IE on Vista... calling windoze nerds :D
Discussion
With pretty well all browsers, when you "save web page complete" or whatever they call the option, the definition of "complete" generally falls some way short of the dictionary definition, and certain types of resources are not saved.
As a somewhat poor example, Opera will save javascripts that the page loads but will not save external static resources loaded by those javascripts. Well, it has to stop somewhere or "save page complete" on the wrong page might pull the entire internet in.
My current concern is over the behaviour of Microshaft's latest combination of abominations. If someone saves one of my web pages using IE on Vista, and later tries to view the saved copy offline, what resources might they be missing as a result of deficiencies in "save complete"? External JS? External CSS? Embedded SWF? There must be something, it's a Microshaft product...
OK there isn't any complex code on my website at the moment, but who's to say that will always be the case
TIA...
`
As a somewhat poor example, Opera will save javascripts that the page loads but will not save external static resources loaded by those javascripts. Well, it has to stop somewhere or "save page complete" on the wrong page might pull the entire internet in.

My current concern is over the behaviour of Microshaft's latest combination of abominations. If someone saves one of my web pages using IE on Vista, and later tries to view the saved copy offline, what resources might they be missing as a result of deficiencies in "save complete"? External JS? External CSS? Embedded SWF? There must be something, it's a Microshaft product...
OK there isn't any complex code on my website at the moment, but who's to say that will always be the case

TIA...
`
At a guess, I'd say that any resources that are not saved will still map to their original locations on the internet.
Usually when you save page complete, it creates an additional folder for the resources to go into. The connection between the base html file and the created folder is intimate. So if you try to delete or rename the folder it will complain that the connection will becme broken. This is all reasonable because images, and other data in that folder are referenced by absolute path in the html file, and changing the name or deleting the file results in a discrepancy between the absolute paths that are substitued into the html, and the physical location.
In the circumstance that the browser does not draw a resource from the internet and put it into the folder, then no substitution takes place, and if the basich html file is loaded into the browser, the information will be queried from the internet, should the connection be available.
I think it's reasonable to assume that embedded (DHTML style) scripts will carry across. I'd have thought that external CSS would too. Having said that, I just saved this thread, and something was missing because the title bar dissapeared visually but the links were still there. Beyond that I think that you can only really assume images, and possibly, wmf sound files.
In general I'd guess it's about proprietary formats, so I'm guessing that Java, and shockwave wouldn't make it, where ActiveX probably would.
Usually when you save page complete, it creates an additional folder for the resources to go into. The connection between the base html file and the created folder is intimate. So if you try to delete or rename the folder it will complain that the connection will becme broken. This is all reasonable because images, and other data in that folder are referenced by absolute path in the html file, and changing the name or deleting the file results in a discrepancy between the absolute paths that are substitued into the html, and the physical location.
In the circumstance that the browser does not draw a resource from the internet and put it into the folder, then no substitution takes place, and if the basich html file is loaded into the browser, the information will be queried from the internet, should the connection be available.
I think it's reasonable to assume that embedded (DHTML style) scripts will carry across. I'd have thought that external CSS would too. Having said that, I just saved this thread, and something was missing because the title bar dissapeared visually but the links were still there. Beyond that I think that you can only really assume images, and possibly, wmf sound files.
In general I'd guess it's about proprietary formats, so I'm guessing that Java, and shockwave wouldn't make it, where ActiveX probably would.
Edited by dilbert on Saturday 14th July 16:59
dilbert said:
At a guess, I'd say that any resources that are not saved will still map to their original locations on the internet.
Yes, that is the behaviour I too expect...dilbert said:
Usually when you save page complete, it creates an additional folder for the resources to go into. The connection between the base html file and the created folder is intimate. So if you try to delete or rename the folder it will complain that the connection will becme broken. This is all reasonable because images, and other data in that folder are referenced by absolute path in the html file, and changing the name or deleting the file results in a discrepancy between the absolute paths that are substitued into the html, and the physical location.
You mean the OS itself recognises that the folder is connected to the html file and moans if you delete/rename it, not just that the browser throws the expected wobbly?dilbert said:
In the circumstance that the browser does not draw a resource from the internet and put it into the folder, then no substitution takes place, and if the basich html file is loaded into the browser, the information will be queried from the internet, should the connection be available.
Yeah, I wouldn't expect it to save conditionally-loaded resources when the condition was false, attempt to reload anything that didn't load successfully in the first place, or anything like that.dilbert said:
I think it's reasonable to assume that embedded (DHTML style) scripts will carry across. I'd have thought that external CSS would too. Having said that, I just saved this thread, and something was missing because the title bar dissapeared visually but the links were still there.
As in, you could no longer read "PistonHeads > Gassing Station > The Pie & Piston > IE on Vista... calling windoze nerds
"? That might imply something important about its behaviour with CSS; I'll have to bypass my proxy that rewrites the
out of PH and see if I can work out what.dilbert said:
Beyond that I think that you can only really assume images, and possibly, wmf sound files.
In general I'd guess it's about proprietary formats, so I'm guessing that Java, and shockwave wouldn't make it, where ActiveX probably would.
Hmm. Other people's proprietary formats... which are the cross-platform ones. I could well see that I might at some point find a reason to put Java on my website, and despite my views on flash I can't entirely rule out the possibility of wanting to use that ever... ActiveX however would not be there. I get a lot of hits from Linux and Mac users...In general I'd guess it's about proprietary formats, so I'm guessing that Java, and shockwave wouldn't make it, where ActiveX probably would.
What I really need is a tame Vista user
I have a tame XP user, I guess "IE 7.0" is of more significance than "NT 6.0" so I'm not totally unable to experiment.Yep that's the one. The O.S. connects the saved resource folder, and the saved HTML file.
TBH, I'm not on Vista, but I am on IE7. I think I'm viewing Vista as being "something different" rather than the "next version" at the moment. We'll see.
That thing with the CSS, you could well be right. I'm thinking, as a result of my quick experiment, that external CSS may not make it. Although it may just be that the formatting of the save function wasn't up to scratch, because when I tested that page with and without the internet connected, the shockwave ad was present and blank, as you would expect, but the title bar was in a whiteout condition both times.
IE is pretty fussy when it comes to the physical layout of the HTML. In the main this is because their HTML parser is line based, and not tag based, I think. It makes it faster, but not perhaps as easy to talk to.
When you ask IE to produce HTML (source view or save as HTML) it's results are not consistent. It is laid out, but not that coherently. In all cases it ought to produce HTML which will render correctly in IE, but that's not always what you're after, if in fact thats what it does.
I don't think that the Vista thing will make much difference. Windows O.S. only offers a native XML parser, the SGML/HTML parser comes with IE, so it's the IE thing that will matter most.
The connection of the resource folder and the HTML file is O.S. specific, and although used by IE, is a generic capability within the OS - I think.
Further edit;
I had a look in the resource folder, and it contains .JS, and .CSS, so they *should* work, but the practicality may differ!!!!

TBH, I'm not on Vista, but I am on IE7. I think I'm viewing Vista as being "something different" rather than the "next version" at the moment. We'll see.
That thing with the CSS, you could well be right. I'm thinking, as a result of my quick experiment, that external CSS may not make it. Although it may just be that the formatting of the save function wasn't up to scratch, because when I tested that page with and without the internet connected, the shockwave ad was present and blank, as you would expect, but the title bar was in a whiteout condition both times.
IE is pretty fussy when it comes to the physical layout of the HTML. In the main this is because their HTML parser is line based, and not tag based, I think. It makes it faster, but not perhaps as easy to talk to.
When you ask IE to produce HTML (source view or save as HTML) it's results are not consistent. It is laid out, but not that coherently. In all cases it ought to produce HTML which will render correctly in IE, but that's not always what you're after, if in fact thats what it does.
I don't think that the Vista thing will make much difference. Windows O.S. only offers a native XML parser, the SGML/HTML parser comes with IE, so it's the IE thing that will matter most.
The connection of the resource folder and the HTML file is O.S. specific, and although used by IE, is a generic capability within the OS - I think.
Further edit;
I had a look in the resource folder, and it contains .JS, and .CSS, so they *should* work, but the practicality may differ!!!!

Edited by dilbert on Saturday 14th July 17:57
Gassing Station | Computers, Gadgets & Stuff | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


