Spending money on a monitor
Author
Discussion

trooperiziz

Original Poster:

9,457 posts

283 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
I don't know why I do this, but whenever I buy a pc, I go for the best I can get for my budget. Then upgrade carefully as time goes on, always looking for bang-for-buck. The buy the cheapest monitor I can get at the size I want.

I realised that considering my interface to the pc is the monitor and I will be looking at it every single time I use my pc, it's probably a good idea to get something good enough to go with the rest of the system.

So, with that in mind i've ordered a 24" Dell Ultrasharp for the princely sum of £430. As i usually only spend about £130 on a monitor it's a slight step up!

Roll on the weekend, is it crazy to get excited about a new monitor?


NickFRP

5,156 posts

266 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
Hell NO.. id be excited

Bet its the MUTS NUTS. its nearly as bits as my 32" TV lol

but £420 thats alot of wonger. think of how big your desktop could be. hmmm how good films and games will be.




rich1231

17,340 posts

291 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
trooperiziz said:
I don't know why I do this, but whenever I buy a pc, I go for the best I can get for my budget. Then upgrade carefully as time goes on, always looking for bang-for-buck. The buy the cheapest monitor I can get at the size I want.

I realised that considering my interface to the pc is the monitor and I will be looking at it every single time I use my pc, it's probably a good idea to get something good enough to go with the rest of the system.

So, with that in mind i've ordered a 24" Dell Ultrasharp for the princely sum of £430. As i usually only spend about £130 on a monitor it's a slight step up!

Roll on the weekend, is it crazy to get excited about a new monitor?
you will love it... just ignore the 27" and 30" versions now

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
AFAIAC the monitor is the single most important part of the computer experience - blurry CRTs, dead pixels on LCDs, etc. Absolutely essential to have a screen your eyes are comfortable with.

Regarding 'ultrasharp' - make sure that high resolution LCDs are OK with your eyes. If native resolution text is too sharp to read comfortably at your normal working distance, then the resolution is too high. Of course, changing the resolution on an LCD monitor results in blocky, aliased horribleness.

My monitor setup is obscene really but it's incredibly comfortable and I never run out of space or have to squint to see the screen. Also, due to the points-per-inch being the same as most printer setups, a visual preview of a document pretty much matches the printed document in size.

So to answer the original question... my monitors cost nearly as much as the computer.

However - buy wisely and they will last a LONG time. I paid silly money (£2500) for an 18" Eizo L675 back when only traders in banks had LCDs because there was no space for a CRT in my tiny house, and I needed to run a computer with decent resolution (1280x1024). The Eizo was solidly built, had no dead pixels, and is still running like a champ more than 6 years later. Your computer is unlikely to last this long unless it's a Mac. So ensure you're happy with the screen, and that it has a variety of inputs (today, DVI essential, HDMI just in case the movie studios get their way with encryption, and VGA for retro kit).

trooperiziz

Original Poster:

9,457 posts

283 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
rich1231 said:
trooperiziz said:
I don't know why I do this, but whenever I buy a pc, I go for the best I can get for my budget. Then upgrade carefully as time goes on, always looking for bang-for-buck. The buy the cheapest monitor I can get at the size I want.

I realised that considering my interface to the pc is the monitor and I will be looking at it every single time I use my pc, it's probably a good idea to get something good enough to go with the rest of the system.

So, with that in mind i've ordered a 24" Dell Ultrasharp for the princely sum of £430. As i usually only spend about £130 on a monitor it's a slight step up!

Roll on the weekend, is it crazy to get excited about a new monitor?
you will love it... just ignore the 27" and 30" versions now
I did look at them, but the 27" is the same resolution for a lot more money, and the 30" would probably cause my graphics card to crumble...

Graphics cards and processors will come and go but I'm guessing that the Dell will be with me for a long time, my current 2 monitor setup has been with me for 3 years now, my monitor before that was about 8 years old I think!


Marki

15,763 posts

301 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
hehe i just brought a 22" Packard Bell TFT hehe it cost 200 Euros inc VAT hehe

Its great being in the trade biggrin

trooperiziz

Original Poster:

9,457 posts

283 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
cyberface said:
Regarding 'ultrasharp' - make sure that high resolution LCDs are OK with your eyes. If native resolution text is too sharp to read comfortably at your normal working distance, then the resolution is too high. Of course, changing the resolution on an LCD monitor results in blocky, aliased horribleness.
It's 1920*1200 resolution, which shouldn't be too tiring in a 24" display and i like high reolution. But luckily my eyes are already screwed, so it doesn't matter if I screw them a bit more wink

trooperiziz

Original Poster:

9,457 posts

283 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
Marki said:
hehe i just brought a 22" Packard Bell TFT hehe it cost 200 Euros inc VAT hehe

Its great being in the trade biggrin
I could have got a 22" for a lot less money, but didn't want to live with the shame and inferiority complex that would come with wink

Marki

15,763 posts

301 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
trooperiziz said:
Marki said:
hehe i just brought a 22" Packard Bell TFT hehe it cost 200 Euros inc VAT hehe

Its great being in the trade biggrin
I could have got a 22" for a lot less money, but didn't want to live with the shame and inferiority complex that would come with wink
hehe

mike_e

595 posts

294 months

Tuesday 17th July 2007
quotequote all
We use these monitors, great pieces of kit, you'll be very pleased I'm sure. Multiple input sources, card readers, USB ports and good image quality.

They do seem to produce better results running at their max resolution of 1920 x 1080. Image quality at lower resolutions isn't the best.

VictorMeldrew

8,293 posts

308 months

Sunday 22nd July 2007
quotequote all
rich1231 said:
trooperiziz said:
I don't know why I do this, but whenever I buy a pc, I go for the best I can get for my budget. Then upgrade carefully as time goes on, always looking for bang-for-buck. The buy the cheapest monitor I can get at the size I want.

I realised that considering my interface to the pc is the monitor and I will be looking at it every single time I use my pc, it's probably a good idea to get something good enough to go with the rest of the system.

So, with that in mind i've ordered a 24" Dell Ultrasharp for the princely sum of £430. As i usually only spend about £130 on a monitor it's a slight step up!

Roll on the weekend, is it crazy to get excited about a new monitor?
you will love it... just ignore the 27" and 30" versions now
I have the 2407FPW. To be honest it's too big for desktop use - unless you have a very deep desk. You end up with tennis spectator neck syndrome - you just can't take in the whole screen without excessive neck movements. The 24" wasn't available when I got mine; I wish it had been.

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Sunday 22nd July 2007
quotequote all
Eh? I've got two 30" apple LCDs, yes I have to move my neck a little bit to go from the far edge of one screen to the far edge of the other, but they're sure as hell not too big for desktop use.

And my desk is about 2 foot deep, not a monster setup. There's a pic of my silly Mac setup on one of the threads here IIRC.

I'd say go for the biggest, highest quality screen you can afford - with one caveat, that the DPI is OK with your eyes at the normal distance you work from. High quality kit lasts longer, your screen will last many generations beyond your computer if you upgrade reasonably regularly (I'm an early-adopter nutter and still have a 6-year old LCD Eizo screen working like a champ).

My Apple screens will be replaced when they die, simple as that. It's already like the Matrix in here, won't be needing more screen real estate... smile

VictorMeldrew

8,293 posts

308 months

Sunday 22nd July 2007
quotequote all
Maybe you don't sit through 20 hour sessions day in day out like I do!

I have a 20" TFT alongside, and a 17" lappie the other side, and spread my desktop across all three.

I suppose either, or both, the above could actually be the problem!



Edited by VictorMeldrew on Sunday 22 July 22:09

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Sunday 22nd July 2007
quotequote all
VictorMeldrew said:
Maybe you don't sit through 20 hour sessions day in day out like I do!

I have a 20" TFT alongside, and a 17" lappie the other side, and spread my desktop across all three.

I suppose either, or both, the above could actually be the problem!



Edited by VictorMeldrew on Sunday 22 July 22:09
20 hours a day, no. I can't survive on less than 4 hours sleep (there's no way I can finish on the computer and be asleep one minute later, nor wake up and immediately be working (that'd be poor personal hygiene anyway...) so 20 hour sessions would realistically be 3 hours sleep max. I'd die.

However I *do* spend easily 15 hours at a stretch with my current setup and it's great.

Remember both my monitors are the same size, so it's like one very wide screen. I also have the Eizo 18" but that's just for the servers, and the 17" Apple studio display which just has the Server Monitor app running on it. Main work is done on the two identical screens.

Perhaps your three different sizes (and presumably DPI as well) make it harder especially if you're using apps that spread windows / toolboxes / palettes across multiple monitors?

IME one big one beats two little ones, and two big ones beats virtually anything else. And I've worked with the guys at Bloomberg with the 9 18" LCDs in a 3x3 matrix...

VictorMeldrew

8,293 posts

308 months

Monday 23rd July 2007
quotequote all
I can get away with 3 hours sleep for a few days, but then I start to suffer. Had to work through a few weeks ago and then on till 8pm the next day, 38 hours straight.

I have a 2407 and a 2007 at 1920x1200 and 1600x1200, with the notebook at 1680x1050 as its too much strain as 1900x1200. The 2407 and 2007 are fairly closely matched, with the 2407 about 1/2" taller.

The two 30" screens must be pretty awesome - how do you ever find the mouse?!

cyberface

12,214 posts

288 months

Monday 23rd July 2007
quotequote all
VictorMeldrew said:
I can get away with 3 hours sleep for a few days, but then I start to suffer. Had to work through a few weeks ago and then on till 8pm the next day, 38 hours straight.

I have a 2407 and a 2007 at 1920x1200 and 1600x1200, with the notebook at 1680x1050 as its too much strain as 1900x1200. The 2407 and 2007 are fairly closely matched, with the 2407 about 1/2" taller.

The two 30" screens must be pretty awesome - how do you ever find the mouse?!
That sort of work schedule is impossible without drugs. You may 'get through it' but your performance will be severely impacted (compared to your peak performance with normal sleep). 38 hours without sleep is deprivation and not only will performance suffer but it's dangerous to your health. If you have to work shifts like that then get some modafinil and make the sleep up at the weekends. Sorry if that sounds like I'm lecturing, but man that's unhealthy frown

Sounds like the two main screens should be OK - you've got the same vertical resolution but the DPI will be different, there'll be some 'squeezing' when your eyes go from one screen to the other. The laptop screen... well if it's a 17" screen capable of native 1900x1200 then it's ridiculously high resolution and in the absence of a resolution-independent UI (Apple will have it in Leopard, not sure where Windows is on this front) then that screen will be a killer on your eyes, especially buttons and other bitmapped interface items. I hate running LCDs at anything other than native resolution, since I find it really hard on the eyes (even an easy half resolution, with 4 pixels for each normal pixel, looks blocky and the OS's antialiasing looks awful).

The two 30" screens are 2560x1600 each, so yeah - my mouse can be a bit glitchy at times and throw the cursor well away from where it was (odd) and I have to wiggle it around until I can find it, but OS X has 'hot corner' functionality so if the cursor gets lost then I can just move to bottom left and the screen saver will kick in...

roadsweeper

3,790 posts

305 months

Monday 23rd July 2007
quotequote all
trooperiziz said:
24" Dell Ultrasharp
Great choice. thumbup

We have 3 of them here and they are utterly fantastic. They were also recently voted quite highly in a magazine's top 100 technology products of the year too. smile

I wouldn't bother with the 27" monitor myself as there is no increase in resolution, but the 30" is a tempter I must admit! hehe However, it probably makes more sense just to buy another 24" screen as the price drops and run a dual screen setup. smile

JonRB

80,233 posts

303 months

Monday 23rd July 2007
quotequote all
roadsweeper said:
trooperiziz said:
24" Dell Ultrasharp
Great choice. thumbup
Indeed - I have one myself. 1920x1200 native res and a really good pic. I run it and the corresponding normal aspect 21" (1600x1200) next to it in a dual monitor setup.

JonRB

80,233 posts

303 months

Monday 23rd July 2007
quotequote all
VictorMeldrew said:
I have the 2407FPW. To be honest it's too big for desktop use - unless you have a very deep desk. You end up with tennis spectator neck syndrome - you just can't take in the whole screen without excessive neck movements. The 24" wasn't available when I got mine; I wish it had been.
Errr, the 2407 is the 24", hence the '24' in the 2407.

Road2Ruin

6,571 posts

247 months

Monday 23rd July 2007
quotequote all
Check out ebuyer.co.uk there are so many good 22" monitors around now for under £200 and can even get a reasonable one for under £180! Could have got two 22" monitors for less than £430 and run them next to each other.