 PC's connecting wireless / and wired to a 4 port hub connected to cable modem.

All PC's can ping hub.

All PC's can see all other PC's on network. (i.e. icon comes up in NW neighbourhood).

PC's cannot ping other PC's (I've done ipconfig on each machine to determine IP address and pinged from one machine to another with no replies of any kind).

IP addresses being correctly configured by router. (i.e. starting at 192.168.0.1 ascending.

Anyone got any idea?

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
On one PC, turn off the Windows Firewall.
Create a share. Set the properties to 'Everyone'.
Turn on the Guest account.
Create user accounts (WITH A PASSWORD! <- Importance of this can not be overstated for multiple reasons) that match every other machine.

Try now.
If it works turn off guest. Try again. If it works, reestablish the firewall. Try again. If with the system secured your cooking on gas, go around the 4 machines and create user profiles for everyone on each one, remembering to set matching passwords for all.


Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

275 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
Does the router have a route for 192.168.0/24 that points at the ethernet device?

mr_tony

Original Poster:

6,351 posts

300 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
On one PC, turn off the Windows Firewall.
Create a share. Set the properties to 'Everyone'.
Turn on the Guest account.
Create user accounts (WITH A PASSWORD! <- Importance of this can not be overstated for multiple reasons) that match every other machine.

Try now.
If it works turn off guest. Try again. If it works, reestablish the firewall. Try again. If with the system secured your cooking on gas, go around the 4 machines and create user profiles for everyone on each one, remembering to set matching passwords for all.
I removed all firewalls from all machines (while not connected to the web!).

No joy - it's definately not the firewalls causing the issue.


mr_tony

Original Poster:

6,351 posts

300 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
Einion Yrth said:
Does the router have a route for 192.168.0/24 that points at the ethernet device?
No idea what that means (well I understand the words but the ordering leaves me confused!).

Assuming you mean - do the network cards work - yes - all PC'#s in turn have internet access...

ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
mr_tony said:
ThePassenger said:
On one PC, turn off the Windows Firewall.
Create a share. Set the properties to 'Everyone'.
Turn on the Guest account.
Create user accounts (WITH A PASSWORD! <- Importance of this can not be overstated for multiple reasons) that match every other machine.

Try now.
If it works turn off guest. Try again. If it works, reestablish the firewall. Try again. If with the system secured your cooking on gas, go around the 4 machines and create user profiles for everyone on each one, remembering to set matching passwords for all.
I removed all firewalls from all machines (while not connected to the web!).

No joy - it's definately not the firewalls causing the issue.
Tony. Follow everything above. Step 1 is turn it off. If you don't move on to Step 2, you'll be forever in circles.

Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

275 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
mr_tony said:
ThePassenger said:
On one PC, turn off the Windows Firewall.
Create a share. Set the properties to 'Everyone'.
Turn on the Guest account.
Create user accounts (WITH A PASSWORD! <- Importance of this can not be overstated for multiple reasons) that match every other machine.

Try now.
If it works turn off guest. Try again. If it works, reestablish the firewall. Try again. If with the system secured your cooking on gas, go around the 4 machines and create user profiles for everyone on each one, remembering to set matching passwords for all.
I removed all firewalls from all machines (while not connected to the web!).

No joy - it's definately not the firewalls causing the issue.
Tony. Follow everything above. Step 1 is turn it off. If you don't move on to Step 2, you'll be forever in circles.
They're not responding to 'ping'; does the Winblows firewall block ICMP?

mr_tony

Original Poster:

6,351 posts

300 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
Tony. Follow everything above. Step 1 is turn it off. If you don't move on to Step 2, you'll be forever in circles.
I'll try again using Guest - but I have created accounts with matching username password on each machine (at admin level to save fcuking about).

This should be irrelevant for a ping to come back though - surely? This isn't a case of getting an invalid login message etc - there is just no connection.

The machines can 'see' each other (i.e. they display that they exist by creating icons in the network neighbourhood). They must therefore be communicating across the router in order to advertise their existence. Why then will they not respond to a ping?

Machines are :

Desktop - 2002 Win 2000 Adv Server SP II
Laptop - Windows XP Pro
Desktop - 1998 Win 2000 Adv Server SP II

e.g from laptop - pinging Desktop returns nothing.

all 3 connected to internet.

No firewalls (even hardware router firewall turned off).

All ahve identical Administrator username / password.


ThePassenger

6,962 posts

266 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
If the machines don't know they're on a trusted network and are firewalled, or the router is not set up to allow ICMP traffic, they'll often play dumb. Having said that. The fact they can see each other in Network Neighbourhood does suggest they're responding on the usual SMB/WINS requests.

The Griffalo

72,863 posts

270 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
Is it a Vigor router?

mr_tony

Original Poster:

6,351 posts

300 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
ThePassenger said:
If the machines don't know they're on a trusted network and are firewalled, or the router is not set up to allow ICMP traffic, they'll often play dumb. Having said that. The fact they can see each other in Network Neighbourhood does suggest they're responding on the usual SMB/WINS requests.
I've removed ZoneAlarm completely as I assumed that this was causing the issue. Having done so there is no change.

I'm now using the lovely free PCGuard Firewall from Virgin (easy to switch off, less easy to configure in any detail)

If the firewall is off - how would I tell the machines they are on a trusted local network - surely thats the firewalls job to manage that?

The generi host process for WIN32 is happily running in the background, suggesting that it's listening for trafffic, just never seems to get any.


ukwill

10,289 posts

238 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
sounds to me like your router/hub has its own set of security tools and one of those is (by default probably) to block ICMP requests.

The Griffalo

72,863 posts

270 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
The Griffalo said:
Is it a Vigor router?
Laa laa, nobody is listening wink

Onz

507 posts

237 months

Wednesday 4th July 2007
quotequote all
Is File and Printer Sharing turned on as an exception in Windows Firewall on each computer?


mr_tony

Original Poster:

6,351 posts

300 months

Thursday 5th July 2007
quotequote all
ukwill said:
sounds to me like your router/hub has its own set of security tools and one of those is (by default probably) to block ICMP requests.
Bingo!
Poor docs with the hub. Turns out it's got it's own firewall built in that just blocks everything. HAving sorted that one everything is hunky dory, all machine firewalls reimplemented with new rules (note to anyone on Virgin Digital that ping is partially blocked as standard by the PCGuard software they supply).

So at last the network is back to normal and I can print stuff and archive my mp3s smile

I was a software guy by trade, but never been much of a networks person, was convinced I was doing all the right things, but never really had any traning on networks so never really 100% confident that what I'm doing is right.

Thanks all - you've been most helpful.